Malaysia

Islam forbids ‘Robin Hood’ acts: ex-PAS MP

Ends do not justify means according to Islam, says Datuk Mohd Khairuddin Aman Razali

Updated 1 year ago · Published on 23 Jan 2023 12:25PM

Islam forbids ‘Robin Hood’ acts: ex-PAS MP
Datuk Mohd Khairuddin Aman Razali notes that in Islam, the legitimacy of an act depends on two conditions, namely the right intention and manifested action that conform to shariah. – Bernama pic, January 23, 2023

KUALA LUMPUR – Former PAS leader Datuk Mohd Khairuddin Aman Razali, who is now with Umno, has issued a general reminder that stealing with the ultimate intention of helping the poor by way of sedekah (alms) is prohibited by Islam. 

He pointed out that the religion rules that the end does not justify the means if a particular action is not done in accordance with Islamic teaching. 

“Is it halal to rob with the intention of giving alms to the poor like Robin Hood? In Islam, the legitimacy of an act depends on two conditions, namely the right intention and manifested action that conform to shariah. 

“An illegal act does not become legal and halal merely because of good intentions,” he said in a brief post on his Facebook yesterday. 

“However, an intention can change in status from neutral (harus) to recommended (sunat), reprehensible (makruh), or forbidden (haram).”

Citing a quote from an ulama, the former Kuala Nerus MP added that “all practices are based on intention”. 

While he did not mention any names, Khairuddin’s statement comes in light of PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang’s remark that the cash handouts distributed to voters during the 15th general election are a charitable act. 

The Marang MP also claimed that the alms were courtesy of public donations and not distributed directly by election candidates. 

Previously, Barisan Nasional had filed election petitions for three parliamentary seats alleging vote buying during the campaigning period, including for the Marang constituency.

Perikatan Nasional, which includes PAS, has been accused by various quarters of misappropriating billions of ringgit in public money during its time in federal power to help fund its election campaign. 

The Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission has already initiated an investigation into the matter, with its probe focusing on the RM92.5 billion in government funds allegedly abused under the previous administration.

Last month, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim said that officials from the Finance Ministry have confirmed serious breaches of procedure in the handling of public funds under former prime minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin’s rule. – The Vibes, January 23, 2023

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Canteen operations during Ramadan won’t hurt students’ faith, MCA tells PAS

Malaysia / 1mth

Stop politicising school canteen issue, MP tells PAS

Malaysia / 1mth

Order for school canteens to operate during Ramadan ‘excessive’: PAS

Malaysia / 1mth

PAS-led K’tan assembly slammed for passing shariah laws struck down by apex court

Malaysia / 1mth

Selangor Sultan expresses deep regret over Abdul Hadi's statement

Malaysia / 2mth

Do not politicise Federal Court ruling on Kelantan shariah code: Zahid

Spotlight

Malaysia

KLIA shooting suspect arrested in Kota Baru, says IGP

Malaysia

Sarawak to develop 10 river basins for hydropower

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

KLIA police to use e-scooters to speed up response time, boost patrols

Malaysia

Budget hotels to raise rates by up to 40%

By Noel Achariam

Malaysia

45 heat-related illness cases reported nationwide

Malaysia

Surrender now, police tells KLIA gunman

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

PBS, Sabah STAR to enter pact

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

PKR Youth condemns attack against Iranian diplomatic complex

Malaysia

KLIA shooting suspect arrested in Kota Baru, says IGP

Malaysia

KLIA shooting suspect detained for 7 days

Malaysia

Sarawak native rights group complains it was not consulted about dams

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Bank worker union calls for better staff treatment, facilities

Malaysia

Guns being smuggled into Malaysia despite tight border surveillance

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Sarawak to develop 10 river basins for hydropower

By Stephen Then