Malaysia

Family of man killed by uprooted tree have every right to sue: Penang exco

This could spur state to better ensure public’s safety, says Jagdeep Singh Deo

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 29 Apr 2021 12:54PM

Family of man killed by uprooted tree have every right to sue: Penang exco
In the fatal incident on Tuesday, a giant angsana tree crushed the roof of a car, killing the driver, after it was uprooted during a downpour in George Town. – Social media pic, April 29, 2021

by Arulldas Sinnappan

GEORGE TOWN – State Housing and Local Government Committee chairman Jagdeep Singh Deo said the family of a victim who died after a tree fell on his car can go ahead with legal action as they are entitled to do so under the law.  

He said the legal action against the relevant authorities and the state would require them to deal with the issue.

“However, asking the Datuk Bandar to resign from the post is uncalled for. The tree was replanted when the arborist issued the certificate.

“That is why we are investigating this case and we are monitoring every replanted tree now.

“Investigations ongoing to establish the cause of the incident and the report will be submitted to the state government once it is completed; we cannot assume that every other tree is the same,” he said.

Penang exco Jagdeep Singh Deo says while the family can take legal action against the state authorities, calling for the Datuk Bandar to resign from the post is uncalled for. – Wikipedia pic, April 29, 2021
Penang exco Jagdeep Singh Deo says while the family can take legal action against the state authorities, calling for the Datuk Bandar to resign from the post is uncalled for. – Wikipedia pic, April 29, 2021

In the fatal incident on Tuesday, a giant angsana tree crushed the roof of a car, killing the driver, after it was uprooted during a downpour here. 

Jagdeep said this during the handing over of food items to 1,000 Penang Island City Council (MBPP) and Seberang Prai City Council (MBSP) staff at the Town Hall building here today.

Present were MBPP secretary Datuk Addnan Mohd Razali and MBSP mayor Datuk Rozali Mohamud.

“We have instructed both city council mayors to be cautious and monitor the replanting of trees and make sure all trees are safe because the safety of the people are of utmost importance,” Jagdeep said.

On another note, Jagdeep said, out of 5,200 staff members from the two city councils, only 1,493 have been vaccinated. 

He said he has raised the matter with the Health Ministry as there are 2,400 frontliners in both councils who face a higher risk of contracting Covid-19 as they go out to the field.

He also commended MBPP and MPSP staff for working tirelessly to break the chain of Covid-19 transmissions.

The falling tree may reflect lack of knowledge about the replanting process on the part of the contractors, says one expert. – Social media pic, April 29, 2021
The falling tree may reflect lack of knowledge about the replanting process on the part of the contractors, says one expert. – Social media pic, April 29, 2021

Replanting procedures adhered to? 

Meanwhile, adviser of the Malaysian Nature Society's Penang chapter Kanda Kumar questioned if proper procedures are being followed in removing and replanting trees.

He said he was saddened over the incident that had claimed a life.

He said the falling tree may reflect lack of knowledge about the replanting process on the part of the contractors.

“There are thousands of trees replanted all over the world and there has hardly been such an incident. Why did it happen here?” he said. 

“It is not just dig-and-plant process. There are procedures to follow in the tree-replanting process.”

Kanda said a qualified arborist or botanist must be appointed to oversee the process, and contractors should not be allowed to undertake such a task without their presence.

“The experts will study the condition of the soil and root strength of the tree they want to remove,” he said.

“They will also study of the condition of the soil for about two weeks before replanting the tree there. It is not dig-and-remove today and dig-and-replant tomorrow.” – The Vibes, April 29, 2021

Related News

People / 21h

Prevention and early detection vital to reduce NCD rates, says Penang Exco

Community / 3d

More attention needed to care for the aged, says consumer association

Malaysia / 3d

Declining birth rate among the Chinese community worrying, says Penang Exco

Community / 5d

Penang introduces self-service cutlery return initiative at food court

Community / 5d

Penang urged to plant new trees before felling those deemed rotten

Community / 6d

Burst pipe affects 130,790 consumers in Penang

Spotlight

Malaysia

Papagomo acquitted for second time in sedition case over government, Israel claims

Malaysia

ECRL fares start at RM60, with 50% discounts for children, seniors and OKU

Malaysia

DKU seeks court action against Ismail, 16 others over Negeri Sembilan royal dispute

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Kampung Manis: Dreams of 227 families to own replacement homes draw closer

Malaysia

Fadhlina takes legal action over video of 2023 Parliament speech

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Civil servants urged to turn Selangor Sultan’s anti-graft message into action

Malaysia

Animal welfare group urges probe into alleged sexual abuse of cat in viral video

Malaysia

Macron appeals for calm after France riots: 2,400 arrested, nearly 1,000 officers injured

Malaysia

Malaysia renews offer to help Indonesia fight fires

You may be interested

Malaysia

M40 cost-of-living aid, online safety among key questions in Parliament

Malaysia

Budget 2027 expands tax relief, fuel and electricity subsidies for M40 households

Malaysia

Ayob Khan alleges terror recruiters are targeting Malaysian children through Roblox

Malaysia

MCMC warns cyberbullies, AI disinformation offenders as online safety comes under scrutiny

Malaysia

Housewife loses RM472k in phone scam after fraudsters threaten arrest

Malaysia

STR and SARA aid: RM11b disbursed as monthly assistance records 99.7% utilisation

Malaysia

Guan Eng proposes RM1,000 tax rebate for purchase of air purifiers

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Property agent loses over RM79k after being scammed twice