Malaysia

Translation issues mar Bali bombings trial of 2 Malaysians, Hambali

Lawyers argue over impartiality of interpreters provided by US military

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 31 Aug 2021 9:30AM

Translation issues mar Bali bombings trial of 2 Malaysians, Hambali
(From left) Encep Nurjaman, also known as Hambali, Mohammed Nazir Lep and Mohammed Farik Amin were arrested in Thailand in August 2003 and sent to a secret CIA prison network before being moved to Guantanamo in September 2006. – File pic, August 31, 2021

WASHINGTON – The issue with interpreters overshadowed much of the trial of the three suspects involved in the November 2002 Bali bombings, with lawyers arguing over impartiality of the translators provided.

Lawyers representing Malaysian duo Mohammed Nazir Lep and Mohammed Farik Amin also questioned the interpreter’s proficiency.

Lawyer Christine Funk said her client, Farik, expressed frustration about the translations, reported Indonesian news portal BenarNews.

She was quoted as saying that he is not proficient in English but was “forced to listen to two languages”.

Meanwhile, lawyer James Hodes, representing Indonesian Encep Nurjaman, also known as Hambali, said the Indonesian interpreter should be removed from the case, alleging that the translator was not impartial.

“The Indonesian interpreter has made statements that these guys are all terrorists and should be killed,” Hodes told the judge. “That’s just one of the reasons.”

The lawyer also asked for the proceedings to be recorded and put on the record.

“I can give you my cellphone and they can start recording.”

Hambali had also requested that he be represented by an Indonesian lawyer.

The interpreters are provided by the American military.

Military judge Commander Hayes Larsen told the lawyers to “respond slowly so we can get an accurate interpretation”.

“I want to ensure that the accused understands all that is happening.”

It was reported that the hearing was adjourned to today after a prosecutor read out the general charges against the three defendants. The defendants have yet to enter a plea.

The arraignment was viewed remotely from a US army base near here, under media arrangements provided by the Office of Military Commissions. No photographs or videos were allowed during the proceedings.

A charge sheet uploaded by the US Office of Military Commissions showed that the Malaysians face nine charges and Hambali, eight, in relation to their alleged roles in the terrorist attacks.

All three will be charged with conspiracy, attempted murder, murder, intentionally causing serious bodily injury, terrorism, destruction of property, and attacking civilians and civilian objects.

The charges do not carry the death penalty.

The trio were arrested in Thailand in August 2003 and sent to a secret CIA prison network before being moved to Guantanamo in September 2006.

The Malaysians were also implicated in an al-Qaeda plot to crash a hijacked plane into the 73-storey US Bank Tower, also known as the Library Tower, in Los Angeles.

Hambali has been described as “an operational mastermind for Jemaah Islamiyah, a Southeast Asian militant group affiliated with al-Qaeda”.

The Malaysian duo were also described as Hambali’s top aides in JI who had undergone training by al-Qaeda, according to Guantanamo case documents.

He was among those responsible for organising the September 11, 2001 attacks in the US.

The US also alleged that Hambali met Osama bin Laden in 1996 in Afghanistan.

The charges were announced on the first full day of the administration of President Joe Biden.

When Biden was Barack Obama’s vice-president, they sought, but failed, to close the navy-run prison in Guantanamo, and had remaining prisoners either released or tried in US civilian courts. – The Vibes, August 31, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Man jailed for 9 months after admitting to stealing women's undergarments at laundromat

Malaysia / 1w

10 former Negeri Excos file application in Federal Court to challenge revocation of appointments

Malaysia / 1w

UK academic fights to be allowed to leave Malaysia for father’s funeral

Malaysia / 1w

Haze: Details of Malaysia’s aid to Indonesia to be finalised this Monday – Fahmi

Malaysia / 2w

Is Malaysia 'soft' in tackling the haze? The government has done everything it possibly can – PM Anwar

Malaysia / 4w

High Court allows Anwar's bid to hear preliminary issues first

Spotlight

Off beat

Paya Terubong landslide: MBPP submits draft report

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Bersatu, Muda sign CSA with Madani govt to back Budget 2027

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Syndicate using AI-generated 'Datuk' woman to deceive public

Malaysia

MIPP withdraws from Melaka polls after failed negotiations with PN

Malaysia

Thirteen suspended Bersatu MPs may be excluded from MADANI government deal

Malaysia

Selangor Sultan urges scholars to speak truth, leaders to respect constructive criticism

Malaysia

691 teachers flagged for immediate psychological intervention, says Fadhlina

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Anwar urges political unity as Bersatu backs Budget 2027

Malaysia

Malaysia removes 828,000 online gambling posts, blocks 7,411 websites

Malaysia

Appellate Court reserves decision on Sabah's 40% revenue entitlement appeal

Malaysia

Anwar rebukes those who brand fellow Muslims as hypocrites, apostates

Malaysia

PN yet to name Kota Laksamana candidate after MIPP's last-minute withdrawal

Malaysia

Education Minister: 5,681 school bullying cases recorded in first eight months of 2026

Malaysia

Mohd Shuhaily returns to police force from border agency

Malaysia

Bersatu, Muda sign CSA with Madani govt to back Budget 2027

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir