Malaysia

Court bins Rosmah’s application to recuse judge Zaini

Judge says leaked ‘draft judgments’ based on opinions written by research unit, were not his grounds

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 01 Sep 2022 2:46PM

Court bins Rosmah’s application to recuse judge Zaini
In the application filed on Tuesday night, Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor (pic) cited loss of confidence following the leak of an alleged draft judgement – published on the Malaysia Today website – that she claimed was not drawn up by judge Mohamed Zaini Mazlan himself. – ALIF OMAR/The Vibes pic, September 1, 2022

by Danial Dzulkifly

KUALA LUMPUR – The high court here has dismissed Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor’s last-minute application to recuse judge Mohamed Zaini Mazlan from presiding over her corruption trial in relation to the RM1.25 billion solar hybrid project in Sarawak.

In his judgement, Zaini said the documents that form the application are based on opinions written by the Research Unit of the Kuala Lumpur High Court.

“The draft judgments were not prepared by me, nor were they prepared based on my instructions but they remain just that, opinions.

“They are not my grounds, nor did I rely or use them as a working draft for my judgement.

“I hope the research division will forgive me for saying this but I did not read the opinions. I’ve done my own research and was assisted by counsel in this case, by their well-written submissions.”

He added that, “I’ve always done my work as laborious as they are and I’ve written more than 200 judgments to date”.

“Now, anyone can form their own opinions but at the end of the day, the only opinion that matters is my own.

“That will form the basis for my decision.”

Earlier, one of Rosmah’s lawyers Datuk Jagjit Singh said the defence needed more time to marshal a response to the prosecution’s counter-affidavit on Rosmah’s recusal bid.

This also earned a reprimand from Zaini, who told Jagjit that he was ready to hear the merits of the application as the defence filed a certificate of emergency on August 30 as a means to expedite the hearing on the matter.

Zaini told Jagjit he was ready to set aside the prosecution’s affidavit – filed this morning by deputy public prosecutor Poh Yin Tinn – so as not to handicap the defence.

Senior deputy public prosecutor Datuk Seri Gopal Sri Ram then said Rosmah’s application did not have credible evidence to support her justification to recuse the judge.

However, the court stood down for about 30 minutes after Zaini granted Jagjit some time to prepare his thoughts to argue Rosmah’s application.

In the application filed on Tuesday night, Rosmah cited loss of confidence following the leak of an alleged draft judgement – published on the Malaysia Today website – that she claimed was not drawn up by Zaini himself.

She filed the notice of motion through Messrs Akberdin & Co, naming the public prosecutor as respondent.

She is also seeking an order that with the recusal of the judge, the case should be heard, retried or decided by another high court judge.

Rosmah, 70, is charged with one count of soliciting RM187.5 million and two counts of receiving bribes of RM6.5 million from Jepak Holdings Sdn Bhd’s former managing director Saidi Abang Samsudin through her former special officer Datuk Rizal Mansor.

The kickbacks were allegedly an inducement to help the company Jepak Holdings secure the hybrid photovoltaic solar system integrated project for 369 rural schools in Sarawak, worth RM1.25 billion. – The Vibes, September 1, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 5d

Sultan Nazrin warns Perak palace dignitaries against exploiting royal titles

Malaysia / 6d

2,097 police personnel arrested for drugs, robbery and corruption since 2021

Malaysia / 2w

Banking veteran questions loss of shame as corruption takes hold

Malaysia / 2w

Allegation of minister receiving RM9.5m political statement without evidence - PM Anwar

Malaysia / 2w

Fahmi condemns threats against UM student over corruption remarks

Malaysia / 3w

Negeri Ruler, Tuanku Muhriz, invited to Conference of Rulers meeting tomorrow

Spotlight

Malaysia

Denying young candidates opportunities risks leadership gap in future - Adam Adli

Malaysia

Na’imah’s constitutional challenge over police probe dismissed by High Court

Malaysia

AGC orders further police probe into allegations against Negeri Sembilan MB

Malaysia

PH-Bersatu rivalry puts political understanding to test in Melaka polls

Malaysia

Muhyiddin’s sedition trial dates vacated pending fresh AGC review

Malaysia

Man in his 20s killed in suspected revenge attack in Banting, three arrested

Malaysia

Prosecution to call 25 witnesses in Saravanan’s RM1.097m corruption trial

Malaysia

Malaysia on cyberattack radar, government steps up security measures

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

World

US strikes Iran’s Qeshm Island in latest limited attacks, report says

You may be interested

Malaysia

Ismail’s move to seek Tuanku Muhriz’s consent seen as recognition of ruler’s legitimacy

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

King receives briefing on military developments under Defence Ministry plans

Malaysia

MOH steps up push to change lifestyle habits as NCDs claim 96,000 lives yearly

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Malaysia to seek Pakistan's cooperation over 130 citizens detained in suspected scam operation

Malaysia

Zahid accuses rivals of desperation over claims against BN candidate

Malaysia

PKR demands Ab Rauf explain status of 55 Melaka development projects

Malaysia

Govt considers adding organ donor status to driving licences to boost transplants

Malaysia

AGC orders further police probe into allegations against Negeri Sembilan MB