Malaysia

Citizens will be disenfranchised if emergency declared, warn ex-Bar Council presidents

Seven legal experts say existing laws sufficient to contain virus crisis

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 24 Oct 2020 3:35PM

Citizens will be disenfranchised if emergency declared, warn ex-Bar Council presidents
Seven former Bar Council presidents say movement controls and other measures already implemented against Covid-19 are enough to beat back the pandemic. – The Vibes file pic, October 24, 2020

KUALA LUMPUR – The government can rely on existing laws to handle the coronavirus crisis, said seven former Bar Council presidents in response to rumours that a state of emergency will be declared.

Zainur Zakaria, Kuthubul Zaman, Yeo Yang Poh, Ambiga Sreenevasan, Ragunath Kesavan, Christopher Leong and Steven Thiru, in a join statement, warned that using emergency powers with the purpose of suspending Parliament may lead to citizens being disenfranchised.

“Covid-19 can be properly battled using existing laws. The effective measures undertaken to overcome the first wave earlier this year are a testament to the absence of any need for a declaration of emergency.”

Putrajaya is now using the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988 to impose measures to curb the disease’s spread, including the imposition of several iterations of movement controls.

The seven pointed to a 2019 UK case, R (Miller) v The Prime Minister, which saw the British top court ruling that the judiciary can interfere in Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s bid to discontinue a parliamentary session.

“Our constitution, to be able to continue protecting citizens, is always a living document in need of purposive construction by the courts,” said the statement.

“If it shall come to that, we are confident that the judiciary will rise to the occasion.” – The Vibes, October 24, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Malaysia / 1mth

Malaysian doctor couple saves passenger from allergic shock mid-flight

Malaysia / 4mth

Bad move to channel EPF dividends into Account 3 for festive withdrawals, cautions economist

Malaysia / 5mth

Malaysia Airlines flight MH21 declares emergency in French airspace (Updated)

Opinion / 8mth

A tale of two administrations: How Warisan and GRS shaped Sabah’s future

Malaysia / 9mth

MH102 diverted to Bangkok due to passenger health emergency

Spotlight

Opinion

Ronnie Liu: What we should truly rejoice over is not the victory of any single party

Sports & Fitness

Ronaldo silences critics with historic World Cup double as Portugal cruise to victory

Malaysia

Foreign student held as police probe suspected murder of female student

Malaysia

Student seen crying with hair pulled in alleged bullying incident (video)

Malaysia

Indonesian woman jailed 6 years for trafficking teenager for sexual exploitation in Tawau

Malaysia

Govt's 2026 fuel subsidy expense may reach RM37.2b despite Budi Madani diesel savings

Malaysia

Johor PRN: Maszlee accepts invitation to debate with Onn Hafiz

Malaysia

Home Ministry: Synthetic drugs now a major threat; East Coast most affected

Malaysia

Drug-positive man crashes into Terengganu Hospital emergency zone glass door

Malaysia

Bar Council voices reservations over planned split of AGC and prosecutor roles

You may be interested

Malaysia

Some writing attributed to Zara not written by teenager - expert

Malaysia

Bar Council voices reservations over planned split of AGC and prosecutor roles

Malaysia

Teen driver sent to Henry Gurney school for three years over fatal Seremban crash

Malaysia

Drug-positive man crashes into Terengganu Hospital emergency zone glass door

Malaysia

Home Ministry: Synthetic drugs now a major threat; East Coast most affected

Malaysia

Court grants interim injunction against Papagomo over alleged harmful online content

Malaysia

Govt continues negotiations with US over reciprocal tariffs - Johari

Malaysia

Nation strengthens economic defences as global conflict and El Niño threats loom