Malaysia

Emergency over Covid-19 a dangerous precedent, say ex-Bar presidents

Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act, movement controls enough to contain virus threat

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 17 Jan 2021 4:05PM

Emergency over Covid-19 a dangerous precedent, say ex-Bar presidents
A nationwide emergency has been imposed to contain the Covid-19 pandemic, but the reasoning has been contested by various quarters, including members of the legal fraternity. – The Vibes file pic, January 17, 2021

KUALA LUMPUR – The latest proclamation of emergency has set a dangerous precedent, in that it can be whipped up again in the future during situations where requisite conditions under the federal constitution are not met.

Asserting this, 10 former Bar Council presidents, in a joint statement today, noted that the proclamation on January 11 expressly relies on the Covid-19 pandemic as a threat to “security, economic life or public order” in the country.

Failing any other ground, this is hardly a legitimate reason for an emergency, particularly in light of the reach of the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988 and movement controls to contain the disease, they said.

They also noted that most businesses continue to function, albeit under very challenging conditions.

“It is incumbent on any responsible government to avoid seeking such a proclamation, save for the most extreme of circumstances. Do these circumstances exist here?”

The statement is signed by Steven Thiru, Christopher Leong, Ragunath Kesavan, Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan, Datuk Yeo Yang Poh, Datuk Kuthubul Zaman, Datuk Mah Weng Kwai, Datuk Cyrus V. Das, Zainur Zakaria and Datuk Param Cumaraswamy. 

Besides the proclamation itself, they said, more alarming is the Emergency (Essential Powers) Ordinance 2021 that has been promulgated and gazetted, giving the government unrestricted powers over person and property. 

Its most egregious provision is the suspension of parliamentary and state assembly sittings, which has no justifiable reason, they said.

The group said the move is unconstitutional, and only insulates the executive from accountability. 

“A proclamation and any ordinances promulgated must be tabled in Parliament under Article 150(3) of the constitution. This is for Parliament to exercise its constitutional power of scrutiny of the government.

“Both Houses may pass resolutions annulling the proclamation and ordinances. There is, therefore, a guarantee that Parliament will continue to function during the emergency, as it did under previous emergencies. 

“The (current) ordinance deprives Parliament of this critical constitutional power of checks and balances. It denies our democracy.”

They added that other measures in the ordinance directly related to the pandemic are achievable through other means, and called for the immediate tabling of the emergency proclamation and ordinance in Parliament. – The Vibes, January 17, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Ten former Bar Council presidents affirm Tuanku Muhriz as rightful Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri

Malaysia / 2mth

Haze in Serian enters emergency phase

Malaysia / 2mth

Haze: Emergency only in areas with API of 500, not the whole of Sarawak

Opinion / 5mth

The constitutional framework of justice: Balancing adat

Malaysia / 6mth

Malaysian doctor couple saves passenger from allergic shock mid-flight

Malaysia / 7mth

'Sack me if I violated PKR constitution' - Rafizi

Spotlight

Malaysia

Khalid urges PAS to ditch Umno alliance and support Anwar

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Govt, AG, Hannah opposed conditional pardon, minutes show

Malaysia

Former Negeri Sembilan exco members end legal fight over removal

Business

Nvidia rules out Jensen Huang comeback as quarterly revenue doubles to US$115b

Malaysia

Indonesia should compensate Malaysians for the prolonged haze – Guan Eng

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Padang Rengas dispute exposes challenge facing possible BN-PN pact

You may be interested

Malaysia

Nation's economy expands 5.6%, a first over nine months of 2026

Malaysia

Malaysia seeks greater defence self-reliance through expanded French military cooperation

Malaysia

Anwar praises Macron’s ‘courageous conscience’ on Gaza, Palestine

Malaysia

1MDB’s burden will outlive the generation that witnessed its rise

Malaysia

France offers nuclear energy expertise as Malaysia seeks to accelerate decarbonisation

Malaysia

Scammers exploit digital banking to recruit uni students as account mules for RM40

Malaysia

Burnham says Brexit has left UK worse off as he seeks closer EU ties

Malaysia

Sabah, Sarawak's local representation in civil service faces Dewan Rakyat scrutiny