Malaysia

DAP MP calls for speaker to act over Menu Rahmah claims

Dr Halimah Ali must be referred to the Parliamentary Committee of Privileges, says Dr Kelvin Yii

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 21 Feb 2023 2:39PM

DAP MP calls for speaker to act over Menu Rahmah claims
Dr Kelvin Yii (pic) says that Dr Halimah Ali’s statement could lead to misunderstandings and stigma towards the autistic and disabled communities in Malaysia. – SYEDA IMRAN/The Vibes file pic, February 21, 2023

KUALA LUMPUR – Dr Kelvin Yii (Bandar Kuching-PH) has written to the Dewan Rakyat speaker to refer Dr Halimah Ali (Kapar-PN) to the Parliamentary Committee of Privileges over her controversial claims on the Menu Rahmah campaign.

Dr Yii said Dr Halimah’s claims had confused the House and could be considered a sign of contempt. 

He requested that Datuk Johari Abdul have her brought to the committee in accordance with Section 36 (12) of the Standing Orders.

Dr Halimah had previously made a statement during her speech that the Menu Rahmah movement could lead to risks of ailments, including cancer and autism. 

Nonetheless, she denied making such claims, and asserted that the Hansard would prove her innocence.

However, a check by The Vibes with the Hansard for Parliament’s sitting on February 14 revealed that the lawmaker had indeed said that those who opt for Menu Rahmah offerings could be exposed to various ills. 

“I have no problem with the term ‘rahmah’ but don’t let (the initiative) get to the point where low-income citizens are given low-quality food supplies (that) might cause them to be exposed to cancer, autoimmune disease, autism, and so on,” she was quoted as saying in the Hansard.

Dr Halimah had previously drawn flak for her comment, with Dewan Negara member Senator Datuk Ras Adiba Radzi labelling the statement as an insult to the disabled community in Malaysia.

In a statement today, Dr Yii rebutted her claims as untrue and irresponsible, as she had made arguments not based on facts and science.

He added that her statement could lead to misunderstandings and stigma towards the autistic and disabled communities in Malaysia.

“The Kapar MP has been given numerous opportunities to apologise and retract her statement,” he said. 

“But she continued to confuse the House, and denied ever making the comment in several public statements, including a statement in the House where she told us to refer to the Hansard to prove that the comment was never uttered,” he added.

Section 36 (12) of the Standing Orders of the Dewan Rakyat states that “any member who imputes statements that mislead the House is deemed to be in contempt of the House and the member may be referred to the Committee of Privileges for the offence”. – The Vibes, February 21, 2023

Related News

Malaysia / 3y

Fukushima wastewater release: no live marine fish imported from Japan

Malaysia / 3y

Menu Rahmah has helped reduced food inflation: Salahuddin

Malaysia / 3y

Beware of ministerial power abuse: PAS MP on sustainable energy law amendments

Malaysia / 3y

Classify LGBTQ community as mentally ill people: PAS MPs 

Malaysia / 3y

Menu Rahmah hasn’t turned ‘cold’ as claimed by some: Salahuddin

Malaysia / 3y

Dewan to discuss how govt plans to speed up economic recovery

Spotlight

Malaysia

Eight homes evacuated after recurring landslides raise safety fears in Shah Alam

Malaysia

Najib’s pension suspended, Saifuddin confirms

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: PH to abolish seven appointed state assembly positions

Malaysia

Naked body of woman found floating in river

Malaysia

Dzulkefly praises HKL’s success in reattaching police officer’s hand

Malaysia

Four homes remain unsafe as Penang landslide stabilisation takes up to five months

Malaysia

1MDB allowed to admit affidavit of Rosmah’s shopping partner in its case

Malaysia

Najib faces four conditions under house arrest, including restrictions on movement and visitors

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Melaka polls: DAP alleges BN campaign takeover of more than 500 government billboards in Melaka

Malaysia

Najib’s pension suspended, Saifuddin confirms

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Over 2,200 IPR participants record income or sales milestones under poverty eradication drive

Malaysia

Melaka election: Police record 34 reports, open 25 investigation papers

Malaysia

Dzulkefly praises HKL’s success in reattaching police officer’s hand

Malaysia

Leaders must be judged by justice, not religion

Malaysia

Malaysian Bar seeks to halt Najib's house arrest pending court challenge

Malaysia

Son arrested after mother found strangled at Banting home