Malaysia

Najib's house arrest claim puts government in a bind

Anwar administration must decide between defying the king and placating the people.

Updated 1 month ago · Published on 05 Apr 2024 11:54AM

Najib's house arrest claim puts government in a bind
Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah is alleged to have issued an order for Datuk Najib Razak to serve the serve the rest of his jail term at home instead of Kajang Prison. – Twitter pic, April 5, 2024.

THE Pardons Board did not discuss allowing former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak to serve his jail term at home when it met on January 29, unnamed government officials told Channel NewsAsia.

The sources said the matter was not brought up by the six-member board when it ruled on Najib’s  pardon application.

The CNA report said Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri'ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah, then king and chairman of the Pardons Board, had issued a supplementary order for Najib’s house arrest “before he completed his five-year reign in end-January”. 

The officials said the Attorney-General’s Chamber had objected to placing Najib under house arrest instead of jail because the supplementary order was not brought up in the meeting.

Attempts by the former prime minister to seek house arrest could shake up national politics and place the unity government in a fix.

Najib, 70, has filed a judicial review application to the High Court to allow him to serve the rest of his jail term at home.

He claims that then King Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah had issued an order that he be allowed to serve the reduced sentence of his imprisonment at home instead of confinement in Kajang Prison. 

Najib is seeking a copy of that “supplementary order” dated January 29, 2024.

If the order exists, it would compel the government to release him from Kajang Prison to his residence in Kuala Lumpur.

Najib said the former king had issued the order during a meeting of the board.

The application was filed by his solicitor Messrs Shafee & Co.

The former prime minister also claims that the supplementary order, or addendum order, was omitted when his partial pardon was announced on February 2. 

Just two months ago, the Pardons Board halved his 12-year jail sentence for corruption in connection with 1Malaysia Development Bhd (1MDB). His fine of RM210 million (US$44.3 million) was cut to RM50 million.

According to CNA, the government has yet to come out with a statement on how it intends to deal with Najib’s latest court challenge.

Attorney-General Datuk Ahmad Terrirudin Mohd Salleh did not respond to a request for comment from CNA. 

A spokesman for the Prime Minister’s Office said it will not be making any statement on this matter, while Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail said he knew nothing about a supplementary order.

However, the senior government officials did acknowledge that Sultan Abdullah had issued a supplementary order with regard to the house arrest before he completed his five-year reign in end-January. 

Najib’s latest legal challenge is set to be heard on April 17 by the High Court, which will decide whether to allow his bid for a judicial review.

“It is a matter that needs to be litigated,” said lawyer Datuk Zaid Ibrahim, who had also previously served as a member of Najib's defence team. “I belong to the old school; the pardon is the king’s alone to confer.”

Najib, who was the prime minister for nine years until May 2018 and the first one be imprisoned, began serving his jail term in August 2022 after failing in two appeals to overturn his conviction by a High Court two years earlier.

The clemency he secured in late January did not go down well with Malaysians. 

Questions were raised as to why Najib, who had served less than two years of his sentence, had become eligible for a royal pardon – at a time when he remains on trial for other corruption charges related to the 1MDB debacle.

According to CNA, this week’s bombshell that Najib could be allowed to serve his jail sentence under house arrest could raise serious questions over the country’s pardon system and stir criticism that two sets of laws exist for convicted persons in Malaysia.

The government had recently agreed in principle to a new initiative called Licensed Prisoner Release, aimed at reducing congestion in prisons and promoting community correction. 

It would let prisoners with jail terms of four years or less serve home detention, Saifuddin said last month. The initiative could also include prisoners who have chronic illnesses or disabilities, as well as those who are elderly or pregnant.

Najib’s latest legal challenge has pushed Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's administration into a corner, CNA reported.  

A government challenge to Najib’s bid would be viewed as tantamount to challenging the unfettered role of the country’s constitutional monarchy.

What’s more, it could also upset the delicate relations with Umno, which is a crucial component in Anwar’s coalition government. 

Najib continues to wield significant influence over the party that he headed while he was the prime minister for nine years. Government opposition to the house arrest gambit could set the stage for a revolt among certain factions in Umno against the Anwar administration.

“At this point, Anwar’s position is that he is against the house arrest for Najib,” said one government official, noting that the international reputation of the government and the country’s justice system would immediately be undermined. – The Vibes, April 5, 2024

Spotlight

Malaysia

Task force to draw up TOF for Sarawak’s push to fix dilapidated clinics

By Desmond Davidson

Malaysia

GRS content with Pakatan, uninterested in other partners

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

Shell in talks to sell Malaysia fuel stations to Saudi Aramco, says report

Malaysia

Fahmi: World Press Freedom Index is not gold standard for media freedom

Malaysia

Decision against 6 rogue Bersatu MPs to be presented to party’s supreme council

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

Two men arrested for using King's photo in KKB state seat campaign

You may be interested

Malaysia

Decision against 6 rogue Bersatu MPs to be presented to party’s supreme council

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

3 killed as pickup truck crashes into road shoulder

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Debate swirls over proper term to describe indigenous people of Sabah

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

Uprooted tree inspected by arborists every 2 years, says Dr Zaliha

Malaysia

Shell in talks to sell Malaysia fuel stations to Saudi Aramco, says report

Malaysia

Task force to draw up TOF for Sarawak’s push to fix dilapidated clinics

By Desmond Davidson

Malaysia

Keep demanding for return of eroded rights, Wan Junaidi tells Sarawak govt

By Desmond Davidson

Malaysia

Padu’s flaw is ease of changing password, says Sarawak minister

By Desmond Davidson