Malaysia

Mkini not responsible for 3rd party comments, says dissenting apex court judge

Datuk Nallini Pathmanathan says news portal proved it had no prior knowledge of incendiary comments, acted swiftly once made aware of them

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 19 Feb 2021 3:41PM

Mkini not responsible for 3rd party comments, says dissenting apex court judge
The Federal Court today found Malaysiakini guilty of contempt, but editor-in-chief Steven Gan escaped a guilty verdict in the suit brought by Attorney-General Tan Sri Idrus Harun. – The Vibes file pic, February 19, 2021

KUALA LUMPUR – Malaysiakini should not be held liable for comments by third parties published on their website, according to the sole dissenting judge in its contempt verdict today.

Datuk Nallini Pathmanathan said that her dissent was based on a few reasons, with the first issue being related to Section 114A of the Evidence Act.

Section 114A presumes that content on a website would have been published by the host itself.

But, according to Pathmanathan this is rebuttable, meaning Malaysiakini could, and indeed did prove it wrong.

“It is because the totality of the evidence points to the fact that at the time when comments were first visible to readers, the respondents were unaware of their existence and content of the same, until it was brought to their attention on June 12, 2020,” she said in her dissenting judgement.

She said that Malaysiakini could only be considered as a publisher if it had knowledge of the existence of the comments posted by third parties.

Pathmanathan referred to the Communications and Multimedia Act and the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Code, which states that Malaysiakini would only have liability as a publisher when they are aware of the existence of third-party comments.

“This is in light of the evidence from the respondents that comments may arise at any time during the day or night and at any point in time in the future.

“That, to my mind, with respect, appears to be an untenable proposition. 

“And that is why Parliament in its wisdom adopted the “flag and takedown” approach that enables intermediaries to respond as soon as they acquire knowledge,” she said.

Given that Malaysiakini took down the comments in 12 minutes of being advised of the fact, she said this was a sufficiently immediate response that demonstrated their intent not to allow contemptuous material on their portal.

Pathmanathan rubbished the argument that Malaysiakini “ought to have known” about the existence of such comments.

She said, under such a test, an online news portal will be liable for such comments as soon it appears on the portal and is unable to avoid that consequence even if the comments were removed.

She said, such an approach went against the spirit of laws enacted by Parliament.

“In the law of contempt, constructive knowledge or the fact you ought to have known, cannot be applied against an online content provider who is not the author of the comments. 

“It is after all the author who is the person who committed the primary offence. 

“Malaysiakini is not the primary perpetrator,” she added. – The Vibes, February 19, 2021

Related News

Business / 6d

SoftBank, Grab propose US$1.85b investment in Malaysia’s AI infrastructure

Malaysia / 1w

Mujahid: Corruption must be rejected, even when committed by our own

Opinion / 1w

Why Malaysia lacks progress in geothermal energy?

Opinion / 1w

Trump’s dismal poll night and the lesson for Malaysia

Malaysia / 2w

Malaysia’s average household size falls to 3.8 people

Malaysia / 2w

Attractive salaries, commissions help drive growth of scam centres in Malaysia

Spotlight

Malaysia

MB’s resignation: “I was not informed” – Jalaluddin

Malaysia

Ismail’s resignation raises various questions: Work of hidden hands?

Malaysia

Padang Rengas dispute exposes challenge facing possible BN-PN pact

Malaysia

Khalid urges Anwar to reject Anthony Loke’s resignation amid political uncertainty

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Zahid: One name submitted for new Negeri MB

Malaysia

Viral abuse video leads to murder charge against couple in father's death

You may be interested

Malaysia

1MDB’s burden will outlive the generation that witnessed its rise

Malaysia

Businessman urges MPOB to provide details of palm oil mixing probe

Malaysia

UMNO division committee member denies alleged offensive TikTok post against PM

Malaysia

Former Negeri Sembilan exco members end legal fight over removal

Malaysia

Malaysia - France poised to forge strategic partnership in defence, critical minerals

Malaysia

Puad challenges Zahid over calls for DAP ministers to resign while retaining DPM post

Malaysia

NS Palace: MB's resignation not confirmed, royal consent required

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Govt, AG, Hannah opposed conditional pardon, minutes show