Malaysia

Misleading parliamentary reply or media misreporting, says Guan Eng of Penang LRT loan snafu

Ex-finance minister denies he approved, secured secret RM2 billion loan guarantee to Penang last year, as claimed by Datuk Seri Najib Razak

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 01 Dec 2020 2:05PM

Misleading parliamentary reply or media misreporting, says Guan Eng of Penang LRT loan snafu
Former finance minister Lim Guan Eng (right) says no financial institution will consider evaluating a loan unless the green light has been given by the government. – Bernama pic, December 1, 2020

GEORGE TOWN – The dispute over Penang’s light rail transit (LRT) loan continues, with Lim Guan Eng saying there was either a misleading parliamentary reply or misreporting by the media, following a clarification by Finance Minister Datuk Seri Tengku Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz.

Earlier, it was reported that Putrajaya had cancelled its guarantee of a loan with the Asian Development Bank (ADB) for the project.

Tengku Zafrul yesterday told the Dewan Rakyat that the federal government did not withdraw Penang’s loan application, and that there had never been a government guarantee.

In a statement today, ex-finance minister Lim said Pekan MP Datuk Seri Najib Razak lied when he said the former had approved and secured a secret RM2 billion loan guarantee to Penang when he was in the cabinet last year.

“(Tengku) Zafrul said in Parliament that the due diligence report from ADB on the merits of the application for the loan by the Penang government to finance the LRT project has not been presented to the federal government. 

“He asserted that the federal government did not withdraw the guarantee as there is currently none, but it does not mean that the project has been scrapped.”

He added that ADB will only provide loans to countries, whether directly or indirectly, through a sovereign loan guarantee, regardless of the merits of the application.

“I would agree that there are other cheaper loans available, but this would be dependent on the willingness of the federal government to provide prior approvals. No financial institution will even consider evaluating a loan unless the green light is given first by the federal government.”

Meanwhile, Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow, in a statement, said he regrets the Finance Ministry’s stance on the state’s LRT loan.

He said former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, in a letter dated October 1, 2019, stated that bonds by the Penang government for related projects would be guaranteed by Putrajaya.

“The Penang government, however, will not give up. Instead, it will continue its efforts to implement the LRT project because it has several other financial options to fund projects under the Penang Transport Master Plan.”

He said the state will continue to inject confidence in the federal government to give priority to financing the said project.

“I have also shared this stance and conveyed it to Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Economy) Datuk Seri Mustapa Mohamed at a discussion session on the allocation of the 12th Malaysia Plan to Penang last Thursday in Kuala Lumpur.

“In fact, the same matter and stance were also stated to Finance Minister Datuk Seri Tengku Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz while attending the Budget 2021: Penang dialogue, organised by the Northern Corridor Implementation Authority on August 8, and the (Malaysia Plan) Preparation Involvement Session 12 with (International Trade and Industry Minister) Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali on August 2, 2019 in Penang.”

Last Wednesday, Tengku Zafrul, in a parliamentary reply to Chow (PH-Tanjong), said any new loan with a government guarantee should be scrutinised as much as possible because it would increase the government’s contingent liability.

He said the Finance Ministry received a letter from ADB dated January 25 last year regarding Penang’s loan application.

“In line with a review of the country’s GDP (gross domestic product) projections and the government’s focus on economic recovery post-Covid-19, the Finance Ministry has decided to not continue with the ADB loan amounting to US$500 million (RM2 billion) to finance the RM9.5 billion Penang LRT project.” – The Vibes, December 1, 2020

Related News

Off beat / 5d

Penang moves to strengthen position as green manufacturing hub

Events / 5d

Annie Tan looks to keep traditional Asian flavours relevant through modern dining

Community / 1w

Penang looks towards AI for greater sustainability

Events / 1w

PBAPP receives strong support for purchase of treated water

Malaysia / 1w

Interests of Penang and Perak protected under water agreement, says Exco member

Lifestyle / 1w

Chet Singh, a pioneer of Penang's industrial development, dies at 90

Spotlight

Malaysia

Geopolitical tensions must not derail regional economic integration - Anwar

Malaysia

Najib has been given a second chance. But where is the accountability to Malaysians?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

PAS joins BN in sitting out Sarawak polls

Malaysia

PAC to probe possible financial breaches, abuse of power in Sabah Pan Borneo project

Malaysia

Landowners cannot demolish unauthorised places of worship themselves, says Nga

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Differing views do not constitute treason – lawyer

Malaysia

Suspected criminal shot dead in exchange of fire with police in Perak

You may be interested

Malaysia

Police uncover alleged air route used to smuggle drugs to Sabah, 11 arrested

Malaysia

Two RMAF personnel remanded in drug smuggling case

Malaysia

Geopolitical tensions must not derail regional economic integration - Anwar

Malaysia

Man who sodomised, killed baby under his care sentenced to death by hanging

Malaysia

Malaysians urged to update phones to avoid missing emergency alerts

Malaysia

Police probe after two foreign children found playing outside Subang Jaya apartment window

Malaysia

No tsunami threat to Malaysia after 5.3-magnitude earthquake off Sumatra

Malaysia

MCMC denies viral claims of public early warning system test in four states