Malaysia

Chasing nirvana, woman seeks court order to leave Islam

Lawyer says client has exhausted all avenues in shariah system to leave faith

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 14 Apr 2022 9:00AM

Chasing nirvana, woman seeks court order to leave Islam
Lawyer Fahri Azzat, who is representing the woman, says the case differs from previous similar cases, as his client is turning to the civil court system in her bid to renounce Islam only after having exhausted her options in the shariah court system. – AFP pic, April 13, 2022

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – A 32-year-old woman has filed a civil suit against the federal government and religious authorities in a bid to renounce Islam so that she can convert to Confucianism and Buddhism.

Lawyer Fahri Azzat, who is representing the woman, said the case will be a test for establishing freedom of religion for Muslims in Malaysia, where apostasy is rejected by the government.

He said his client’s case differs from previous attempts to secure the legal right to leave Islam, as she had already made a prior attempt through the shariah court system.

“Previous cases they went to the civil courts first. In our situation, my client went to the shariah court and the shariah appeals court as well,” Fahri told The Vibes.

We exhausted the shariah process, and they are still not letting her go.”

In her application for a judicial review at the high court, the woman – born to Muslim parents – said she had never practised Islam, as neither of her parents, who are divorced, had practised the religion.

She said her parents had given her free rein to determine her own faith, which she said she found in Confucianism and Buddhism through which she hopes to attain nirvana or a state of enlightenment.

The woman said in her affidavit that she routinely consumes food and beverages considered “haram” such as pork and alcoholic drinks.

She said she first filed an application to leave Islam at the shariah court in August 2018. The court instructed her to attend 12 faith counselling sessions from January to June the following year, pending her trial.

Lawyer Fahri Azzat, who is representing the woman, says the case will be a test for establishing freedom of religion for Muslims in Malaysia, where apostasy is rejected by the government. – LB Training pic, April 14, 2022
Lawyer Fahri Azzat, who is representing the woman, says the case will be a test for establishing freedom of religion for Muslims in Malaysia, where apostasy is rejected by the government. – LB Training pic, April 14, 2022

During her trial, her mother and a close friend presented oral evidence of her Buddhist faith before the shariah court, which later dismissed her application in July 2020 and ordered her to attend further faith counselling sessions.

The woman said the shariah court dismissed her case on grounds that Article 11 of the federal constitution, which provides for freedom of religion, does not apply to Muslims, and that her failure to adhere to Islamic principles was a matter of “dosa dan pahala” or sin and reward and does not negate her faith.

Fahri said his client’s application differs from the attempt by Lina Joy, whose case led to a landmark ruling in 2007 by the Federal Court, which stated that a person intending to renounce their current faith and convert to another religion must do so according to existing laws.

He noted that Lina Joy, who sought to officially leave Islam so she could convert to Christianity, had brought her case directly to the civil court instead of first going through the shariah system.

Everyone is labouring under the idea that you have to go to the shariah courts to get the (conversion) order. But from this case, we can show they are not interested in doing that either,” Fahri said.

“I hope this is the case that nails the fact that there’s freedom of religion for Muslims too.”

Fahri said the high court is scheduled to decide on whether to grant leave for his client’s application on April 27. – The Vibes, April 14, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Najib expected to return home today to begin house arrest, says Shafee

Opinion / 2w

FT compulsory land acquisition laws under scrutiny once again

Malaysia / 1mth

High Court allows Anwar's bid to hear preliminary issues first

Malaysia / 2mth

British management on trial – does a royal management institute deliver value?

Malaysia / 3mth

Court quashes RM313.8 million tax bill against Na’imah

Malaysia / 4mth

High Court court allows contempt proceedings against Undangs, two others

Spotlight

Malaysia

MB’s resignation: “I was not informed” – Jalaluddin

Malaysia

Ismail’s resignation raises various questions: Work of hidden hands?

Malaysia

Padang Rengas dispute exposes challenge facing possible BN-PN pact

Malaysia

Khalid urges Anwar to reject Anthony Loke’s resignation amid political uncertainty

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Zahid: One name submitted for new Negeri MB

Malaysia

Viral abuse video leads to murder charge against couple in father's death

You may be interested

Malaysia

NS Palace: MB's resignation not confirmed, royal consent required

Malaysia

Suspected fake Selangor Crown Prince aide jailed, caned over RM185,000 cheating cases

Malaysia

Conspiracy to oust Tuanku Muhriz has failed; time to seek forgiveness, say MPs

Malaysia

Police probe claims Nigerian syndicate using student visas to recruit members in Malaysia

Malaysia

Kuching student accused of attacking teacher with a deadly weapon sent for mental observation

Malaysia

Businessman urges MPOB to provide details of palm oil mixing probe

Malaysia

1MDB’s burden will outlive the generation that witnessed its rise

Malaysia

Anwar praises Macron’s ‘courageous conscience’ on Gaza, Palestine