Malaysia

Be respectful in criticism of high court judge, Shafee told

Use phrases other than ‘poisoned his judgment’, ‘hopelessly incompetent’, Court of Appeal justice tells Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s lawyer

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 06 Apr 2021 12:39PM

Be respectful in criticism of high court judge, Shafee told
Lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah (right) represents former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak in the RM42 million SRC International case. – Bernama pic, April 6, 2021

PUTRAJAYA – Court of Appeal justice Datuk Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil has advised Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah to use courteous words when criticising high court judge Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali, who convicted the lawyer’s client, Datuk Seri Najib Razak, over the misappropriation of RM42 million in SRC International Sdn Bhd funds.

Karim, who leads a three-member bench, told Shafee that he can use phrases like “erred in law” and “misdirected himself” to show weaknesses in Nazlan’s judgment.

“I think that if we can use a better word with due respect to the learned judge... find a better adjective to describe him. Other than you saying ‘poisoned his judgment’, or ‘hopelessly incompetent’, could you find another phrase? Accord respect to the judge.

“Use phrases like ‘grossly erred’, he had ‘erred and flawed’, he ‘misdirected himself’. Don’t just say he is ‘hopelessly incompetent’,” said Karim, who presided over the appeal with justices Datuk Has Zanah Mehat and Datuk Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera.

Shafee: Can I just say, the learned judge demonstrated incompetence. 

Karim: Yes.

Shafee: Clearly, he demonstrated incompetence. That, I can say. (Otherwise,) I can’t pull any punches, as Yang Arif can appreciate. If these things happened, I have to say them.

Karim: Just say it (respectfully).

Shafee: With a bit more decorum. Alright.

At the outset, Shafee, in his submissions at the hearing of Najib’s appeal against his conviction and jail sentence for the misappropriation of the RM42 million, said the trial judge was incompetent when making the ruling.

“Can we say, with the greatest of respect, that the learned judge was hopelessly incompetent in this case. That is the only explanation I can give as to how a blunder of this sort could happen. That goes to the root as to whether we have gotten a fair trial in this case.

“Now, I want to add one more ground. By incorporating what was not supposed to be there in the grounds of judgment and in the record of proceedings, as in the finding of prima facie has elements previously not there, as though it had always been there, has the judge poisoned his ground of judgment?

“Had the poisoning occurred, Yang Arif (this court) will have to relook the grounds. That is another question I would like to pose.”

The Kuala Lumpur High Court on July 28 last year sentenced Najib to 12 years’ jail and imposed a RM210 million fine after finding him guilty on seven counts of criminal breach of trust, money laundering and abuse of power involving the SRC International monies.

Nazlan sentenced the former prime minister to 10 years’ jail on each of the three counts of CBT and each of the three counts of money laundering, and 12 years’ jail and a RM210 million fine, in default of five years’ jail, for the power abuse charge.

The appeal hearing continues. – Bernama, April 6, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 6mth

Court of Appeal: Emergency proclamations beyond judicial review

Malaysia / 7mth

Rosmah: ‘There was no obligation for me to buy any of the jewellery’

Malaysia / 8mth

Family takes issue of government responsibility in Altantuya's death to Federal Court

Malaysia / 10mth

Court of Appeal rejects Najib’s bid to reinstate RM1.9m civil suit against Tommy Thomas

Malaysia / 1y

Court dismisses ex-AG special officer’s appeal in lawsuit against Rewcastle-Brown

Opinion / 1y

A tribute revisited: Why I needed hope

Spotlight

Malaysia

Bersama, Bersatu fail to win a seat in Melaka, face questions over political future

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

African man apologises to Malaysians over machete attack on policeman

Malaysia

Two family members to be charged with murder of elderly man in Negeri Sembilan

Malaysia

Kuching student accused of attacking teacher with a deadly weapon sent for mental observation

People

Hans Isaac engaged to former Miss Universe Malaysia Francisca Luhong in Paris proposal

Malaysia

NS Exco: Palace weighs settlement proposals as court hearing postponed

Malaysia

Police hunt answers after 15-year-old girl shot in neck in Ranau

Malaysia

Missing 74-year-old windsurfer found dead off Tanjung Bungah

You may be interested

Malaysia

PH's Melaka gains point to need for wider political cooperation, says Amirudin

Malaysia

Ismail Lasim resigns as Negeri Sembilan MB

Malaysia

Scams: Fahmi wants WhatsApp to strengthen phone number verification

Malaysia

Umno-PAS alliance faces bigger test as GE16 brings leadership question into focus

Malaysia

Nation's economic resilience allows BNM to hold OPR at 2.75%, says Amir Hamzah

Malaysia

Malaysia in Macron's sights as France seeks to cut reliance on rare earth supplies

Malaysia

Bersama, Bersatu fail to win a seat in Melaka, face questions over political future

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

NS Exco: Palace weighs settlement proposals as court hearing postponed