Malaysia

Killing fly with sledgehammer: Bumi group says no need to shut virus-hit businesses

Datuk Ameer Ali Mydin says financial hit huge, infection risk may lie in customers themselves

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 03 Feb 2021 9:00AM

Killing fly with sledgehammer: Bumi group says no need to shut virus-hit businesses
Bumiputera Retailers’ Organisation president Datuk Ameer Ali Mydin suggests that businesses with Covid-19 cases among staff conduct disinfection after operating hours, which would not require a closure. – The Vibes file pic, February 3, 2021

by Amar Shah Mohsen

KUALA LUMPUR – It makes little sense to require retailers to temporarily close their business premises in the event Covid-19 cases are detected among staff, said Bumiputera Retailers’ Organisation president Datuk Ameer Ali Mydin. 

He said doing so does not really address the fact that the coronavirus is already in the community, adding that affected businesses could suffer tremendous losses due to this. 

Ameer, who is also managing director of Mydin Mohamed Holdings Bhd, said for a well-performing hypermarket, a day’s closure could cost up to RM100,000.

This includes sanitising the area, which could cost between RM20,000 and RM30,000 for a reasonably sized hypermarket, and tens of thousands of ringgit more in potential income will also be missed. 

“Chances are, even if you are forced to close your premises for a day or two, customers who walk in the next day may also be unknowingly carrying the virus,” he told The Vibes yesterday. 

“Logically, we don’t need to shut down, because if a staffer is positive, it is most likely they contracted it from outside. In fact, they are also similarly exposed to customers, who may already be positive. 

“It cannot continue like this. Cases are going to be there every day. Even if I test negative today, that does not mean I can’t be positive tomorrow. It feels like the government is using a sledgehammer to kill a fly.” 

Federation of Malaysian Consumers’ Associations president Datuk Marimuthu Nadason is of the opinion that temporarily shutting businesses with Covid-19 cases is not an issue, saying it does not ‘kill’ to take extra precautionary measures. – The Vibes file pic, February 3, 2021
Federation of Malaysian Consumers’ Associations president Datuk Marimuthu Nadason is of the opinion that temporarily shutting businesses with Covid-19 cases is not an issue, saying it does not ‘kill’ to take extra precautionary measures. – The Vibes file pic, February 3, 2021

At present, premises with Covid-19 infections have to cease operations temporarily to conduct disinfection and sanitisation, with the closure duration depending on the respective states and on a case-by-case basis. 

Since the start of the pandemic last year, hundreds of business premises have been instructed by the Health Ministry to close for disinfection, including hypermarkets, supermarkets and grocery chains. 

Ameer, who is also Malaysia Retailers’ Association vice-president, suggested that deep cleaning be conducted at night, after operating hours.

In the meantime, he said, a quick sanitisation could be carried out immediately in areas where a Covid-19-positive staffer might have been, while allowing other parts of the store to remain open. 

“By doing this, we can also stem rumours about the closure of business premises, which could create fear among the public, and further affect businesses.”

Existing SOPs enough to ensure consumers’ safety

Malaysian Muslim Consumers’ Association chief activist Datuk Nadzim Johan said Ameer’s suggestion for businesses to remain open despite cases among staff should be given serious consideration. 

He said he understands that there may be concerns among consumers, but added that existing standard operating procedures (SOPs) are sufficient to ensure their safety. 

“The government has already introduced SOPs, like wearing face masks and practising social distancing. They just need to comply. 

“When vaccines are rolled out later, do business premises still have to shut down if there are cases reported?”

He said the government should listen to business players, who, as it is, are making losses even without closures, due to the drop in sales resulting from movement restrictions.

Federation of Malaysian Consumers’ Associations president Datuk Marimuthu Nadason, however, believes the existing SOPs on closures should remain, saying it does not “kill” to take extra precautionary measures. 

“If there is a case, close down for one day, disinfect, then reopen. It’s very simple. Most importantly, we need to assure the public of (their) safety. This is the priority.” – The Vibes, February 3, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1d

Tajikistan eyes bigger role for Malaysia in Central Asian market

Malaysia / 1d

Sabah poverty figures, tourism ranking among Malaysia’s quieter gains, says World Bank economist

Opinion / 2d

Merdeka: This is our Malaysia – and you will not take it from us

Malaysia / 4d

Malaysia's July exports increase by 38.2 per cent

Malaysia / 4d

Alumni calls on Malaysia to increase intake of Thai uni students

Malaysia / 5d

Violence in Thailand: Visitors drop by almost 50 per cent

Spotlight

Malaysia

Singapore could bar under-18s from social media platforms that fail safety test

Malaysia

College student dies after falling from 22nd-floor condominium in Setapak

Malaysia

PM praised for ‘Medeka Day’ reforms; More needed to cope with rising costs – Guan Eng

By Ian McIntyre

World

Tupac Shakur murder case ends after 30 years as ex-gang leader found guilty

Malaysia

Unidentified man found dead in Sungai Buloh drain as police probe suspected murder

Malaysia

Four killed, four injured in 11-vehicle Pahang highway crash

Malaysia

Sarawak haze crisis deepens as five areas hit hazardous air quality

Opinion

Would the United States use nuclear weapons against Iran?

Malaysia

Tajikistan eyes bigger role for Malaysia in Central Asian market

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Container lorry plunges 20 metres into Gua Musang ravine, driver killed

Malaysia

Singapore could bar under-18s from social media platforms that fail safety test

Malaysia

Rosmah Mansor’s RM970m solar corruption appeal finally set for hearing

Malaysia

Sabah poverty figures, tourism ranking among Malaysia’s quieter gains, says World Bank economist

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Higher BUDI fuel quotas may help ease inflation, economist says

Malaysia

Four killed, four injured in 11-vehicle Pahang highway crash

Malaysia

Cloud seeding to target Sarawak haze and water shortages from Sept 3

Malaysia

Religious Affairs Ministry condemns Malaysian’s participation in Bangkok pageant