Malaysia

Penang being ‘extorted’ by PAS minister and MB, Guan Eng says of ‘water war’

Ex-CM accuses Datuk Seri Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man, Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor of ‘ganging up’ against state he once led as Sg Muda spat persists

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 28 Mar 2021 6:04PM

Penang being ‘extorted’ by PAS minister and MB, Guan Eng says of ‘water war’
Former Penang chief minister Lim Guan Eng says SPAN has failed to uphold its statutory duty and responsibility to ensure the state’s residents have uninterrupted access to clean water. – Lim Guan Eng Facebook pic, March 28, 2021

GEORGE TOWN – Kedah’s plan to build large water tanks along Sg Muda, which will reduce supply to Penang, has been slammed by Lim Guan Eng as a means to “extort” money from the latter state.

“Clearly, Environment and Water Minister (Datuk Seri) Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man is ‘ganging up’ with his PAS colleague and Kedah Menteri Besar Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor against Penang,” said the former Penang chief minister in a statement today.

He said it is “reckless and irresponsible” of the Perikatan Nasional administration and PAS to challenge Penang’s right to draw water from Sg Muda for their own political benefit.

“For the past 64 years, no federal government has conspired with a state government to threaten the population of another state by sabotaging their water supply.

“This is divisive and will unnecessarily stoke resentment and inflame sentiments.”

Penang has a right under the federal constitution to draw water from the river, part of which flows within its borders, and supplies 80% of the total volume required by the state’s 1.8 million residents, he said.

“Sanusi should stop such bullying tactics. Paying for water drawn on Penang’s side of the border is both illegal and unconstitutional. 

“First, the various agreements between both states, as well as the Kedah and Penang (Alteration of Boundary) Act 1985, have concluded the agreed altered boundaries between the northern states. 

“Second, a riparian owner, whether a landowner or a state like Penang, possesses an inalienable right to use and extract when (the river) runs on the side of Penang’s border, where the course of the river cannot be artificially manipulated, altered or realigned.”

The DAP secretary-general said Penang and his party will vigorously defend the state’s right to clean water.

The National Water Services Commission (SPAN) has failed to uphold its statutory duty and responsibility to ensure Penang folk have uninterrupted access to such supply, he said, adding that the regulator has upset the people by disrespecting the constitution and the legal doctrine of riparian rights.

Lim’s statement is in response to a report that SPAN sees nothing wrong with Kedah’s plan to install tanks along Sg Muda, despite the state having admitted that the 14 structures, measuring 20m to 30m deep and up to 1km wide, will “throttle” supply when the river reaches Penang.

Sanusi, when announcing the proposed project, told Penang to be “ready” to get muddy water should it refuse to compensate Kedah for the water it draws from Sg Muda.

“How can SPAN continue to function as a regulator when it condones or won’t step in to prevent 1.8 million people in Penang from drinking muddy water?” said Lim. – The Vibes, March 28, 2021

Related News

Culture / 7h

Penang: Three refurbished tourism attractions to be ‘reopened’ soon

Off beat / 1d

Penang targets 100% digital payment adoption rate

Tech / 3d

Penang’s Tech Dome celebrates 10th anniversary with opening of new space gallery

Malaysia / 6d

No further delays for water tariff hike in Penang - CM

People / 1w

Penang: Greater efforts needed to record historical events, says nonagenarian

People / 1w

Penang: Eurasian association mourns sudden loss of its president

Spotlight

Malaysia

‘No such thing as Bangkok Move or Dubai Move’ – Ahmad Zahid

Malaysia

KSN: Rectify long waiting times, service challenges and workforce constraints at UMMC now

Malaysia

LGE trial: 4 to 5 meetings held before open tender bidding for road, undersea tunnel projects - witness

Malaysia

Najib marks 73rd birthday as legal battles continue from behind prison walls

Malaysia

Court orders police to probe foreign management institute

Malaysia

UMNO pushes back against Hamzah’s ‘PBN’ proposal, says BN-PN cooperation is not a new coalition

Malaysia

Form four student killed after car crosses into opposite lane in Setiu crash

World

France heatwave death toll rises to nearly 5,800 as extreme temperatures trigger record mortality

Culture

Penang: Three refurbished tourism attractions to be ‘reopened’ soon

By Ian McIntyre

You may be interested

Malaysia

Two-year-old girl killed after being hit by lorry driven by grandfather in Kedah

Malaysia

KL police stress round-the-clock readiness to safeguard city

Malaysia

Govt embarks on RM1.49B flood mitigation projects in Sabah as high-risk areas receive priority

Malaysia

PRNNS: No place for race-based, hatred campaigns in Negeri – Aminuddin

Malaysia

Sabah assembly approves RM1.6b Supplementary Supply Bill to fund additional spending

Malaysia

Hajiji withdraws remark against Kapayan rep following request in Sabah assembly

Malaysia

Court orders police to probe foreign management institute

Malaysia

‘No such thing as Bangkok Move or Dubai Move’ – Ahmad Zahid