Malaysia

Standing orders can’t supersede constitution, legal expert tells Art Harun

Dewan Rakyat rules are not law, says Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 15 Oct 2020 2:23PM

Standing orders can’t supersede constitution, legal expert tells Art Harun
A law expert says the Dewan Rakyat speaker should not use the standing orders as an excuse to not allow the motion of no-confidence against the prime minister. – The Vibes file pic, October 15, 2020

by Azril Annuar

KUALA LUMPUR – The Dewan Rakyat speaker should not be using the parliamentary standing orders to reject the no-confidence motion against the prime minister, said law expert Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi.

He told The Vibes that the standing orders are merely rules to regulate Dewan Rakyat proceedings and cannot override Article 43(4) of the Federal Constitution.

“The standing orders are not even ‘law’ but internal rules of the House. They were not passed by Parliament and do not qualify as law.

“The standing orders cannot override Article 43(4) of the Federal Constitution that deals with the issue of loss of confidence.

“The issue of confidence is not an internal matter but goes to the heart of a parliamentary democracy,” said Shad Saleem in a WhatsApp message.

Yesterday, Dewan Rakyat Speaker Datuk Azhar Azizan Harun had confirmed receiving a letter from Gua Musang MP Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah, dated September 24, questioning why the no-confidence motion was not debated during the previous sitting between July 13 and August 27.

Tengku Razaleigh, popularly known as Ku Li, had also urged Azhar to guarantee that a motion of no-confidence against Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin could be tabled in the Dewan Rakyat.

Later, in the statement, Azhar said a no-confidence motion would not take precedence if it was not received by a minister.

“I must point out that the no-confidence motion in the Dewan Rakyat’s standing orders is not unique to the system that we practice.

“In fact, the system practiced in Australia is almost similar to ours, where a no-confidence motion would not be expedited if it was not received by a minister,” he had said. – The Vibes, October 15, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 4mth

PM term limit: 'It starts with me' - Anwar

Malaysia / 5mth

Dewan Rakyat passes International Mediation Bill

Malaysia / 5mth

Government completes repayment of RM22.45b in overpaid taxes last year - highest in 5 years

Malaysia / 5mth

PM: Malaysia recorded 4.9 per cent GDP growth in 2025, surpassing official projections 

Malaysia / 5mth

Malaysia's 2025 economic performance to be debated in Dewan Rakyat today

Malaysia / 6mth

Parliament convenes Monday with spotlight on King’s address

Spotlight

Malaysia

PRN Negeri Sembilan: The battlegrounds, big names and three-cornered fights to watch

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

People

Woman ends up with RM500 over food bill after date with ‘doctor’

Malaysia

Love scam: Twelve China nationals arrested in Ipoh over suspected online call centres

Malaysia

ASLI to field female candidate in Jeram Padang DUN

Community

‘Furry officer’ laid to rest as Kuching traffic police mourn beloved stray cat (video)

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Father mauled by crocodile as son watches in horror in Sabah river (UPDATED)

Malaysia

Johor shuts down Forest City Network School premises

Malaysia

Singapore: Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon to retire in Feb 2027, succeeded by Justice Sushil Nair

You may be interested

Malaysia

KWAP intructs full internal review after eFishery financial misconduct case

Malaysia

Negeri Sembilan poll race begins as nominations kick off

Malaysia

PRN Negeri Sembilan: Four seats in focus, battle expected to be tougher than Johor

Malaysia

Bersatu ‘messing things up’ for BN, PN candidates, claims Wan Saiful

Malaysia

MACC opens probe into KWAP'S RM200 million eFishery investment

Malaysia

“Resign if you attack fellow Unity Government partners,” Anwar enforces discipline

Malaysia

Love scam: Twelve China nationals arrested in Ipoh over suspected online call centres

Malaysia

PH youth wing calls on BN ministers to quit cabinet over PN electoral alliance