World

Senate committee approves Trump court nominee as Democrats boycott

With Republicans holding a 53-47 majority in the US Senate her final approval is all but certain

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 22 Oct 2020 10:00PM

Senate committee approves Trump court nominee as Democrats boycott
Barrett's nomination will now go to the full Senate for debate and a planned vote on Monday. – AFP pic, October 22, 2020

WASHINGTON – The Senate Judiciary Committee pushed through US President Donald Trump's conservative pick for the Supreme Court, Amy Coney Barrett, Thursday as Democrats boycotted the vote saying it was too close to the November 3 election.

The unanimous vote, with all Democrats absent, sets the stage for full Senate approval at the beginning of next week on Barrett, who will tilt the high court firmly to the right.

On Wednesday Democrats labelled the rushed nomination process a "sham" that broke former Republican promises to never vote on a Supreme Court nominee so close to a presidential election.

"We will not grant this process any further legitimacy by participating in the committee markup of this nomination just 12 days before the culmination of an election that is already underway," they said in a statement.

But Republican committee chairman Lindsey Graham dismissed their action, and, taking advantage of their absence, moved up the vote by almost four hours.

"That was their choice," he said before the vote.

"It will be my choice to vote the nominee out of committee. We are not going to allow them to take over the committee."

Full vote on Monday

Barrett's nomination will now go to the full Senate for debate and a planned vote on Monday.

With Trump's Republicans holding a 53-47 majority in the Senate, final approval is near certain, even if two Republican senators say they do not agree with voting on her so close to a national election that polls show Trump could lose.

An appeals court judge and former law professor, Barrett's approval will give conservatives of 6-3 majority on the nine-member high court that has the potential to end protections for abortion and same-sex marriage rights and strike down a popular national health care program.

Approval will give Trump a key victory and appeal to his conservative voter base, many of whom consider winning conservative control of the court and banning abortion the primary issues in national politics.

Trump has said he wants a judge who will end abortion rights and help kill the Affordable Care Act, the so-called Obamacare program that extended health care overage to millions of uninsured Americans.

The court will hear a case on the ACA a week after the November 3 election.

A long-time law professor at the University of Notre Dame, and an appeals court judge for the past three years, the 48-year-old Barrett follows a somewhat fundamentalist school of US judicial thought, originalism, and is a devout Catholic.

Over two days of intensive questioning in Judiciary Committee hearings last week, she steadfastly avoided expressing her legal views, saying she would not address theoretical issues, but only judge cases as they come, on their own merits. 

"She will take her job on without agenda," Graham said Thursday."

"She understands that judging is not a cause, it is a process."

But in the hearings Barrett also refused to say if she would recuse herself if, in the days after joining the Supreme Court, she has to review any legal challenge on the results of the election.

Trump has said he wants her in place if the election results are fought up to the high court, as in 2000.

"I certainly hope that all members of the committee have more confidence in my integrity than to think that I would allow myself to be used as a pawn to decide the election for the American people," she said. – AFP, October 22, 2020

Related News

Opinion / 1y

The Trump dilemma and reclaiming balance: The urgent need for fair global trade

Malaysia / 2y

Sanctions on 4 Malaysia-based companies still in place, says US official

Business / 2y

US court orders J&J, Kenvue to pay US$45 million over death of baby powder user

World / 2y

Aid for Ukraine held hostage by US politics

Malaysia / 2y

Cops say no info yet on repatriation of two Malaysians from Guantanamo Bay

Malaysia / 2y

Penang-born fugitive Fat Leonard sent back to the US

Spotlight

Malaysia

Johor state election: MACC receives three reports of alleged corruption

Malaysia

Banks need to do more to help counter rising costs of living – Guan Eng

By Ian McIntyre

Business

BNM holds OPR at 2.75 per cent

Malaysia

MACC: No one off limits in probe into US$13 million luxury property deal

Malaysia

Govt rejects claims Jho Low secretly returned to Malaysia for 1MDB asset talks

Malaysia

School stabbing incident: Suspect claimed she was dissatisfied, allegedly bullied

Places

Four premier hotels in Penang to be restored, open doors soon

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Rosmah demands action against Nga over alleged misleading election poster in Johor polls

Malaysia

Malaysia faces RM51.4b 1MDB burden after recovering RM31.3b in funds and assets

You may be interested

World

Trump declares Iran peace accord 'over'

World

Amnesty calls for war crimes probe into Israeli strikes in Lebanon that allegedly killed entire families

World

Fresh US strikes on Iran deepen ceasefire crisis as Trump warns of escalation

World

US-Iran ceasefire under renewed strain as Washington launches fresh strikes

World

Tehran retaliates against US bases in the Gulf

World

China flood death toll rises to 39 in Guangxi as rescue teams race against further typhoon threat

World

61 passengers leave Bangladesh airport after visa checks halt Malaysia-bound flight travellers

World

Cargo plane wreckage found off Pakistan as search for 5 crew members continues