Malaysia

Penang votes to ‘compel’ Sanusi to apologise for questioning state’s sovereignty

Assemblymen give overwhelming support in favour of proposal to censure Kedah MB

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 07 Mar 2023 6:19PM

Penang votes to ‘compel’ Sanusi to apologise for questioning state’s sovereignty
The Penang assembly has passed a historic motion to ‘compel’ Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammed Sanusi Md Nor (pic) to apologise for claiming the state was ‘loaned’ from Kedah. – ABDUL RAZAK LATIF/The Vibes file pic, March 7, 2023

by Ian McIntyre

GEORGE TOWN – The Penang assembly ended its sitting today by voting for the motion to “compel” Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammed Sanusi Md Nor to apologise to 1.8 million Penangites for his remarks that the state was “loaned” from Kedah.

This is the first time in the assembly’s history that such a motion was passed – aimed at a leader of another state – by seeking an open apology and to reprimand him for making possibly seditious remarks.

When debating the motion, Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow (Padang Kota-PH) challenged Sanusi to seek legal recourse to clear his name and to put the facts to rest about the historical status of Penang and Kedah.

“It is not just about history but the remarks made recently bordered on sedition and Sanusi needs to be accountable for his words,” said Chow, garnering applause.

Lim Guan Eng (Air Putih-PH) had tabled the motion underlining that Penang is defined as a sovereign state and enjoys the same rights like any other Malaysian state.

It was overwhelmingly passed when Law put it to vote, as the assembly now only has one official opposition member, who is Yusni Mat Piah (Penaga-PN).

Law also allowed opposition leader Yusni Mat Piah (Penaga-PN) to argue the matter where Yusni stated that Sanusi’s remarks were intentionally misinterpreted by the lawmakers.

Yusni said Sanusi was just seeking more compensation from the federal government, and not Penang, citing that in the past Kedah was paid RM10,000 per annum before it was then raised in 2018 to RM10 million per annum.

Lim interjected that when he was the finance minister, he was the one who raised the quantum to RM10 million to help Kedah’s economy.

“Why make noise about it now? Why didn’t Sanusi broach the subject when his party (PAS) was in federal power? He is intentionally doing this.”

Yusni cited that Sanusi was just following up on what the Kedah sultan had mentioned during a meeting, to which M. Satees (Bagan Dalam-PH) rose to inject, citing Standing Orders, a legislative member cannot cite the name of royalty to inflict influence when debating proceedings within the assembly.

He urged Yusni to withdraw the remark concerning royalty, which Yusni ignored, saying he was just referring to the media reports on the matter.

Meanwhile, Muhammed Faiz Fadzil (Permatang Pasir-PH) said that even though he was born in Kedah, Penang has become the state that “sheltered” him and help him in his cause to serve Malaysians.

“As elected representatives, we will stand to defend Penang’s sovereignty against outsiders bent on dividing and confusing us. Sanusi is a rude leader and he needs to be reprimanded for such callous behaviour.”

The issue blew up after Sanusi had claimed in the Kedah assembly in September that Penang is a state leased from Kedah and, therefore, should not criticise its neighbour over its projects.

Sanusi earlier said the RM100 million annual compensation is among Kedah’s wishlist for Budget 2022, which includes royalty payment, infrastructure, compensation for paddy land, and loan write-offs.

Senator picks

The assembly also appointed Dr R. A. Lingeshwaran, who is Sg Bakap hospital director as a senator, replacing Lim Hui Ying. Lim is now Tanjong MP after the 2022 general election and was appointed deputy education minister.

It was reported that Lingeshwaran joined DAP four months ago while his father – Datuk Seri R. Arunasalam – is a businessman and former MIC strongman in Penang.

The backbenchers also agreed to appoint Amir Ghazali as a senator. He is the political secretary to Penang PKR chairperson Nurul Izzah Anwar.

Amir is replacing Fadhlina Sidek, who won the Nibong Tebal parliamentary seat last year and was appointed as education minister.

However, Law expressed his dismay that Lingeshwaran and Amir were not in the chambers when the motion on their candidacies was passed.

“At the very least, we should get to see them and offer our wisdom to ensure they serve Penang well in their senatorships,” said Law.

Penang is poised to hold its state election by July this year.

Yesterday, Penang also recorded history when four Perikatan Nasional assemblymen were expelled and vacated their state seats for violating the state’s anti-hopping laws. – The Vibes, March 7, 2023

Related News

Community / 9h

Paya Terubong landslide: Developer, landowner must take responsibility - CM

Community / 1d

Paya Terubong landslide: Resident writes to 15 ADUN to seek ban on hillslope development

Malaysia / 1d

Kedah: The ancient Malay kingdom challenges the conventional narrative of Malayan history

Malaysia / 3d

Flash floods, landslides: Penangites asked to be on alert

Malaysia / 4d

Air Itam - Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu Expressway expected to be ready by April next year

Malaysia / 5d

Penang to seek greater clarification over Waze ban

Spotlight

Education

Schools to get extra holidays for Deepavali

Malaysia

Getting angry at your wife for buying items online is a form of abuse, says minister

Malaysia

Man posing as Selangor crown prince’s aide arrested over RM960,020 scam

Malaysia

Dr Mahathir leaves late wife’s tahlil ceremony after feeling unwell

Malaysia

Chegubard jailed four months for defaming King

Malaysia

Court to hear Najib’s bid to revive RM1.9m suit against former AG on Nov 26

Malaysia

Malaysia climbs to 15th in global competitiveness rankings

Education

MOE: Close to 49,000 Year One pupils failed to master basic literacy and numeracy in 2025

You may be interested

Malaysia

PN, BN settle seat allocation for Melaka polls

Malaysia

Dr Mahathir leaves late wife’s tahlil ceremony after feeling unwell

Malaysia

Death in custody: IPCC investigates death of Noorizwan Zulkefly

Malaysia

Online scam losses hit RM1.2b, but only RM14.3m recovered, Home Minster says

Malaysia

MPs to press govt on hospital delays, Geely investment delivery and development funds

Malaysia

Sarawak state election: GPS to contest all 82 seats - Abang Johari

Malaysia

Amir Hamzah: 1MDB losses may remain at RM20.1b even after RM31.3b recovery

Malaysia

Man remanded 7 days over fatal axe attack on FELDA settler