Malaysia

So many questions, so little time: MPs bemoan tight schedule for ministers’ debates

Give chance for lawmakers to interject, get further explanations, R.S.N. Rayer asks deputy speaker

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 23 Sep 2021 3:51PM

So many questions, so little time: MPs bemoan tight schedule for ministers’ debates
In urging Datuk Mohd Rashid Hasnon to give ministers more time to answer questions in Parliament, R.S.N. Rayer says the deputy Dewan Rakyat speaker is considerate person, not like Speaker Datuk Azhar Azizan Harun. – Parlimen Malaysia Facebook pic, September 23, 2021

by Amar Shah Mohsen

KUALA LUMPUR – Several opposition MPs today took the Dewan Rakyat speaker’s office to task for limiting the time imposed on the winding-up speeches of each ministry, saying it is insufficient to address all issues that were raised.

R.S.N. Rayer (Jelutong-PH) was the first to raise this issue after National Unity Minister Datuk Halimah Mohamed Sadique was given only 15 minutes to answer all questions that were posed to her by MPs during their debate on the royal address. 

Similarly, he said other ministers – although some were given a longer period to speak – did not have enough time to address every question from the floor, and that this has also limited the lawmakers’ opportunity to ask supplementary questions. 

“I believe more time is required to give the space and chance to MPs to interject and get further explanations,” he told Deputy Dewan Rakyat Speaker Datuk Mohd Rashid Hasnon in Parliament today. 

“I ask that you give a bit more time for questions. You are a considerate person, not like the speaker (Datuk Azhar Azizan Harun). Whenever he says no, it means no.” 

Echoing Rayer’s request, Hannah Yeoh (Segambut-PH) pointed out how 16 ministries were given a single day yesterday to answer all the questions that were raised by lawmakers in the past four days of proceedings. 

“If we look at the trend in which the ministers respond, they usually keep the sensitive issues to the end of their speech. By that time, the time for them to speak is already up. 

“There’s no meaning if MPs are asked to debate for four days, but ministers only answer them in two. It is the speaker’s duty to make Parliament proceedings more meaningful.

“If it is (meaningful), I believe the attendance of MPs will also improve. Now, we have to wait until night, and sometimes, our questions are not answered. If we have to wait for a written reply, what’s the use of sitting in this Dewan?”

Other than the winding-up speeches by 16 ministers yesterday, 11 more ministers are set to speak today. 

Rashid said the time allocated for each ministry is based on the number of questions directed at them, and that they will only respond to points that have been raised during the debates previously. 

“Whichever ministries have more issues being raised, we will give them more time. Each minister knows how many questions are being asked. 

“Yes, I admit two days is not enough, but we are limited by the number of days the current sitting has,” he said, adding that he will raise this issue for deliberation to ensure there is enough time for proper debates and answers in the future. – The Vibes, September 23, 2021

Related News

Entertainment / 4w

ALIFE calls for one-stop centre to manage and market concerts

Malaysia / 1mth

Najib granted conditional pardon, to serve remainder of sentence under house arrest

Malaysia / 1mth

Hannah Yeoh, husband divorce after 18 years of marriage

Malaysia / 1mth

MP to raise commingled oil cargo tax uncertainty in Parliament

Malaysia / 2mth

Speaker informs EC of Subang parliamentary seat vacancy

Malaysia / 2mth

Tabung Haji RCI report takes centre stage at special Dewan sitting tomorrow

Spotlight

World

Kim Jong Un appears in state media photos after unverified death rumours

Malaysia

Anwar challenges Rafizi over corporate crime, asks why he stayed silent as minister

Malaysia

AKPS chief Mohd Shuhaily to be charged over alleged assault on two policemen

Malaysia

Year One pupil dies after breathing difficulties in Dengkil classroom

Malaysia

College student remanded for three days over alleged rape of underage girl

Sports & Fitness

Lee Zii Jia settles dispute with father, sister over company affairs

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Online scam call centres: Police detain 31 people targeting foreign victims in Pahang crackdown

Malaysia

Guan Eng proposes RM1,000 tax rebate for purchase of air purifiers

By Ian McIntyre

You may be interested

Malaysia

Fadhlina takes legal action over video of 2023 Parliament speech

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Myanmar must act to resolve Rohingya crisis, Foreign Minister says

Malaysia

Two held after 16-year-old girl rescued in suspected sex exploitation case

Malaysia

Tun M says grief still weighs on him after Siti Hasmah’s death

Malaysia

Allegation of minister receiving RM9.5m political statement without evidence - PM Anwar

Malaysia

RM2.1b rural road overspending triggers contractor payment delays, new project freeze

Malaysia

Father arrested over suspected rape of 13-year-old daughter in Ranau

Malaysia

Malaysia must win trust of both sides to move Southern Thailand peace process forward