THE difference of opinion expressed by Attorney General Tan Sri Mohd Dusuki Mokhtar and Federal Territories Minister Hannah Yeoh in the Federal Territories Pardons Board regarding house arrest for former Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak cannot be interpreted as an act of treason toward the royal institution.
Syariah lawyer Datuk Zainul Rijal Abu Bakar stated in a Facebook post that expressing disagreement with a proposal is part of their responsibility as members of the board.
"They were invited by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong (YDPA) to provide their views.
"Therefore, expressing a differing view, including disagreeing with a proposal, is part of their responsibility as board members; it does not constitute an act of defiance or disloyalty toward the royal institution," he stated in the post.
At the same time, Zainul, an adviser to the Malaysian Muslim Lawyers Association noted that the power of pardon is a prerogative of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, as provided for under the Federal Constitution.
"Based on legal principles and relevant court judgments, this power is not necessarily bound by the majority decision or the votes of the Pardons Board members.
"While the views of board members must be taken into account, the final decision on the exercise of the power of pardon rests within the prerogative of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong.
"Furthermore, the exercise of this prerogative power touches upon the principle of 'non-justiciability' which limits the extent to which the courts can intervene in matters concerning the discretion to grant a pardon," he explained.
He was commenting on the objections raised by Mohd Dusuki and Hannah regarding the implementation of house arrest for Najib, as revealed in the declassified minutes of the Pardons Board meeting.
Several pages from the meeting minutes were shared by former DAP Member of Parliament Tony Pua on his Facebook account; among other things, they record the stance taken by the Attorney General on the matter.
According to the minutes, Mohd Dusuki maintained the view, consistent with his position in previous meetings that the former prime minister should continue serving his prison sentence until 2028.
He pointed out that 'house arrest' is not provided for under existing law; it is a concept foreign to our national legal system, a point previously affirmed by High Court Judge Alice Loke.
He further noted that such a decision would have repercussions for the government, specifically affecting political stability, the economy, investment, and the nation's international image.
The minutes also indicate that Hannah expressed a view similar with that of Mohd Dusuki, as well as with the position she had taken in previous meetings. – November19, 2026