Opinion

Vaping: not quite the safe alternative? – Nur Amani Ahmad Tajuddin

E-cigarettes just as detrimental, difficult to quit as ‘regular’ smoking

Updated 7 months ago · Published on 20 Sep 2023 6:18PM

Vaping: not quite the safe alternative? – Nur Amani Ahmad Tajuddin
An e-cigarette has ‌6,000 puffs, and the amount of nicotine is equivalent to 600 cigarettes – this brings into question how much damage a child who has not yet fully developed physically could suffer if he smokes 600 cigarettes daily. – Pixabay pic, September 20, 2023

SMOKING prevalence among Malaysian adults has been relatively static at 23% for the past few years. 

Many in our country have replaced or co-used smoking with vaping or e-cigarettes.

In developed countries such as Australia, the United Kingdom and New Zealand, vaping is used as a form of smoking cessation treatment for adult smokers; they are closely monitored and followed up by general practitioners and quit smoking providers under the NHS in the UK.

The amount of nicotine allowed in an e-juice is controlled under the closed system of the e-cigarettes, and manufacturers abide by the regulations set by their government.

In Malaysia, the prevalence of vaping among adults, and more among teenagers, is at a worrying number of 14%, based on data in 2022. 

The misperception of vaping as a safer alternative is worrying, as more research and data published shows the harmful chemical contents found exceed 250. 

What is more, the e-juice can be easily manipulated and modified. Many are self-manipulated through the addition of illicit drugs such as cannabis and “magic mushrooms”.

Teenagers could get access to vaping products too easily, especially after nicotine was denounced from the poisons act on April 1. 

This has caused upset and increasing worry among healthcare professionals, teachers, and parents as more and more teenagers and children under 12 have never smoked before becoming vapers. 

This trend is expected to increase and cause many known and unforeseen detrimental physical, mental health, social, and financial problems.

Lecturers from the Nicotine Addiction Research and Collaborating Group (NARCC) at Universiti Malaya, University Malaya Medical Centre clinicians, and UM student advocates of generational end-game (GEG) have tirelessly conducted programs to increase awareness of the dangers of smoking and vaping to secondary school students in Klang Valley since the year 2015, and to promote cessation of the use of smoking and vaping. 

Wong Kim Yiew, a GEG trainer and final year student from the Faculty of Business and Economics, Universiti Malaya, said that he was puzzled by the health minister’s statement that “removing liquid nicotine (e-cigarettes) from the drug law is not a problem, but it does not deny that liquid nicotine is a drug”.

He said that during his visits to many schools as a trainer and advocate of smoking prevention programmes, he had seen many secondary school students who had initially casually smoked e-cigarettes but later became addicted to them, making quitting difficult. 

These secondary school students know that long-term smoking will harm their bodies, but have no choice but to suffer the difficulty of quitting. 

One even told him he would finish smoking a whole e-cigarette in one day. 

An e-cigarette has ‌6,000 puffs, and the amount of nicotine is equivalent to 600 cigarettes – this brings into question how much damage a child who has not yet fully developed physically could suffer if he smokes 600 cigarettes daily.

Although the chemical content of e-cigarettes has yet to be analysed, as they are a new product, there are many unanswered questions and unknowns. 

However, Wong has warned that the unknowns are scarier, as we can prevent and treat known risks and hazards.

What is known is that e-cigarettes and cigarettes are both nicotine products, and the nicotine content is even higher than that of cigarettes. 

Nicotine affects brain activity, leading to poor memory, reduced concentration, learning disabilities, and anxiety. 

Nicotine has cardiovascular, respiratory, neurological, and digestive effects and is a catalyst for cancer. 

Nicotine reaches the brain receptors in 12 seconds and can be addictive after two puffs.

In addition, he has personally visited many shops selling e-cigarettes and found that they are very attractive to the younger generation. 

Because of the wide range of packaging and flavours, there can be as many as 20 flavours in a single span, which is dazzling and can appeal to customers with a wide range of preferences.

The presence of nicotine in e-cigarettes, coupled with their attractiveness and addictive nature, are reasons cited by Wong behind why many primary and secondary school students are easily addicted to e-cigarettes today.

Wong has posited that the harm caused by e-cigarettes is probably underestimated, considering the many cases at home and abroad.

In Malaysia, for example, a 16-year-old girl who had been smoking e-cigarettes for three years died of heart failure due to a suspected EVALI (lung embolism) related to e-cigarette use. 

Another distressing case of a 2-year-old girl who suffered nicotine ingestion and seizures due to mistaken e-cigarette use could have been avoided.

In the United States, a 38-year-old man died in his bedroom in 2016. The autopsy report stated that the cause of death was an e-cigarette explosion, with fragments piercing his skull and brain. 

In 2019, CNN and other media reported that an e-cigarette exploded, causing the jawbone of a high school student in the United States to partially fracture and shatter, with some gum tissue and several teeth blown away.

We hope that the Health Ministry, Education Ministry, and Higher Education Ministry will join forces with non-governmental organisations to curb the use of vaping and smoking, in pursuit of creating a smoke-free nation by 2040 and a healthy and productive individual that will contribute to the growth and development of our beloved country, Malaysia. – The Vibes, September 20, 2023

Assoc Prof Dr Nur Amani Ahmad Tajuddin is deputy coordinator of the Nicotine Addiction Research and Collaborating Group and a senior lecturer at the Primary Care Medicine Department, Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Malaya

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

GEG exclusion has nothing to do with industry lobbyists - Dr Dzulkefly

Opinion / 1mth

GEG bombshell: When lawmakers are dictated by ‘merchants of death’ – MyWatch

Malaysia / 1mth

Unity Govt cowardly, irresponsible for snuffing out GEG, bowing to pressure: Khairy

Malaysia / 5mth

Govt tables anti-smoking bill, drops GEG element

Malaysia / 7mth

MoH to meet PSSC over tobacco control bill

Podcast / 9mth

Beyond Breakfast with Shazmin Shamsuddin: Moving Malaysia towards a vape-regulated nation

Spotlight

Malaysia

Penang mulls raising wages of civil servants

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Court upholds Siti Bainun's conviction, sentence for abusing girl with Down syndrome

Malaysia

After years of delay, Sarawak labour laws to be amended to match peninsula's

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Papagomo charged with sedition, defaming king

Malaysia

Langkawi needs tourists, jobs, not LRT, says Mahfuz

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Sabah hospitality industry offers plenty of jobs but little stability

By Jason Santos