France mulls introducing consent age as sex abuse claims pile up

PARIS – The French government has backed the introduction of a minimum age of sexual consent, a move that will bring it in line with most other Western countries, following years of campaigning by abuse victims.

The push for a change in the law has been given extra impetus by allegations brought by a woman who claims she was raped by more than 20 firefighters when she was a teenager, with a ruling in the long-running case expected later today.

Justice Minister Eric Dupond-Moretti yesterday said the government is “favourable that a new crime be established, whereby any act of sexual penetration by an adult involving a minor aged 15 is a crime”.

His proposal goes further than a bill drafted by members of the Senate, which calls for the age of consent to be set at 13.

Speaking to France 2 television the minister said public opinion has shifted on the issue of sex between adults and minors, long shrugged off in France as harmless in cases where the relations are presented as consensual.

Dupond-Moretti said the current requirement for underage victims to prove they are forced, threatened or duped into sex in order to bring charges of rape or sexual assault should be scrapped.

His office in a statement said the minister wants to ensure “equal treatment of all underage victims” in the eyes of the law.

“We are cracking open this sort of ideological leaden weight which prevent victims’ voices from being heard.”

Proving lack of consent

Judges are due to rule today on a long-running case brought by a woman known only as Julie (not her real name), who claims she was attacked during 2008 and 2010, when she was repeatedly hospitalised for severe anxiety attacks.

Each time she was taken to hospital required the intervention of the ambulance service, which is staffed by firefighters.

Three firefighters were initially charged with gang rape, but the charges were later downgraded to sexual violation under a law that makes it an offence – but not a crime – for someone in a position of authority to have sex with a minor.

To prove rape, victims in France must prove they were forced into sex even if they were underage. 

The firefighters insist Julie consented to sex, but her family say she was extremely vulnerable and incapable of granting consent. She herself has insisted she never expressly consented to sex.

Today, France’s top court will rule on her appeal against the downgrading of the charges. – AFP, February 10, 2021