Malaysia

MBPJ impounding bicycles raises questions over green city plan

Cyclists slapped with steep fines, while motorcycles taking their spots remain untouched

Updated 2 years ago · Published on 28 May 2023 3:25PM

MBPJ impounding bicycles raises questions over green city plan
Petaling Jaya’s aspiration to be a bicycle-friendly city is questioned as motorcyclists occupy designated bicycle parking areas, forcing cyclists to park illegally, leading to their being fined by the authorities. – Pic courtesy of Justin Lee Kah Wai, May 28, 2023

by Shahrim Tamrin

KUALA LUMPUR – Petaling Jaya’s aspiration to become a low-carbon green city and improve connectivity is being questioned in the wake of parked bicycles being confiscated close to train stations.

The cycling community is stunned to discover that two cyclists were slapped with a RM250 fine each by the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) for parking illegally across the Taman Bahagia LRT station on April 27, and had to pay the fine to recover their bicycles after being impounded.

According to the duo, they were forced to park at the guard railing beside the public car park after the bicycle parking spots at the train station were fully occupied by motorcycles.

“I had to park my bicycle in another area since motorcyclists took the (bicycle parking) spots. 

“I locked the bicycle onto a fence before I took the LRT to work,” said Bike Commute Malaysia initiative director Justin Lee Kah Wai.

As a regular public transport commuter using a bicycle for his 2km daily journey from home to the LRT station on weekdays, the architectural design lecturer was shocked to learn that his bicycle parked at Jalan SS2/3 was missing.

“After I disembarked from the train at around 10pm, my bicycle was nowhere to be seen. It’s obvious the bicycle U-lock, which cost me RM200, had been hacked,” he lamented.

Thinking that the green vehicle might be stolen, he lodged a police report and continued his search around the area for the next 48 hours.

“I returned to the site for two consecutive days, and two witnesses claimed that they saw enforcement officers loading two bicycles onto an MBPJ lorry,” he said, adding that he had also placed a poster at the location offering a RM1,000 reward for its return.

After a five-day frantic search, Justin received confirmation that his bicycle was stored at MBPJ’s Innovation Centre in Kota Damansara.

“However, I could only pick up the bicycle after the seven-day withholding period was over,” he said.

He was informed that he had committed an offence under Section 43 (3) (9) of the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974.

The 33-year-old had to endure the bureaucratic process of recovering the bicycle with a RM10 cost for a letter of oath and paying RM53 in addition to the RM250 compound issued under Act 133.

Bike Commute Malaysia initiative director Justin Lee Kah Wai says he placed a poster offering a RM1,000 reward for the return of his bicycle, unaware that it was impounded by the Petaling Jaya City Council. – Pic courtesy of Justin Lee Kah Wai, May 28, 2023
Bike Commute Malaysia initiative director Justin Lee Kah Wai says he placed a poster offering a RM1,000 reward for the return of his bicycle, unaware that it was impounded by the Petaling Jaya City Council. – Pic courtesy of Justin Lee Kah Wai, May 28, 2023

Other than the inadequate cycling facilities in cities and township areas, Justin said the bicycle parking spots at train stations in the Klang Valley are often obstructed by motorcycles.

“The area is also poorly lit, making it unsafe to retrieve my bicycle at night. There have also been cases of theft in the area. On several occasions, I even found human faeces and vomit at the site, making the location unsanitary.”

He also lamented that other than the constant fear of bicycle thieves, cyclists also fear that the authorities will take (impound) their bicycles.”

The other bicycle owner, who declined to be named, said he was not considering recovering his bicycle.

“RM300 (cost to recover) is too much for that bicycle, so I’ll have to write it off. They can give it to the orphanage. I am still unhappy about the lock since they (MBPJ) are also essentially destroying our property,” the owner bemoaned.

Reacting to the news, the Klang Valley cycling community expressed dismay with what they described as a huge setback for commuters who want to adopt micro-mobility as a low-carbon transport mode.

“Despite claims by MBPJ to promote a low-carbon lifestyle, these challenges make it difficult for individuals to adopt cycling as a means of commuting.

“This is ridiculous from the officers. Please review and monitor the bicycle parking and ridiculous summons, and provide and encourage green mobility in the future. 

“Please progress or recruit green mobility project consultants to provide support,” suggests Lor Philip.

Another bicycle enthusiast who wished to remain anonymous said the authorities should have taken steps to encourage and promote bicycles as transportation options.

“This action (of impounding bicycles) aims to discourage and harass bicycle usage,” noted Peng Au-Yong.

At press time, The Vibes had sought clarifications from MBPJ. – The Vibes, May 28, 2023

Related News

Malaysia / 5mth

Lee Chean Chung skipped 30 critical planning sessions - says PKR

Malaysia / 2y

MBPJ inspects more high-risk trees after storm causes more uprootings

Malaysia / 3y

New lease of life for landowners still within reach: PJ local councillor

Opinion / 3y

Why remove video of MBPJ’s full board meeting? – PJ residents

Opinion / 3y

PJ councillors’ walkout: urgent investigation needed for KUB/A&W plot ratio fiasco – Michael Kum

3y

Time for local councils to revise dog-catching procedures: Young Syefura

Spotlight

Malaysia

Papagomo acquitted for second time in sedition case over government, Israel claims

Malaysia

ECRL fares start at RM60, with 50% discounts for children, seniors and OKU

Malaysia

DKU seeks court action against Ismail, 16 others over Negeri Sembilan royal dispute

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Kampung Manis: Dreams of 227 families to own replacement homes draw closer

Malaysia

Fadhlina takes legal action over video of 2023 Parliament speech

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Civil servants urged to turn Selangor Sultan’s anti-graft message into action

Malaysia

Animal welfare group urges probe into alleged sexual abuse of cat in viral video

Malaysia

Macron appeals for calm after France riots: 2,400 arrested, nearly 1,000 officers injured

Malaysia

Malaysia renews offer to help Indonesia fight fires

You may be interested

Malaysia

Woman remanded for four days over discovery of headless baby’s body in Terengganu

Malaysia

Father, daughter killed after container crushes car in Sabah

Malaysia

MCMC warns cyberbullies, AI disinformation offenders as online safety comes under scrutiny

Malaysia

Malaysia must win trust of both sides to move Southern Thailand peace process forward

Malaysia

Over 300 schoolgirls may be victims of AI-edited nude images, lawyer says

Malaysia

Budget 2027 expands tax relief, fuel and electricity subsidies for M40 households

Malaysia

DAP lawmakers’ risk being dropped as party tightens KPI checks ahead of GE16

Malaysia

King appoints three Malaysian envoys to Canada, Belgium and Iran