Malaysia

July 7 decision on quantum of damages for negligence, dependency claim in custodial death

Three-member bench allows government’s appeal to set aside Ipoh High Court’s decision

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 24 Jun 2021 4:30PM

July 7 decision on quantum of damages for negligence, dependency claim in custodial death
The family of general worker Kamarulnizam Ismail, who was found dead in Tapah Prison in 2014, have been awarded special damages of RM10,000 and has their appeal for damages for the dependency claim allowed. – The Vibes file pic, June 24, 2021

PUTRAJAYA – The Court of Appeal has deferred to July 7 to decide on the quantum of damages for negligence and dependency claim to be awarded to the family of general worker Kamarulnizam Ismail, who was found dead in Tapah Prison in 2014.

A three-member bench led by justice Datuk Yaacob Md Sam fixed the date after allowing parties in the appeal to file further written submissions on the quantum of damages for negligence and the quantum of damages for dependency claim by June 30.

Lawyer M. Visvanathan is representing Rahaya Salleh, the mother of the deceased, while senior federal counsels Azizan Md Arshad, Andi Razali Jaya A. Dadi, and Mohd Ashraf Abd Hamid appeared for the police, the prison officials, and the Malaysian government.

In today’s proceedings conducted virtually, the Court of Appeal bench allowed the government’s appeal to set aside the Ipoh High Court’s decision to award the family RM100,000 in damages for unlawful detention and RM50,000 for misfeasance in public office.

Justice Yaacob, presiding with justices Datuk Ahmad Nasfy Yasin and Datuk M. Gunalan, awarded the family special damages of RM10,000 and increased the legal costs for the lower court’s proceedings awarded to the family from RM12,000 to RM30,000.

The bench also allowed the family’s appeal for damages for the dependency claim.

The court, however, upheld the high court’s decision to find the respondents liable for negligence.

Visvanathan told the court that the deceased’s family is seeking RM71,400 for dependency claim and RM250,000 as damages for negligence.

Azizan, however, said that the damages for the dependency claim should be RM27,685.44.

In August 2019, the high court held the defendants were liable for negligence and awarded Kamarulnizam’s family RM100,000 for his unlawful detention and RM50,000 for misfeasance of public office.

Then judicial commissioner Anslem Charles Fernandis (now high court judge) said Kamarulnizam, 39, was kept at the Seberang Prai police station lock-up for two days before being transported to the Tapah Prison.

The judge described Kamarulnizam’s stay in the lock-up as unlawful detention because under Section 282 of the Criminal Procedure Code it was mandatory, whenever there is an order, for police officers to act within a reasonable time to transport those found guilty to the prison, and not after two days.

Justice Fernandis also said warden officers in Tapah prison should have kept an eye on Kamarulnizam and be more vigilant after he was given medication for diarrhoea.

The magistrate’s court in Penang had given Kamarulnizam a fine of RM800 in default 14 days’ jail after he pleaded guilty to committing offences under Section 29 of the Minor Offences Act 1957 and Section 89 of the Police Act 1967.

Kamarulnizam, who was working in a sugar refinery in Penang, reported that he chose to serve the jail term as he needed the money to repair his car, despite his father Ismail showing up at the court to settle the fine.

Rahaya, 71, filed the suit against the respondents on March 3, 2017, and sought for dependency claim, misfeasance of public office, aggravated, exemplary, and special damages. – Bernama, June 24, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 3w

Teresa Kok’s defamation suit: Akmal Saleh ordered to pay RM300,000

Malaysia / 4mth

Altantuya family’s appeal bid over RM1.4 million damages to be heard in October

Malaysia / 5mth

Papagomo ordered to pay RM280,000 in damages for defamation of Guan Eng, son (Updated)

Malaysia / 6mth

Girl who suffered brain damage due to negligence during birth awarded RM2.73m

Malaysia / 6mth

Court of Appeal: Emergency proclamations beyond judicial review

Malaysia / 6mth

Court rejects father's RM3 million claim in UUM student death

Spotlight

Malaysia

Loke urges PM to focus on reforms, not early election pressure

Malaysia

Melaka declares special holiday tomorrow, in recognition of the people's mandate

Malaysia

Ab Rauf retains Melaka leadership

Malaysia

Mahathir makes first major party appearance since Hasmah's death at Pejuang AGM

Malaysia

Perak Sultan warns against shielding rulers from people's grievances

Malaysia

Retiree loses RM80k after WhatsApp investment scam demands RM50k to release profits

Health

Selangor health clinics prioritise emergency cases regardless of patients’ nationality

Malaysia

Some 243,501 undocumented migrants sent home under Malaysia's repatriation programme

Malaysia

Police hunt 38-year-old man over fatal stabbing in Kota Kinabalu

You may be interested

Malaysia

Foreign woman found dead by river in Bidor suspected murdered

Malaysia

Malaysia's national identity drive to respect multicultural diversity, says Aaron

Malaysia

Loke urges PM to focus on reforms, not early election pressure

Malaysia

Amirudin: Selangor's RM489b economic ambition hinges on racial unity

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: Defeat leaves Bersama, Bersatu searching for political relevance

Malaysia

Missing 74-year-old windsurfer found dead off Tanjung Bungah

Malaysia

Mukhriz loses bid to block LHDN’s RM5m tax claim, must pursue statutory appeal

Malaysia

Umno-PAS alliance faces bigger test as GE16 brings leadership question into focus