Malaysia

S’gor health director wrong to blame factories, look at infection source: FMM

Tan Sri Soh Thian Lai adds news reports that don’t give full picture contribute to misunderstanding of Covid-19 situation

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 07 Aug 2021 8:00AM

S’gor health director wrong to blame factories, look at infection source: FMM
The majority of Covid-19 infections now are sporadic cases, and so, it is unfair to cite factories as a major contributor to the virus’ spread, says the FMM president. – Bernama pic, August 7, 2021

by Saktesh Subramaniam

KUALA LUMPUR – The Federation of Malaysian Manufacturers (FMM) has expressed deep concern about the misconception that factories are the primary source of Covid-19 infections.

President Tan Sri Soh Thian Lai told The Vibes this misunderstanding is largely due to news reports that do not paint the full picture.

His comments follow Selangor health director Datuk Dr Sha’ari Ngadiman’s statement yesterday that the majority of clusters in Selangor stem from the sector.

He cited Dr Sha’ari, who said “checks conducted by the Health Ministry showed that factories are allowed to operate in the state if they adhere strictly to the SOPs”. 

“In this regard, we wish to stress that, as widely reported based on MoH data, the majority – almost 70% – of Covid-19 cases now are sporadic cases, while clusters contribute to the balance of 30%,” said Soh.

Quoting Heath Director-General Tan Sri Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah, he said among all cases nationwide, of which 30% are cluster-based, 62% are workplace clusters, with factories making up only 30% of this figure.

“Based on the health director’s data in Selangor, almost 50% of workplace clusters are from factories. However, he did not state the number of cases that clusters account for.

It must be noted that the majority of overall Covid-19 cases are still from sporadic cases, and factories are not the main source of infections.”

Based on FMM’s analysis, daily new cases from June 1 to August 4 that are cluster-based ranged between 3% and 19% of total infections.

New factory-related cluster cases in the same period ranged between 0.3% and 8.3% of the overall number, said Soh.

FMM president Tan Sri Soh Thian Lai says despite the SOPs in place, the coronavirus can still enter factories, especially through asymptomatic cases. – FMM pic, August 7, 2021
FMM president Tan Sri Soh Thian Lai says despite the SOPs in place, the coronavirus can still enter factories, especially through asymptomatic cases. – FMM pic, August 7, 2021

“It is very clear that cases linked to clusters, especially factory clusters, are low in comparison with overall cases.”

He said one of the challenges faced by the industry is managing the entry of infections into factories and worker hostels.

“Despite the SOPs and preventive measures in place, the virus can still enter factories, especially through asymptomatic cases.

“These sources are often not traced back to the communities where they most likely originated from. Instead, they are linked to factories due to the fact that they were detected there through the daily targeted screening of workers.”

This is not the first time Soh has defended the industry from accusations that it is a primary source of the coronavirus’ spread.

SME Association of Malaysia president Datuk Michael Kang, too, disagrees with Dr Sha’ari’s statement.

“Where do Covid-19 cases from the manufacturing sector originate from? They all come from community clusters.

“The government should focus on controlling the spread of Covid-19, preventing it from entering the manufacturing sector.”

The industry is not a major source of clusters, he said, calling on the Health Ministry to focus on curbing the virus’ spread in the community and via social activities. – The Vibes, August 7, 2021 

Related News

Malaysia / 18h

Man posing as Selangor crown prince’s aide arrested over RM960,020 scam

Malaysia / 5d

Individual posing as aide to Raja Muda of Selangor causes RM700,000 in losses

Malaysia / 2w

Selangor postpones National Sports Day celebrations due to haze

Malaysia / 3w

Bersama’s Selangor target difficult to achieve if party goes solo, says analyst

Malaysia / 1mth

27 stations record unhealthy API readings; six locations in Selangor affected

Education / 1mth

Selangor to close schools if API readings exceed 200

Spotlight

Education

Schools to get extra holidays for Deepavali

Malaysia

Getting angry at your wife for buying items online is a form of abuse, says minister

Malaysia

Man posing as Selangor crown prince’s aide arrested over RM960,020 scam

Malaysia

Dr Mahathir leaves late wife’s tahlil ceremony after feeling unwell

Malaysia

Chegubard jailed four months for defaming King

Malaysia

Court to hear Najib’s bid to revive RM1.9m suit against former AG on Nov 26

Malaysia

Malaysia climbs to 15th in global competitiveness rankings

Education

MOE: Close to 49,000 Year One pupils failed to master basic literacy and numeracy in 2025

You may be interested

Malaysia

Battersea project’s high upfront cost led to losses for Malaysian investors, says Anwar

Malaysia

Police officer jailed 7½ years over death of Form Five student in Ipoh

Malaysia

Man posing as Selangor crown prince’s aide arrested over RM960,020 scam

Malaysia

Political funding bill recommendations to go before select committee

Malaysia

Water woes threaten SG4’s RM723.75b economic ambition - Economy Minister

Malaysia

Rayer questions decision to probe custodial death under Section 331 instead of murder

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Dewan Rakyat: RM20.1b 1MDB burden, BUDI95 subsidy cuts face scrutiny

Malaysia

MCA settles for two seats in Melaka state election