Malaysia

Penang exco disputes USA Today’s listing of Penang Hill as top ‘tourist trap’

Ranking has limitations such as monolingual data collection, says Wong Hon Wai

Updated 2 years ago · Published on 27 Sep 2023 10:30AM

Penang exco disputes USA Today’s listing of Penang Hill as top ‘tourist trap’
Since 1923, there have been 47 million visitors to Penang Hill and that is more than a million visitors annually. – Bernama pic, September 27, 2023

by Ian McIntyre

GEORGE TOWN – Penang has questioned the report by the USA Today newspaper which listed Penang’s top tourism landmark as the ninth top “tourist trap” and the 14th “most overrated attraction” in its global survey of some 65 nations.

State exco for tourism Wong Hon Wai said the paper’s review has inherent limitations to it, such as data collection which is monolingual and without other major languages used in the region such as Bahasa Malaysia, Mandarin, Tamil or Arabic.

“The bad reviews are about two dozen and it doesn’t take into consideration many other good reviews about Penang Hill which have far more numbers than the bad ones,” Wong, who also oversees the creative economy portfolio, said in a statement.

Since 1923, there have been 47 million visitors to Penang Hill and that is more than a million visitors annually.

Many of them are returning visitors which shows that they are attracted to the charm of Penang Hill as one of the major attractions.

The numbers of visitors speak for itself, said Wong.

“The state government will always look for improvements and a new cable car project is already in the pipeline. This will give tourists a new experience in the future,” said Wong.

The report last month has stirred up emotions in Penang, with many quarters challenging the validity of the USA Today survey.

Besides Wong’s remarks, Penang Consumers Protection Association president Datuk K. Koris Atan was upset with the report, saying that it was irrelevant to the state.

Koris said that there were better issues for the American publication to pursue.

Penang Hill made it into the top 10 list globally, ninth overall by USA Today, which is distributed in major parts of the country (America) and several locations worldwide, too.

USA Today said it analysed 23.2 million Google reviews of 500 popular tourist attractions in the world, spanning 65 countries on six continents in July 2023, as part of the process of reaching a conclusion to its survey.

The print and digital media had analysed mentions of certain keywords that indicate a common negative sentiment among visitors, such as “tourist trap”, “expensive” and “overrated”, hence the three main categories in the article. – The Vibes, September 27, 2023

Related News

Culture / 2d

Penang: Three refurbished tourism attractions to be ‘reopened’ soon

Off beat / 2d

Penang targets 100% digital payment adoption rate

Tech / 5d

Penang’s Tech Dome celebrates 10th anniversary with opening of new space gallery

Malaysia / 1w

No further delays for water tariff hike in Penang - CM

People / 1w

Penang: Greater efforts needed to record historical events, says nonagenarian

People / 1w

Penang: Eurasian association mourns sudden loss of its president

Spotlight

Malaysia

PH: PAS-UMNO unity narrative an old political script that failed before

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

MACC investigator defends land transfer findings in Guan Eng corruption trial

Malaysia

Guan Eng meets PM over greater monetary relief for MSMEs

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Sentiments of Malay voters in Negeri and Johor cannot be compared – Aminuddin

Culture

Penang Museum officially ‘reopened’ after delicate touch-ups

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Former minister, Idris Jala, diagnosed with stage three lung cancer

Malaysia

KBS studying possibility of Sepang replacing Bahrain as F1 host

Malaysia

PM rejects antisemitism claims, says Malaysia opposes Israel’s actions, not Jewish people

Malaysia

Anwar: Malaysia to keep engaging US over 10% tariff as trade talks continue

You may be interested

Malaysia

US gives Malaysia two years to enact forced labour laws under Reciprocal Trade Agreement

Malaysia

MCMC investigates alleged anti-Islam social media post, vows zero tolerance for extremist 3R content

Malaysia

Police smash illegal crypto mining ring, arrest three over electricity theft

Malaysia

DIGP Ayob Khan to retire after nearly 35 years of service

Malaysia

Teenager arrested after newborn baby found wrapped in cloth at university dorm waste area

Malaysia

70-year-old man arrested over alleged political flag removal in Seremban

Malaysia

PH: PAS-UMNO unity narrative an old political script that failed before

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Sentiments of Malay voters in Negeri and Johor cannot be compared – Aminuddin