Malaysia

Lawyer in Unduk Ngadau ‘cattle show’ controversy faces fresh suit, possibly over sedition

Sabah indigenous groups take umbrage at Marcel Jude Joseph over remarks in court submission

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 16 Jun 2021 1:53PM

Lawyer in Unduk Ngadau ‘cattle show’ controversy faces fresh suit, possibly over sedition
The Unduk Ngadau Kaamatan cultural pageant has been described by lawyer Marcel Jude Joseph in a court submission as ‘nothing more than an exotic cattle show, and almost feels like an auction’. – Facebook pic, June 16, 2021

by Jason Santos

KOTA KINABALU – The lawyer who branded the Unduk Ngadau Kaamatan cultural pageant an “exotic cattle show” faces yet another suit, with Sabah indigenous groups potentially calling for the Sedition Act 1948 to be used.

Deputy Chief Minister Datuk Seri Jeffrey Kitingan said the groups are offended by Marcel Jude Joseph’s court submission, and will file a case in the native and civil courts.

The Keningau MP said they may also call for the use of the Sedition Act, given the nature of the said submission.

“Although he has apologised, we see his apology as somewhat half-hearted and insincere. 

We’ve also found that he refused to amend the court submission, saying he was not able to do so as the matter is now in the courts. But according to a lawyer here, any submission to the courts can still be amended and corrected. 

“We also view the apology as admitting guilt over the remarks made, therefore, there is basis for us to act,” he said after a mediation meeting on the matter here today.

The groups involved are the Kadazandusun Cultural Association (KDCA), represented by Joanna Kitingan, Sabah Native Affairs Council president Benedict Topin, Persatuan Momogun Rungus Sabah president Datuk Jelani Hamdan, Sabah Murut Association’s Datuk Bobbey Suan and Sabah Cultural Board general manager Mackey Apisan. 

A police report has been lodged by KDCA, after it demanded an apology from Jude.

Jeffrey said all 26 district coordinators for the Unduk Ngadau pageant will lodge police reports and file suits in their respective native courts. 

The same action will be taken against former Sabah Star election candidate David Orok, who allegedly made a derogatory statement on Unduk Ngadau on Facebook.

Orok in 2014 was charged under the Sedition Act for insulting another religion.

Jude came under fire after his court submission, posted by a Facebook user, went viral.

Page 2 reads: “The (Unduk Ngadau) contest is not about women, it is just a contest, it doesn’t incorporate all women, whatever their talents and skills and education and abilities, it is nothing more than an exotic cattle show, and almost feels like an auction.”

Jeffrey expressed hope that the suits will serve as a lesson that no one should insult the cultures and customs of indigenous communities.

On Jude’s Sabah Star membership, he said the matter has been brought before the party’s disciplinary board. 

Asked whether a non-native can be charged in the native courts, he said this is allowed so long as a native person or group is involved. – The Vibes, June 16, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Sabah poverty figures, tourism ranking among Malaysia’s quieter gains, says World Bank economist

Opinion / 1w

Merdeka: This is our Malaysia – and you will not take it from us

Malaysia / 4w

Sabah and Sarawak can become 'kingmakers', determine who will lead Federal government

Malaysia / 4w

Warisan keeps Sabah pact talks open, pushes for local parties to contest 25 seats

Malaysia / 1mth

Sabah does not agree to 200-litre diesel quota, forms special committee - Masidi

Malaysia / 2mth

Tsunami alert: Stay calm and obey instructions from the authorities – Hajiji (video)

Spotlight

Malaysia

MP calls on US to take legal action against Hadi over ‘plot to topple government’ statement

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Malaysia needs to master its own technology - PM Anwar

Malaysia

RM2.48m lost daily to investment fraud syndicates since 2023

Malaysia

Rising bond rates are a sign of rising debt

Education

Selangor to close schools if API readings exceed 200

Malaysia

Loke: Keep Anwar as PM to complete reform agenda

Malaysia

Investigations into political leaders not driven by spite or political payback - PM

You may be interested

Malaysia

Budget 2027 may bring new relief for squeezed M40

Malaysia

SSM warns NGOs against collecting public donations without approval

Malaysia

Malaysia’s SMART Team begins HADR mission in Nepal

Malaysia

MP calls on US to take legal action against Hadi over ‘plot to topple government’ statement

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Penang’s Air Itam-Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu bypass nearing completion

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Zara Qairina’s father says he was never asked about post-mortem

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Why examining AirAsia’s finances may serve public interest

Malaysia

Negeri Sembilan MB reaffirms loyalty to Tuanku Muhriz amid throne dispute