World

Perth ends snap lockdown as quarantine debate swells

Effectiveness and fairness of Australia’s hotel quarantine system under the spotlight

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 26 Apr 2021 11:59PM

Perth ends snap lockdown as quarantine debate swells
A return traveller arriving at the Intercontinental quarantine hotel in Melbourne, Australia, recently. Quarantine hotels have been the source of each outbreak in Australia since early in the pandemic. – EPA pic, April 26, 2021

SYDNEY – Australian authorities today lifted a snap three-day lockdown of Perth, but faced pointed questions about how the coronavirus leaked from a quarantine hotel for returning travellers.

Stay-at-home orders for Perth and surrounding areas will expire at midnight tonight, after just two people contracted Covid-19 out of thousands tested in the region.

“It was a circuit-breaker we needed to limit community spread and keep our community healthy,” Western Australia state premier Mark McGowan said.

The virus reportedly spread from a man who recently returned from his wedding in India to other travellers at a quarantine hotel, including one who then unknowingly infected people in the community after being released from isolation.

The cases have prompted a fresh debate over the effectiveness and fairness of Australia’s hotel quarantine system, which is now being copied in several countries around the world.

Australia closed its international borders to most non-citizens in March last year, with those allowed to travel subject to 14 days in quarantine, a policy that effectively curbed the spread of Covid-19.

But quarantine hotels have been the source of each outbreak in Australia since early in the pandemic, leading to a series of snap lockdowns across the country and ever-tightening travel rules.

Canberra last week reduced the number of flights from virus-hit India, while some are pushing to ramp up already strict limits on international travel for Australian citizens.

McGowan has slammed the quarantine system, saying hotels were “not fit for purpose” and calling on the conservative federal government to find alternative sites away from populated cities.

His demand was backed by the Australian Medical Association’s Western Australia branch president Andrew Miller, who described the system as a “human rights catastrophe”.

But the federal government has so far resisted calls to take over quarantine – despite having responsibility for border control – with Health Minister Greg Hunt saying the system is among “the best in the world”.

And other leaders, such as New South Wales Premier Gladys Berejiklian, said “we have to accept” there would be inevitable failures with the system “from time to time”.

Australia has recorded less than 30,000 cases and 910 deaths since the pandemic began, with no major outbreaks since last year and most regions enjoying few restrictions. – AFP, April 26, 2021

Related News

Places / 1mth

Four premier hotels in Penang to be restored, open doors soon

Malaysia / 2mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Opinion / 3mth

The Islamic business revolution in Southern Thailand

Malaysia / 4mth

Malaysia, Australia back Pope Leo's call for peace, urge dialogue to end global conflicts

Our Planet / 4mth

Ban on single-use plastic bags to take effect in Penang from Sept 1

Trending / 5mth

MAH: 23-hour stay policy for hotels not practical

Spotlight

World

Series of explosions, fires hit three southern Thai provinces

Opinion

One more temple falls: The destruction of Malaysia’s soul?

Opinion

Why is Israel pushing toward confrontation with Türkiye?

Malaysia

‘Uncle Anwar’ sends representative to children’s entrepreneurs day in Subang Jaya

Malaysia

‘Look at temple dispute based on facts and laws’ – DAP reps tell Rayer

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Malaysia, Brunei set deadline to demarcate boundary, enhance border security

Malaysia

Police probe indecent act allegedly targeting woman in Sungai Petani

Malaysia

Sarawak postpones three major programmes over haze concerns

You may be interested

World

5.9-magnitude earthquake strikes eastern Japan, shakes Tokyo; several injured

World

US threatens Iran with ‘greatest financial offensive’

World

Two police officers among seven killed in wrong-way crash on UK’s A66

World

Canada to hit US goods with dollar-for-dollar tariffs after trade talks collapse

World

US threatens tougher Iran sanctions, raising pressure on China

World

TikTok agrees to US$400 million settlement over alleged child privacy violations

World

Teen killed in sword attack at Swedish school was a 17-year-old girl

World

Prabowo orders more troops, helicopters as Kalimantan fires worsen