Malaysia

Guan Eng cannot return as CM: Chow

Chief minister says it will be unconstitutional as former state head is not an MP, served two terms

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 05 May 2023 2:35PM

Guan Eng cannot return as CM: Chow
Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow has rebuked speculations claiming that Lim Guan Eng will return to serve as chief minister, as the move is deemed unconstitutional based on the state’s amended constitution. – ABDUL RAZAK LATIF/The Vibes file pic, May 5, 2023

by Ian McIntyre

GEORGE TOWN – Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow put to rest speculations that his predecessor Lim Guan Eng can return as the state’s top honcho, saying it is unconstitutional based on the state’s amended constitution.  

Under Article 7 Section 2 (a) of the Penang constitution, the Yang di-Pertua Negeri shall first appoint as chief minister to preside over the executive council, a member of the legislative assembly: (i) who in his judgement is likely to command the confidence of a majority of the members of the assembly, and (ii) who has not at any time held the office of the chief minister for two terms.

Chow told a press conference that the law is binding as of February 1, 2019, and there is no element of it being retrospective.  

“This law is applicable to all chief ministers. I hope this puts to rest the speculations.” 

In the past week, the rumour mill has persisted that Lim was considering returning as the state’s chief minister because he has no present position in government.  

Lim served as the finance minister from 2018 until 2020 when the Pakatan Harapan government then was overthrown in an indirect coup dubbed the “Sheraton Move”.  

Since then, the Bagan MP has relinquished his party post as secretary-general but assumed the post of DAP chairperson, which is seen more as a figurehead than an administrative one.  

Penang amended its constitution in 2018 to limit the position to two terms as it was part of the PH state manifesto during the 2013 general election.  

Chow said that the amended constitution was submitted to the Attorney-General Chambers on June 11, 2018, and it was also ratified by the state legislative assembly (November 2018). 

Penang South Islands project

In a separate issue, Chow said that the critics of the controversial Penang South Islands (PSI)  mega reclamation project, were trying to portray it as similar to the Forest City reclamation project in Johor Baru.  

Chow said that it was totally false, as PSI’s first reclaimed island which is now called Silicon Island, will consist more of greenery and commercial initiatives rather than housing, which is the main concept of Forest City.  

About 700 acres (30%-40%) is devoted to public facilities such as recreational grounds, 45% to waterways such as rivers and lakes while only 24.2% was only for housing.  

Forest City is mostly designed as a high-rise lifestyle residence with resort-like facilities. – The Vibes, May 5, 2023

Related News

Community / 12h

Paya Terubong landslide: Developer, landowner must take responsibility - CM

Community / 1d

Paya Terubong landslide: Resident writes to 15 ADUN to seek ban on hillslope development

Malaysia / 3d

Flash floods, landslides: Penangites asked to be on alert

Malaysia / 4d

Air Itam - Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu Expressway expected to be ready by April next year

Malaysia / 5d

Penang to seek greater clarification over Waze ban

Places / 1w

Penang makes National Geographic list of top 25 cities worldwide to visit

Spotlight

Education

Schools to get extra holidays for Deepavali

Malaysia

Getting angry at your wife for buying items online is a form of abuse, says minister

Malaysia

Man posing as Selangor crown prince’s aide arrested over RM960,020 scam

Malaysia

Dr Mahathir leaves late wife’s tahlil ceremony after feeling unwell

Malaysia

Chegubard jailed four months for defaming King

Malaysia

Court to hear Najib’s bid to revive RM1.9m suit against former AG on Nov 26

Malaysia

Malaysia climbs to 15th in global competitiveness rankings

Education

MOE: Close to 49,000 Year One pupils failed to master basic literacy and numeracy in 2025

You may be interested

Malaysia

Ex-cop asks AG to reopen 2015 assault case against MCBA chief

Malaysia

FELDA settler killed as axe-wielding suspect goes on rampage in Kota Tinggi (UPDATED)

Malaysia

Police officer jailed 7½ years over death of Form Five student in Ipoh

Malaysia

BN pledges settlement before nomination day following MCA’s backlash over Melaka candidates

Malaysia

Nine barred from BUDI MADANI as MOF probes suspected RM270,000 fuel subsidy abuse

Malaysia

Battersea project’s high upfront cost led to losses for Malaysian investors, says Anwar

Malaysia

Chegubard jailed four months for defaming King

Malaysia

Sarawak state election: GPS to contest all 82 seats - Abang Johari