Murray Hunter
MYANMAR is guilty of genocide against the Rohingya people. We all knew that, but now it’s official. This sets a very powerful legal precedent.
Overnight, the International Court of Justice ruled that “the Republic of the Union of Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya,” Court President Yuji Iwasawa declared.
The finding, delivered by a 9-6 majority after a seven-year case brought by The Gambia, marks the first time the World Court has held a state directly responsible for genocide.
Judges concluded that the “only reasonable inference” from the evidence was genocidal intent: the goal was to destroy a substantial portion of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State.
The ruling encompasses the forced expulsion and razing of villages, widespread sexual violence against women and girls, killings of thousands (adopting the UN figure of at least 10,000), extreme violence against children, and attacks on those fleeing to Bangladesh in 2017. Both the military and the then-civilian government under Aung San Suu Kyi denied genocidal intent.
The evidence presented, and now the court’s judgment, says otherwise.
Directly below reports of the verdict sit images of Rohingya boys in a crowd of refugees in Cox’s Bazar, celebrating. Many of them can barely have been born before the escalation of atrocities in 2017.
To be so young, so far from home, and cheering as the world finally acknowledges that their people were victims of genocide is profoundly moving.
For the nearly two million who fled and those still languishing in camps, this is vindication.
As Rohingya writer Lucky Karim put it, it offers “a moment of vindication and solace… For many of us, this is the most important day of our lives.”
In The Gambia, the government rightly called it a day of “profound satisfaction” and “a historic day for international justice.”
The judgment cannot be appealed. It stands.
Myanmar in 2026 is not the Myanmar of 2017.
Aung San Suu Kyi’s democratic credentials collapsed under the weight of her government’s role.
The 2021 coup installed military rule that has since evolved into a contested, conflict-ridden landscape under Min Aung Hlaing’s leadership.
Early hopes that other ethnic groups would fully embrace solidarity with the Rohingya, recognising that what happened to them could happen to anyone, have faded amid the grinding civil war.
The military will not hold itself to account. Meaningful enforcement remains difficult.
What the ruling does demand is immediate, practical action from host countries.
Malaysia, which hosts roughly 190,000–200,000 registered Myanmar refugees and asylum-seekers (the large majority Rohingya), has been pursuing repatriations.
In recent months, it has returned thousands of Myanmar nationals, including in coordinated operations with Myanmar authorities involving naval vessels, amid domestic political pressure and public hostility toward refugees.
Officials have described the returns as voluntary and claimed safeguards, yet UNHCR and rights groups have warned that conditions for safe, dignified, and voluntary return do not exist.
Myanmar remains unsafe; Rakhine State is contested and dangerous; Rohingya continue to face systemic discrimination and lack of citizenship.
Non-refoulement—the principle that no one should be returned to a place where they face serious threats to life or freedom—is a cornerstone of refugee protection and customary international law.
Sending people back to a state newly adjudged guilty of genocide against their ethnic group, under a leadership that oversaw or continues to dominate the security apparatus responsible, violates both the spirit and the letter of that obligation.
Even if some returnees are not Rohingya, the broader pattern of persecution, conflict, and state failure in Myanmar makes large-scale returns reckless.
Claims of “voluntary” consent ring hollow when people are held in detention centres, barred from independent UNHCR screening in some cases, and facing limited alternatives.
Malaysia is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, but that does not exempt it from fundamental humanitarian duties or from the moral weight of the ICJ’s determination. Increasing support for Rohingya communities in Malaysia and Bangladesh—through better protection, education, livelihoods, and international burden-sharing—is the responsible path.
Pressuring for accountability, safe conditions for eventual voluntary returns with full rights restoration, and genuine political change in Myanmar is necessary.
Handing people back to the perpetrators’ state is not.
The boys cheering in Cox’s Bazar point the way.
For their grandmother’s generation, waves of violence against the Rohingya were a grim fact of life.
These children have had their lives shaped by the same state violence, but they will grow up in a world that has officially named it genocide.
Malaysia should honour that recognition. Halt the repatriations. Protect those who fled.
Anything less abandons the very principle the ICJ has just affirmed. – November 21, 2026