Opinion

Letter – Malaysians make their mark in Malaysiakini case – J.D. Lovrenciear

More than RM500,000 raised in less than 5 hours sends clear, loud message of how citizens object to court’s 6-1 verdict against news portal

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 20 Feb 2021 4:00PM

Letter – Malaysians make their mark in Malaysiakini case – J.D. Lovrenciear
Malaysiakini editor-in-chief Steven Gan outside the Palace of Justice in Putrajaya yesterday. He was found not guilty of contempt in a suit brought by Attorney-General Tan Sri Idrus Harun. – AFP pic, February 20, 2021

IN a record time of under five hours of appealing for financial support, Malaysiakini got more than the requested RM500,000.

The online news portal created the fundraiser to pay the RM500,000 fine after the Federal Court found it liable for contemptuous comments by its readers.

Here are some poignant thoughts that deserve serious thinking.

First, when citizens immediately pour in their support for a media outlet and within hours raise more than half a million ringgit, it sends out a clear and loud message of objection from the citizenry over the court’s 6-1 verdict.

Second, this unprecedented court ruling has been met with deep and widespread alarm from the legal fraternity.

Third, the fear that there will be a meddling with the independence of the judiciary with regard to calls for a law to be passed in Parliament to preset how judges should interpret “contemptuousness”, is not to be dismissed lightly.

Fourth, this case raises many other debatable considerations, including the question of whether we are leaning away from our democratic principles as is constructed in our federal constitution.

It also raises the question of what will be the message we are sending out to the larger democratic world, namely are we a progressive or regressing nation?

And what will be the subsequent impact upon foreign investments from the democratic economies’ – not communist regimes – which are much needed to lend a lifeboat to our own economy.

As we now reflect on the above thoughts, we have to also be mindful of how and where contemporary civilization is evolving, realistically.

Have we set the clock backwards?

In this fast-advancing age of artificial intelligence and 5G technology knocking hard on the doors of many nations, is this fate that fell upon Malaysiakini not distressing?

If this nation of leaders – from the legislature, executive and judiciary (the cornerstones of nationhood), are true to their sacrosanct oath of office, they cannot sweep this latest development under the carpet.

We need to debate in the best interest of human civilisation and its rights on planet Earth. – The Vibes, February 20, 2021

J.D. Lovrenciear is a The Vibes reader

Related News

Malaysia / 1y

Malaysiakini reporter detained by MACC

Malaysia / 4y

Umno sues Mkini, Awani for RM25 mil each over ‘defamatory’ reports

Malaysia / 4y

[UPDATED] Court rejects Malaysiakini’s bid to review contempt verdict

Malaysia / 5y

Will top court’s binning of Mkini defamation suit hamper local journalism?

Malaysia / 5y

Federal Court trashes Mkini appeal against gold miner’s defamation suit

Malaysia / 5y

Guan Eng wins RM600,000 in defamation suit against blogger Raja Petra

Spotlight

Education

Fadhlina: Numerous factors considered before any decision made to close schools

Malaysia

Traffic congestion in Bandar Sunway persists into the afternoon

Malaysia

Two people allegedly stabbed in Kepong attack, student faces 20 years in jail

Malaysia

KLIA steps up K9 patrols at peak hours after security incidents

Malaysia

Customs seizes RM162m in drugs, including 460kg hidden in cemetery hut

Malaysia

Fourteen men charged over teenager’s death after alleged two-day ordeal

Malaysia

Instant billionaire? Bank customer finds RM1 billion mistakenly credited to account

Malaysia

Irene Sofiya murder: Accused’s family to take legal action over fake social media posts

World

Indonesia records 277,075 respiratory infections as forest fires fuel haze crisis

You may be interested

Opinion

The forest before the border

Opinion

AI ethics and journalism. Will emerging guidelines strengthen or constrain independence?