BOTH political parties failed to win a single state seat, with Bersama losing 15 candidates' deposits and Bersatu five, raising questions about their grassroots strength and electoral prospects.
Bersama and Bersatu emerged from the Melaka state election without a single seat, raising questions about their ability to translate their political ambitions into meaningful electoral support.
Bersama, the party associated with former PKR deputy president Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli, contested 16 seats but failed to secure a victory.
Its candidate in Bemban, Dr Muhammad Solehin Saleh, was the only one to retain his election deposit after polling 4,140 votes.
The remaining 15 candidates forfeited their deposits.
Bersatu also failed to make inroads, losing all seven seats it contested. Its candidates in Lendu and Pantai Kundor retained their deposits, while the other five lost theirs.
The results have drawn criticism on social media, particularly towards Bersama, with some users questioning whether the party has a future following its disappointing performance.
Several Facebook users called for the party to be disbanded. Razlam Mamat, for instance, offered a blunt assessment, writing: “Just disband it.”
Another user, Melan Zubir Bin Saaudi, also called for Bersama to be dissolved, directing criticism at Rafizi over the party’s showing.
Others, however, argued that the party should not be written off after its electoral setback.
Facebook user Alen Kean Rc said Bersama was still new and needed time to establish itself, describing electoral defeat as part of the process of building a political organisation.
He also claimed the party had limited financial resources and lacked the influential figures and major donors available to more established political parties.
Another commenter, Jali Baran, argued that losing seats and election deposits should not be the sole measure of a party’s prospects, saying some supporters had used their own money to help fund its campaign.
Julius Casablanca similarly urged Bersama to continue contesting future elections, pointing out that established parties had also experienced defeats before building their political strength.
The criticism also extended to Rafizi’s political direction, with another user, Ijau Lelayang, questioning his move away from PKR and his subsequent involvement in Bersama.
For Bersatu, the defeat raises a different set of questions about its standing in Melaka and its ability to rebuild support after failing to secure representation in the state assembly.
The results leave both parties with considerable ground to make up, particularly against established political organisations with stronger grassroots networks and longer-standing support bases.
For Bersama, the immediate challenge is to establish an identity and political following beyond its association with Rafizi.
Bersatu, meanwhile, will have to contend with the implications of drawing a blank in all seven constituencies it contested.
Whether the Melaka results prompt either party to rethink its approach will depend on the decisions of their respective leaderships. For now, both leave the election without a seat in the state assembly. - November 16, 2026