Malaysia

Exploiting canteen issue during Ramadan makes mockery of ‘PAS for all’, says Aliran

Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek’s role not confined to one race, Penang PKR women's wing chips in.

Updated 2 years ago · Published on 14 Mar 2024 8:00PM

Exploiting canteen issue during Ramadan makes mockery of ‘PAS for all’, says Aliran
A supporter waves the PAS flag during the election campaign at the Permatang Pauh parliamentary constituency in November 2022. The party has been told that while Muslims’ observance of fasting should be respected, so too should the rights of non-Muslims to eat during Ramadan. The Vibes pic, March 14, 2024.

by Ian McIntyre

HUMAN rights and reform organisation Aliran has expressed deep concern that PAS has found it necessary to make an issue out of the Education Ministry’s recent directive to school canteens to open for business during the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan.

“This is an unnecessary issue, especially in a multi-ethnic and multi-religious society such as ours – where the people, including schoolchildren, should exercise mutual respect for each other’s rights and responsibilities.

“It is divisive for PAS to raise such an issue, which flies in the face of the party’s ‘PAS for all’ slogan,” said the Aliran executive committee in a statement today.

While the Muslims’ observance of fasting should be respected and appreciated, so too should the right of non-Muslims to eat at the school canteen, it stressed.

“It would not diminish the importance of fasting if the canteens are encouraged to operate during this period.

“If anything, it would enhance the religious devotion of the Muslim students and reinforce the forbearance expected of them during the fasting month.”

Aliran said that any move to disallow school canteen operators from operating during Ramadan would be tantamount to being insensitive to the basic rights and needs of non-Muslims.

Those who have an insatiable appetite to exploit issues for political gain should exercise restraint during the blessed month of Ramadan, it added.

PAS Ulama Council chief Datuk Ahmad Yahya, who is the Pokok Sena MP, recently criticised Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek, accusing her of acting in haste by allow school canteens to operate as per normal during the fasting period.

PAS’s extremist nature revealed, says Penang PKR

Meanwhile, the women’s wing of Penang PKR accused the PAS ulama council of stooping to low levels by politicising the month of Ramadan instead of embracing the related teachings on nobility and abstinence during this period

Its head Nurhidayah Che Rose took to social media to indicate that the wing will protest the manner of how the clerics’ body attempted to politicise the issue of the Education Ministry allowing school canteens to operate during Ramadan.

"To criticise minister Fadhlina Sidek for allowing the canteens to operate to serve non-Muslim students reflects the extremist nature of PAS and its disrespect of Ramadan. Worst, it causes a polemic argument," said Nurhidayah.

"During Ramadan, it is unnecessary for Muslims to quarrel among ourselves. and neither should we politicise everything.”

“We believe the action to allow the canteens to operate is correct. It imbues tolerance among the students and teaches the Muslims to have the determination to fast as per the teachings and allow the non-Muslim mothers relief in not having to prepare food for their children."

She stressed to PAS that Islam is a religion which teaches its followers to be tolerant and sensitive to the needs of all.

"Fadhlina is a minister who oversees the welfare of all schools and tries to meet the needs of every student and educator in the country. Her role is not confined to just one location or one race," said Nurhidayah.

Penang PKR Wanita therefore urged PAS leaders to respect Ramadan as a period for reflection instead of seeking cheap political mileage, she said. – The Vibes, March 14, 2024

Related News

Opinion / 22h

Johor MB’s exclusionary rhetoric betrays the people, exposes UMNO’s political hypocrisy

Malaysia / 4d

Saifuddin, Zaliha appointed PKR vice-presidents

Malaysia / 1w

Hulu Selangor cannot afford to wait for a government specialist hospital – PKR leader

Malaysia / 3w

Electoral landscape looking clearer as GE16 draws nearer

Malaysia / 3w

Rafizi, Nik Nazmi; PKR membership terminated - Dr Fuziah

Malaysia / 3w

Rafizi, Nik Nazmi to vacate parliamentary seats tomorrow, quit PKR

Spotlight

Malaysia

Anwar congratulates Modi on becoming India's longest-serving elected PM

Malaysia

Missing jewellery: Rosmah ordered to pay RM67.5 million

People

Malay kampongs in Bangkok: Echoes of southern heritage in Thailand’s capital

Opinion

Johor MB’s exclusionary rhetoric betrays the people, exposes UMNO’s political hypocrisy

Malaysia

Johor and NS polls first major test of post PAS-Bersatu political order

Malaysia

Claimed installation of 12th N. Sembilan ruler invalid - Pengelola Bijaya Diraja

Malaysia

4WD driver who drove backwards on highway nabbed, positive for drugs (video)

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Seven in ten Malaysian workers earn RM5k or less - economist

You may be interested

Malaysia

Seven in ten Malaysian workers earn RM5k or less - economist

Malaysia

Two women killed after being thrown from Myvi in Batang Sadong bridge crash

Malaysia

Claimed installation of 12th N. Sembilan ruler invalid - Pengelola Bijaya Diraja

Malaysia

Johor, Negeri Sembilan seat talks enter final stage as PH awaits Anwar’s return

Malaysia

Grandfather risks life to save nine family members as fire destroys home

Malaysia

MACC - MOF deepen alliance to pursue high-profile graft cases and asset recovery

Malaysia

PAS not contesting solo in Johor PRN, new political alignment formed

Malaysia

PAS cites unity and political stability in decision to end cooperation with Bersatu