Malaysia

Vaccinating based on age groups may hinder more than help: virologist

India did it and is now paying a hefty price, with daily Covid-19 cases topping 100,000, warns Prof Sunil Kumar Lal

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 18 Apr 2021 10:00AM

Vaccinating based on age groups may hinder more than help: virologist
India now has three times the daily cases of the United States, the world’s worst-hit nation, and families are clamouring for drugs and hospital beds. – AFP pic, April 18, 2021

by Joseph Masilamany

KUALA LUMPUR – A molecular virologist is cautioning that vaccinating the population based on age group restrictions could have a major downside.

“Look at the Covid-19 infections in the country now. The number of infections is suddenly rising steeply. This is the outcome of vaccinating the population based on age group restrictions,” Prof Sunil Kumar Lal told The Vibes.

“This is the mistake India made by administering vaccination jabs in an ‘age-dependent step-wise release’, and is paying the price for it now. 

“We must learn from the mistakes of other countries, including the United States,” Sunil, an academician with the Petaling Jaya-based Monash University, said.

He said Malaysia is “somewhat” repeating the same mistake, although the magnitude at which cases are spiking in both countries are vastly different, what with India’s larger population.

Sunil said this is based on epidemiological reasoning.

“The 60-year-olds are not the ones going into crowded places in the first place. Essentially, 1.3 billion people in India have been without vaccine protection till April 1.  

“So, we are seeing the consequences of this disparity when portions of the population are vaccinated based on this ‘age group restriction’ model,” he said.

Monash University’s Prof Sunil Kumar Lal says Malaysia must learn from the mistakes of other countries, including the US. – Pic courtesy of Sunil Kumar Lal, April 18, 2021
Monash University’s Prof Sunil Kumar Lal says Malaysia must learn from the mistakes of other countries, including the US. – Pic courtesy of Sunil Kumar Lal, April 18, 2021

100,000 daily infections

According to India-based Scroll.in, India is undergoing the third phase of its Covid-19 vaccination roll-out, with those above 45 years old eligible for the shots.

Public and private hospitals have administered 80 million doses.

But this phase is coinciding with a second wave of Covid-19 infections in the country.

According to the news portal, three months after it began rolling out the vaccines, the country has hit a grim milestone, recording more than 100,000 fresh infections, with spikes in states like Maharashtra, Punjab, Chhattisgarh and Karnataka, among others. 

“Amid the rising cases, chief ministers of states like Maharashtra and Delhi have requested the removal of the ‘age limit for immunisation’ model amid the rising cases,” reported Scroll.in.

As to why the vaccination programme has not been opened to all, the news portal said the aim of the immunisation programme is not to administer the vaccine to those who want it but those who need it first.

“There are two aims for such vaccine drives; to prevent deaths and to protect the healthcare system,” Scroll.in reported, quoting Union Health secretary Rajesh Bhushan.

Meanwhile, Sunil said the current vaccines will be only ”partially effective” against new Covid-19 variants.

“Their effectiveness is low in protecting against Covid-19 infection and the potency of the vaccine will be further reduced.

“The new variants are constantly evolving, and we will not be able to get rid of it (Covid-19) or eradicate it for the next few years.” – The Vibes, April 18, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 3w

Kedah MB’s “Cina ada China, India ada India” remark draws criticism over citizenship narrative

Events / 4w

India’s MedTech firm Meril opens first Malaysian academy to expand clinical training network

Malaysia / 2mth

Anwar congratulates Modi on becoming India's longest-serving elected PM

Malaysia / 2mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Sports & Fitness / 3mth

Thomas Cup: France inch closer to historic triumph, faces reigning champions China in final

Sports & Fitness / 3mth

Thomas Cup: France on fire, outclass Japan to reach maiden semis

Spotlight

Malaysia

Six per cent growth proves Malaysia's economy remains resilient - PM

Malaysia

DAP must have an 'exit clause' if it opts to remain in government - Ramkarpal

Malaysia

Police looking for two women who allegedly stole gold bracelet (video)

Malaysia

BN’s relations with PN put further strains on PH - KJ

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

MRT suddenly stops at Bukit Bintang and all went dark (video)

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Couple plead guilty over death of three-month-old baby in their care

Malaysia

PKR allows Nurul Izzah open-ended leave to pursue PhD, keeps door open for return

Malaysia

Mediation centres are a positive alternative in defamation cases

You may be interested

Malaysia

MOF: RM1.2b STR Phase Three payments begin for 5.3 million recipients

Malaysia

Asyraf Wajdi hits back at attempts to link him to Tabung Haji controversies

Malaysia

Guan Eng accuses Penang CM of misleading people

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

MACC expands Tabung Haji probe to Makkah, Madinah investments and 1MDB-linked deal

Malaysia

PKR dismisses Bersatu cooperation talk as false ‘speculation’

Malaysia

Mohamad Hasan calls for tighter Tabung Haji governance after RCI findings

Malaysia

DAP must have an 'exit clause' if it opts to remain in government - Ramkarpal

Malaysia

Woman found dead in suitcase in Perak River as police open murder probe