Malaysia

Respect all views: Wan Fayhsal defends Idris’ remarks on Bon Odori, Oktoberfest

Such festivals not indigenous to Malaysian culture anyway, says deputy minister

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 03 Aug 2022 12:58PM

Respect all views: Wan Fayhsal defends Idris’ remarks on Bon Odori, Oktoberfest
Wah Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal said that the government has not used the law to obstruct anyone's freedom to practice their culture. – Bernama pic, August 3, 2022

by Amar Shah Mohsen

KUALA LUMPUR – Bersatu’s Wan Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal defended Religious Affairs Minister Datuk Idris Ahmad’s warning to the public of the “danger” of celebrating events like Bon Odori and Oktoberfest. 

The deputy national unity minister told the Dewan Rakyat today that Idris’ views should be respected, in the spirit of accepting different views.

“In fact, Bon Odori and Oktoberfest are not even indigenous to us and are not part of our society’s culture originally.

“And even if there are differences, the minister has expressed his views, and I feel we should respect that. 

“I would also like to point out that we (government) did not use the law to obstruct anyone's freedom to practice their culture.

“In this regard, I feel there is nothing wrong with what the religious minister said, both as a Muslim and as the individual responsible for religious authority,” Wan Fayhsal said.

He was responding to a supplementary question from Lim Guan Eng (Bagan-PH) on the National Unity Ministry’s stand over previous comments made by Idris. 

Specifically, the DAP lawmaker said the PAS vice-president had interfered with the cultural life of non-Muslims in the country when he commented on Bon Odori and Oktoberfest. 

This is after Idris, in a written parliamentary reply to Lim last week, said beer festivals like Oktoberfest should not be openly celebrated as it could lead to social problems. 

He said this is because alcohol can affect the harmony, order, and safety of the community, and reminded all parties to respect the rules and regulations of Malaysia, which has Islam as the religion of the federation.

In the same reply, Idris also said the government had not stopped the Japanese Bon Odori festival from taking place on July 16, but had merely urged Muslims against attending events he deemed contrary to Islamic teachings.  

On June 6, Idris advised Muslims not to participate in the Bon Odori festival held at the Shah Alam Sports Complex, as the festival “contains elements of other religions”.

In a rebuke, Selangor ruler Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah suggested Idris attend the festival himself to see the difference between culture and religion, and told the minister to stop using Jakim to issue confusing and inaccurate statements. – The Vibes, August 3, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 3y

Govt fumes after TV Alhijrah airs old show with ex-minister from PAS

Food / 3y

Germany’s booze-free beer boom

Malaysia / 3y

Perikatan hopes for post-election deal with Umno

Malaysia / 3y

Perikatan seat talks for state polls close to half-done: PAS

Malaysia / 3y

Is it a crime to show support for Muhyiddin, Wan Fayhsal bemoans probe into gathering

Malaysia / 3y

[UPDATED] Muhyiddin nothing like Najib, says Wan Fayhsal

Spotlight

Malaysia

Papagomo acquitted for second time in sedition case over government, Israel claims

Malaysia

ECRL fares start at RM60, with 50% discounts for children, seniors and OKU

Malaysia

DKU seeks court action against Ismail, 16 others over Negeri Sembilan royal dispute

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Kampung Manis: Dreams of 227 families to own replacement homes draw closer

Malaysia

Fadhlina takes legal action over video of 2023 Parliament speech

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Civil servants urged to turn Selangor Sultan’s anti-graft message into action

Malaysia

Animal welfare group urges probe into alleged sexual abuse of cat in viral video

Malaysia

Macron appeals for calm after France riots: 2,400 arrested, nearly 1,000 officers injured

Malaysia

Malaysia renews offer to help Indonesia fight fires

You may be interested

Malaysia

Anwar: Malaysia still owes RM8.9b in 1MDB liabilities

Malaysia

Sarawak deputy premier warns of increasing threats of vaping

Malaysia

Malaysia’s baby bust: A silent crisis threatening the nation’s future prosperity

Malaysia

Johor hotspots lead Malaysia’s haze tally as 25 localities record unhealthy air

Malaysia

Father, daughter killed after container crushes car in Sabah

Malaysia

PKR restructures Sarawak leadership to strengthen election machinery

Malaysia

Hajiji urges GRS leaders to put Sabah first, warns against infighting

Malaysia

Fadhlina takes legal action over video of 2023 Parliament speech

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir