Malaysia

Defence shows court videos contradicting testimony of Siti Bainun’s abuse

Witness Yasmin Nahar Mahmood however sticks to story, denies she is lying

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 16 Apr 2022 7:00AM

Defence shows court videos contradicting testimony of Siti Bainun’s abuse
Siti Bainun Ahd Razali, 30, is charged with two counts of neglecting and abusing Bella between February and June 2021, resulting in the victim sustaining physical and emotional injuries. – Bernama pic, April 16, 2022

KUALA LUMPUR – The sessions court here yesterday was shown several video recordings of the treatment given to residents who were allegedly treated like slaves by Rumah Bonda founder Siti Bainun Ahd Razali.

The recordings showed a birthday celebration for Yasmin Nahar Mahmood, 19, who was then a resident of the home; Yasmin vacationing with Siti Bainun at a hotel, and one taken during a Hari Raya celebration.

In earlier proceedings, Yasmin, the fifth prosecution witness, said she had been treated like a slave by Siti Bainun while staying at the shelter.

Cross-examining Yasmin, Nur A’minahtul Mardiah Md Nor, the lawyer representing Siti Bainun, asked her if Siti Bainun treated her like a slave despite the footage showing otherwise

Yasmin replied: “Yes.”

The reply came during Nur A’minahtul’s cross-examination of the witness in defence of Siti Bainun, who is accused of neglecting and abusing a 13-year-old teenager with Down Syndrome only known as Bella.

Referring to the Hari Raya celebration video recorded on May 22, 2021,Yasmin agreed with Nur A’minahtul that Bella hugged Siti Bainun for a long time.

Nur A’minahtul: “Bella gave her abuser a long tight hug?”

Yasmin: “Yes.”

Nur A’minahtul: “So Bella wasn’t afraid of her abuser?”

Yasmin: “Yes.”

In yesterday’s proceedings, the defence listed 10 of Yasmin’s statements which were said to be lies and false statements.

Among them were that Bella’s legs had become weak after the frequent abuse – the video recording showed Bella could walk normally – and that she had been beaten with a clothing hanger until it broke; the defence noted that Yasmin was then at a shelter in Jitra, Kedah at the time of the incident.

Yasmin however denied that the statements she had given were false.

Earlier when questioned by another defence lawyer,  Asiah Abdul Jalil, Yasmin said Siti Bainun had instructed her to apply medicine to the wounds on Bella’s body and the medicines were bought by the accused herself.

The witness agreed the medicines used on Bella included aloe vera moisturiser, iodine solution, wound spray, antiseptic solution, and wound dressing as shown in a photograph.

Siti Bainun, 30, is charged with two counts of neglecting and abusing the teen between February and June 2021, resulting in the victim sustaining physical and emotional injuries.

The trial before judge Izralizam Sanusi continues next Wednesday. – Bernama, April 15, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Speaker congratulates Muar MP as he rushes off after Budget presentation

Culture / 2mth

Syed Saddiq, Bella Astillah to wed on Oct 10 in all-white ceremony

Malaysia / 1y

‘Bella’ and seven others charged for threatening, extorting and confining a man

Malaysia / 1y

Syed Saddiq, family members and Bella Astillah arrive at Putrajaya court

Culture & Lifestyle / 1y

‘So, when is the big day?’ Anwar asks Syed Saddiq

Malaysia / 2y

Bella's boyfriend charged for murder, police pinpoint jealousy as motive

Spotlight

Malaysia

Eight homes evacuated after recurring landslides raise safety fears in Shah Alam

Malaysia

Najib’s pension suspended, Saifuddin confirms

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: PH to abolish seven appointed state assembly positions

Malaysia

Naked body of woman found floating in river

Malaysia

Dzulkefly praises HKL’s success in reattaching police officer’s hand

Malaysia

Four homes remain unsafe as Penang landslide stabilisation takes up to five months

Malaysia

1MDB allowed to admit affidavit of Rosmah’s shopping partner in its case

Malaysia

Najib faces four conditions under house arrest, including restrictions on movement and visitors

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Anwar demands firm action over attack that severed policeman's wrist

Malaysia

Malaysia moves to tighten data centre controls amid scrutiny over Nvidia chip exports

Malaysia

Wisma Putra prepares evacuation plans for citizens amid Houthi attacks

Malaysia

Four homes remain unsafe as Penang landslide stabilisation takes up to five months

Malaysia

Google Maps lists Najib’s Langgak Duta home as ‘prison mansion’

Malaysia

Guan Eng praises Loke for his leadership, principles

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

KL police chief warns officers against hesitation when facing armed threats

Malaysia

Sungai Pertak flash flood death toll rises to six as another body found