HRW calls for Egypt sanctions over ‘extrajudicial executions’

BEIRUT – The group Human Rights Watch accused Egypt today of routinely killing opponents in “unlawful extrajudicial executions” made to look like shoot-outs and urged international sanctions against Cairo.

Citing Interior Ministry figures, the New York-based rights group found that at least 755 people were killed in 143 alleged shoot-outs – with only one suspect arrested.

“Egyptian security forces have for years carried out extrajudicial executions, claiming that the men had been killed in shoot-outs,” HRW said.

The group’s compilation of Interior Ministry statements covered the period from January 2015 until December 2020.

“The alleged armed militants killed in the so-called shoot-outs did not pose an imminent danger to security forces or others when they were killed and in many cases had already been in custody,” the group claimed in its 101-page report.

The rights group said that in most of the statements authorities had claimed that suspected militants opened fire first, compelling security forces to shoot back. 

Authorities alleged that all those killed were sought for “terrorism” and most belonged to the Muslim Brotherhood.

The Muslim Brotherhood, one of Egypt’s oldest political movements with spin-offs around the Muslim world, was outlawed as a “terrorist organisation’ in 2013 following the military ouster of Islamist president Mohamed Morsi.

President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, who led the military takeover in 2013 and came to power in 2014, has overseen a wide-ranging crackdown against dissidents, from Islamists to secular activists.

HRW interviewed relatives, lawyers, activists and a journalist on the specific cases of 14 men who it says were slain in extrajudicial killings. 

“Members of eight families said they saw what they believed were signs of abuse on the bodies of their killed relatives, including burns, cuts, broken bones, or dislocated teeth,” the report noted. 

“The conclusions drawn from the documented incidents demonstrate a clear pattern of unlawful killings and cast serious doubt on almost all reported ‘shoot-outs’,” it added.

HRW recommended Egypt's international partners “halt weapons transfers...and impose sanctions against the security agencies and officials most responsible for ongoing abuses”.

In March, 31 countries staged a rare rebuke of Egypt at the UN Human Rights Council, expressing alarm over its use of anti-terrorism laws against government critics. – AFP, September 7, 2021