Malaysia

‘Mining rare earth elements will harm water catchment areas’

Even leading producer China does not mine in such areas, says PBA Holdings Bhd chief executive officer

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 17 Dec 2020 4:51PM

‘Mining rare earth elements will harm water catchment areas’
PBAPP and PBA Holdings Bhd chief executive officer Datuk Jaseni Maidinsa (left) says the raw water contamination at Ulu Muda would be serious, as mining and extracting rare-earth elements involves toxic chemicals and metallurgical treatments to separate the minerals from excavated soil, including acid baths and leaching ponds. – Facebook pic, December 17, 2020

GEORGE TOWN – Kedah’s plan to mine rare earth minerals will damage water catchment areas in three ways, said the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) and PBA Holdings Bhd.

PBAPP and PBA Holdings Bhd chief executive officer Datuk Jaseni Maidinsa said in a statement yesterday that rare earth mining would cause environmental destruction at the water catchment area, creating land and water pollution and causing raw water contamination.

He said that the Ulu Muda water catchment area, which serves 4.2 million people in Perlis, Kedah, and Penang, would be in danger if the mining activities were to begin.

“Even China, the leading rare earth element (REE) producer in the world, does not mine for REE in water catchment areas.

“Mining RM60 billion worth of REE will inevitably involve large-scale land clearing and tree-cutting to set up mining operations in a pristine rainforest environment. 

“Land and water pollution is unavoidable as mining operations to extract and process REE will cause pollution and generate waste that will seep into the soil and nearby groundwater,” said Jaseni.

He said the raw water contamination would be serious, as mining and extracting REE involves toxic chemicals and metallurgical treatments to separate the minerals from excavated soil, including acid baths and leaching ponds. 

He also said that rainfall may cause toxins and chemicals to be washed into Sg Muda and its tributaries, and that the effects of REE mining in Ulu Muda would be more devastating than logging.

“Media reports had stated that the environment and water minister had suggested for Penang to compensate Kedah for its ‘big sacrifice’ to not conduct REE mining in water catchment areas in Kedah.

“This is tantamount to asking Penang to pay Kedah for publicising an irrational proposal and there is no ‘big sacrifice’ because REE mining in a water catchment area is not justifiable.

“The most pertinent point to bear in mind is that the 163,000ha Greater Ulu Muda Forest Complex is much more than a rainforest habitat.

“It is the primary water catchment area for the three states. 96% of Kedah’s raw water and 70% of Perlis raw water originates from Ulu Muda,” Jaseni said.

He said more than 80% of the raw water that PBAPP abstracts from Sg Muda at the Lahar Tiang Intake in Penang comes from Ulu Muda. 

“Please remember that water supply has a direct bearing on the people’s well-being and health.” – The Vibes, December 17, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 3w

Kedah: The ancient Malay kingdom challenges the conventional narrative of Malayan history

Malaysia / 2mth

Sanusi invites Ramkarpal to ‘give a talk’ on gambling in Kedah

Malaysia / 3mth

To leave or to stay? Penang and Kedah DAP remain undecided

Malaysia / 3mth

Kedah may delay Penang lease claim documents till change of federal government

Malaysia / 3mth

‘We will respond after Kedah formally submits lease payment claims’ – Penang CM

Malaysia / 3mth

Kedah MB’s “Cina ada China, India ada India” remark draws criticism over citizenship narrative

Spotlight

Malaysia

Geopolitical tensions must not derail regional economic integration - Anwar

Malaysia

Najib has been given a second chance. But where is the accountability to Malaysians?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

PAS joins BN in sitting out Sarawak polls

Malaysia

PAC to probe possible financial breaches, abuse of power in Sabah Pan Borneo project

Malaysia

Landowners cannot demolish unauthorised places of worship themselves, says Nga

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Differing views do not constitute treason – lawyer

Malaysia

Suspected criminal shot dead in exchange of fire with police in Perak

You may be interested

Malaysia

Puad challenges Ismail to explain circumstances surrounding resignation

Malaysia

MMA seeks urgent probe into claim Sabah doctor used phone torch during procedure

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Enforcement agencies, politicians top corruption perception list in Malaysia – survey

Malaysia

Chow Kit shooting suspect linked to nine robberies since May

Malaysia

'I'm bored with the repeated criticism from Umno' - Tony Pua

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Those who breach government rules, discipline and standards of conduct have to resign - Anwar

Malaysia

Govt faces questions on incentives for flood relief volunteers as monsoon preparedness comes under scrutiny

Malaysia

Father of deceased boarding school student calls for transparent, thorough probe