Malaysia

‘Drop in Covid-19 cases not equal to lower infection rate’

Dr Arvinder-Singh HS says inaccurate to use rate of positive patients among population to measure outbreak situation

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 27 Jan 2021 7:00AM

‘Drop in Covid-19 cases not equal to lower infection rate’
The World Health Organisation recommends more than 5% in large-scale Covid-19 screening tests be done to address community transmission concerns. – ALIF OMAR/The Vibes pic, January 27, 2021

by G. Surach

KUALA LUMPUR – Malaysians are warned that a drop in the number of daily Covid-19 cases will not translate into a lower infection rate.

Clinical Research Centre Malaysia medical officer Dr Arvinder-Singh HS said the country’s attempts to curb the pandemic should consider several other variables – the rate of positive cases, number of intensive care unit (ICU) cases, those requiring respiratory assistance, and deaths due to the virus – to better tackle the problem.

Dr Arvinder said these are the indicators that all parties need to look at in anticipating the end of the pandemic.

“Actually, what we need to see is the number of positive cases out of the number of people that have been tested.

“This allows us to see how many people have been infected from a community or cluster.

“For example, 10 positive cases out of 100 tested indicate that 10% of the people in the community or cluster are infected with Covid-19.

“The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends more than 5% in large-scale screening tests be done to address community transmission concerns,” he said in a series of tweets on Tuesday.

Citing research he conducted recently, Dr Arvinder said the positive rate on his graph was at 6.2% on Monday with a seven-day average of 5.9%.

“Although the number of new infections yesterday (Monday) has decreased, the positive rate is still more than 5%.”

Dr Arvinder-Singh HS’s graph showing the percentage of positive Covid-19 cases in Malaysia over time. – Twitter pic, January 27, 2021
Dr Arvinder-Singh HS’s graph showing the percentage of positive Covid-19 cases in Malaysia over time. – Twitter pic, January 27, 2021

He said among the reasons for this occurrence is how the rate of Covid-19 testing has decreased, which means fewer people getting tested, which in turn equates to lower detection of positive cases.

He pointed out that the percentage rate of infections in the country has been the same since January 16.

As such, he opined that using the rate of positive patients among the population, instead of the total number recorded, to measure the outbreak situation is inaccurate.

“Positive infection rates give a clearer picture of the situation. More tests will result in more positive cases that can be detected (especially Level 1 cases), and the process of isolating patients and identifying close contacts via contact tracing can be done quickly.

“This will prevent patients from deteriorating to a detrimental stage.”

Cannot afford to take matter lightly

Dr Arvinder also pointed out that the actual target to tackle the pandemic is not to reduce the number of positive cases, but to reduce the number of patients admitted to ICUs, requiring respiratory assistance, and deaths, which occur at Categories 4 and 5.

“Based on the research graph, with data compiled from the Covid-19 outbreak since January last year, we can see the rate of cases in ICUs and and those that require respiratory assistance, as well as deaths, against the timeline of events.”

He noted that the second wave occurred after the Sabah election in September, and the third wave after the year-end holidays in November and December. Despite fluctuating positive case numbers, the death toll now is often more than five people a day compared with the situation in August, when there was almost zero deaths a day.

“Although cases are declining, death rates are seen to be increasing.”

A graph with data from Dr Arvinder-Singh HS’ study showing the rate of cases in ICUs and and those that require respiratory assistance, as well as deaths, against a timeline of events. – Twitter pic, January 27, 2021
A graph with data from Dr Arvinder-Singh HS’ study showing the rate of cases in ICUs and and those that require respiratory assistance, as well as deaths, against a timeline of events. – Twitter pic, January 27, 2021

Advising the people to not take things lightly if they notice symptoms, Dr Arvinder said the present situation reflects the possibility that there are more positive cases in the community, with those infected slow to receive immediate treatment. This is especially so among people in the high-risk category.

“One of the reasons for the increase in cases is due to unrestricted movement during the Sabah election and school holidays, especially at ferry ports heading to holiday destinations.

“Therefore, compliance with standard operating procedures should continue to be prioritised, especially in crowded, cramped places and during close (proximity) conversations.”

By doing so, Dr Arvinder hopes that, in the long run, the rate of positive cases will go down, together with the number of ICU cases, those requiring respiratory assistance, and deaths. – The Vibes, January 27, 2021

Related News

World / 4d

Trump's health: Weighs 108kg, heart age 14 years younger, hands bruised from frequent handshakes – Doctor

Malaysia / 1w

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Malaysia / 4w

Government’s RM5.7 billion spending cut a bold move to curb waste, says PKR leader

Malaysia / 1mth

Funding cutbacks may jeopardise public health, education, safety and crime prevention needs – Guan Eng

Community / 3mth

Only 6 months after cleaning, senior citizens' 'treasures' pile up again

Malaysia / 3mth

Bad move to channel EPF dividends into Account 3 for festive withdrawals, cautions economist

Spotlight

Malaysia

Former head of a ministry's corporate communications unit acquitted of bribery charge

Malaysia

Two sisters die trapped in Johor house fire as escape routes cut off by flames

Malaysia

NS election speculation intensifies as Aminuddin granted audience with state ruler

Malaysia

Teenager who drove recklessly, causing death remanded for further investigation

Malaysia

Police looking for trio involved in violent armed robbery in Penang (video)

Malaysia

Family of five killed as car crashes into water pipe in Serian

Malaysia

'I was once spat on by a pakcik' — Marina denies fear of contesting Malay-majority seats

Malaysia

Jewellery shop among six premises destroyed in fire (video)

You may be interested

Malaysia

Pahang police logistics chief killed in motorcycle crash on Genting road

Malaysia

Headless teen tragedy: VW driver charged with dangerous driving causing death

Malaysia

Baby boy thrown from car in AMJ highway crash survives

Malaysia

Sarawak seeks China collaboration to fix growing doctor shortage

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Pamela Ling’s disappearance, Durian Tunggal shooting, corporate mafia; MP demands answers

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Schoolteacher denies multiple counts of physical, digital sexual assault against 2 teens

Malaysia

Negeri Sembilan PH state assemblymen meet at MB's residence

Malaysia

Shift in Bumi economy needed to drive ownership, AI innovation and industrial leadership