Murray Hunter
PKR, just like in the 2021 state election, didn’t win any seats in the recent Melaka state election.
Many pundits are claiming this is because of the growing dissatisfaction with the Madani Government and PKR’s leadership.
However, the truth is much deeper than this. The popularity of PKR has been slowly eroding for a decade now.
Just go through the last three federal elections, and the trend is very clear.
The real problem is PKR itself. The party started with a strong ‘reformasi’ doctrine at the beginning of this century.
A doctrine many believed would give birth to a new Malaysia, or bring a second Merdeka, as many felt back in 2018 and again in 2022.
However, this hasn’t occurred, and that’s the problem when people’s hopes are much higher than the realities.
Malaysian political society and its institutions are so complex, ‘reformasi’ in the way many Malaysians believe could happen is more a far-off dream, because of the deep barriers to change.
In contrast, Sarawak is rapidly changing because it is a single interconnected territory, where the elite all agree with what is being done.
This is not the same case federally.
PKR grew earlier on, which attracted some of the best reform-minded people in the nation.
However, this rubbed against paternalism within the party, leading to a number of major splits.
Today, inside PKR, the administration is more on the authoritarian side, which is holding back the organization’s evolution.
It's certainly time for the middle leadership of PKR to rediscover their ‘reformasi’ personas and become the people that many Malaysians respected when they were in opposition.
If a party doesn’t believe in itself, how can Malaysians take the party seriously again?
PKR’s projected performance in the coming general election is going to be dismal, as many pundits are suggesting.
However, if the leadership of the party are silent (leaving it all to one man), those dismal results will certainly materialise.
The key to PKR being able to have any success in the coming GE is for the leadership to rediscover what PKR really is and pass on this passion back to the rank and file.
It's now all up to PKR’s leadership; they have no one else to blame. – November 16, 2026