Malaysia

Rookie junior engineers behind LCS design: declassified report

Project delays worsened by skilled labour shortage, according to findings

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 17 Aug 2022 8:55PM

Rookie junior engineers behind LCS design: declassified report
The littoral combat ships project has been embroiled in controversy lately due to how the government has paid RM6.08 billion to Boustead Naval Shipyard Sdn Bhd for the plan but has yet to receive a single ship, allegedly due to financial instability and financial mismanagement. – Hishammuddin Hussein Facebook pic, August 17, 2022

by Qistina Nadia Dzulqarnain

KUALA LUMPUR – In another shocking discovery in the littoral combat ships (LCS) controversy, the main contractor Boustead Naval Shipyard Sdn Bhd (BNS) had hired some inexperienced junior engineers to design the RM9 billion vessels, contributing to delays in their completion. 

The delays were also aggravated by a shortage in skilled labour, especially when subcontractors refused to risk sending their experienced welders and quality control personnel due to late payments. 

These were some of the labour issues revealed in today’s declassified Investigating Committee on Procurement, Governance and Finance (JKSTUPKK) report on LCS, which highlighted weaknesses in the project’s management. 

The 106-page report laid bare how the project faced manpower scarcity and commercial issues, which affected the delivery schedules.

It added that detailed designs and production drawings for the first LCS were delayed until September 2019, when it was supposed to be finalised in December 2016. 

The same issue was encountered during the building of the second LCS, which also faced installation setbacks due to labour shortage and contractual issues with a Dutch company. 

The other ships also had similar issues, with the final ship seeing a delay in awarding an intent letter for steel kits to a contractor.

The steel kits for all six ships, which were supposed to be delivered by a Dutch company in stages from December 2015 to August 2017, were delayed due to a contract issue between BNS and an original equipment manufacturer (OEM). 

The Dutch company was not identified in the declassified report.

Besides that, the report said seven OEMs had opted to stop work on the LCS due to BNS’ commercial problems while there were cooperation problems between BNS and French-based Naval Group (formerly DCNS) on design matters. 

The detailed design phase, which involved importing basic designs to production drawings for the building of vessel gear, had been suspended.

The committee also deemed BNS as being unable to settle its debts valued at RM733 million as of May 31, 2019. 

Earlier, it was reported that the committee found BNS to have poor financial capability, and is expected to face serious issues in servicing loans amounting to nearly RM1 billion. 

Putrajaya could also be forking out an eye-watering RM11.145 billion in total for the six LCS, which is a substantial increase from the RM9 billion agreed upon years ago as BNS has claimed that it will need additional funds to complete all the vessels. 

The LCS project has been embroiled in controversy lately due to how the government has paid RM6.08 billion to BNS for the plan but has yet to receive a single ship, allegedly due to financial instability and financial mismanagement. 

Previously, the Public Accounts Committee had released a report on August 4 highlighting various discrepancies and apparent misconduct in the project over the years while recommending the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commision take prosecutive action against those involved in the scandal. – The Vibes, August 17, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 2y

PAC to table report on LCS next month

Business / 2y

BHIC unit disposes of 20.77% stake in Boustead Naval Shipyard for RM1

Malaysia / 2y

LCS project set to resume next month, first ship expected at end-2026: navy

Malaysia / 3y

LCS: PAC to visit Lumut naval base, commence proceedings on Saturday

Malaysia / 3y

Transparency International again demands govt explain LCS issues

Malaysia / 3y

MoF has no choice but to take over LCS project: Anwar

Spotlight

Malaysia

‘No such thing as Bangkok Move or Dubai Move’ – Ahmad Zahid

Malaysia

KSN: Rectify long waiting times, service challenges and workforce constraints at UMMC now

Malaysia

LGE trial: 4 to 5 meetings held before open tender bidding for road, undersea tunnel projects - witness

Malaysia

Najib marks 73rd birthday as legal battles continue from behind prison walls

Malaysia

Court orders police to probe foreign management institute

Malaysia

UMNO pushes back against Hamzah’s ‘PBN’ proposal, says BN-PN cooperation is not a new coalition

Malaysia

Form four student killed after car crosses into opposite lane in Setiu crash

World

France heatwave death toll rises to nearly 5,800 as extreme temperatures trigger record mortality

Culture

Penang: Three refurbished tourism attractions to be ‘reopened’ soon

By Ian McIntyre

You may be interested

Malaysia

Muhyiddin rejects Khaled’s 'kacau daun' jibe, says Bersatu is in Negeri to win

Malaysia

Ministry boosts RE drive with 127.59mw Pasir Mas solar projects as green transition gains momentum

Malaysia

PH promises high-tech future for Negeri Sembilan with new economic growth corridor plan

Malaysia

Johari holds first talks with USTR Greer to balance US trade measures

Malaysia

Four terrace houses destroyed in Taiping fire, no casualties reported

Malaysia

LGE trial: 4 to 5 meetings held before open tender bidding for road, undersea tunnel projects - witness

Malaysia

Woman, two teenagers performing ‘Superman’ stunts on their motorcycles charged (video)

Malaysia

It’s humane economy rooted in justice, dignity and moral purpose over political popularity - Anwar