Malaysia

‘Penangites, Kedahans to lose out in long run if state govts maintain spats’

Political scientist says states dependent on each other via shared prosperity in northern region

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 30 Nov 2021 10:43AM

‘Penangites, Kedahans to lose out in long run if state govts maintain spats’
The war of words between Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor and Penang leaders have continued since he took office last year during the height of the pandemic. – The Vibes file pic, November 30, 2021

by Ian McIntyre

GEORGE TOWN – Penang and Kedah residents will stand to lose out in the long run if the two state governments continue their disputes and pot shots.

“The people will suffer as Penang and Kedah have nothing to gain politically or economically from the prolonging of this rift,” said Sivamurugan Pandian.

Sivamurugan, a political scientist at Universiti Sains Malaysia, said Penang and Kedah are dependent on each other through the concept of shared prosperity in the northern region.

“Many Kedahans are in Penang, and vice-versa with the latter helping to generate new growth in southern Kedah due to spillover projects from the heavy industrialised zones in Penang.”

He told The Vibes that much political jostling can be achieved with this spat, as reality calls on both neighbours to get along for the sake of their people.

Sivamurugan was referring to the spat between Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor and Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow that has been going on for a while.

Among the latest issues was Sanusi posting on social media a conversation he had with Chow about the contentious raw water supply on the sidelines of the annual meeting between chief ministers and menteris besar with the prime minister at Istana Negara.

Sanusi said he had asked Chow about payments for Kedah supplying raw water.

“The Penang chief minister’s answer to me was Penang cannot afford it. It is very difficult to digest his answer because everyone knows that Penang Water Supply Corporation generates a lot of income and profit from supplying water to the industrial, shipping, and domestic sectors using raw water originating from Kedah.”

Sanusi said the demand for raw water payment is – for Kedah and its people – a just and reasonable demand, after the state’s sacrifice to maintain the catchment area of ​​hundreds of thousands of hectares.

Chow then shared the post and responded to it, saying that Penang’s stance had been officially stated many times.

“We will not pay because the issue of payment does not arise. This is because we take water from our state borders. It seems that Kedah still does not want to understand.”

Besides water, Sanusi had broached another contentious topic by claiming that the federal government needs to pay up to RM100 million in annual compensation packages, as the state was technically leased from the Sultan of Kedah during the British colonial era.

The war of words between Sanusi and Penang leaders have continued since he took office last year during the height of the pandemic. – The Vibes, November 30, 2021

Related News

Events / 11min

MBPP President shares valuable insights at zero-waste conference 

Diary / 1d

Penang reaffirms commitment to preserve heritage sites across the state

Places / 2d

LOT Polish Airlines to bring in more tourists to Penang from November

Malaysia / 1w

PH-BN cooperation in Penang remains smooth, says Exco

Places / 2w

Penang hoteliers lose patience over growing number of short-term rentals, homestays

Diary / 2w

A leader's role is not just about issuing statements and making headlines – Penang CM

Spotlight

Malaysia

Do not hide school safety issues to protect reputation - IGP

World

Flydubai pilot planned to crash plane into terminal at Ben Gurion Airport

Malaysia

Sabah Pan Borneo Highway: Only 4 of 35 packages complete after a decade

Malaysia

School caning was never abolished, Minster says

Malaysia

Sepang draws record crowd as Bahrain GP puts Malaysia back on F1 map

Malaysia

Irene Sofiya died from blunt-force head injuries, post-mortem confirms

Malaysia

No CCTV at spot where Irene was killed, says Minister

Malaysia

Irene’s only focus was her studies and her dream to become a doctor - aunt

You may be interested

Malaysia

Budget 2027 must balance cost pressures with fiscal resilience

Malaysia

MASFIH urges diplomatic push with Nepal and China over 54 missing Malaysians

Malaysia

Mentally disabled suspect remanded for 7 days over fatal hammer attack in Marang

Malaysia

Mobile phone, clothing seized from teenager remanded over Yong Peng schoolgirl murder

Malaysia

School caning was never abolished, Minster says

Malaysia

Anwar vows zero compromise on school safety after alleged murder of teen Irene Sofiya

Malaysia

SOCSO: Zetrix never handled mandatory contributions as Loke rejects political claims

Malaysia

Budget 2027 expected to dominate Dewan Rakyat proceedings

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir