Malaysia

Federal Court reserves judgment on Malaysiakini appeal

Panel says it needs time to digest lengthy submissions on Raub Australian Gold Mine case

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 01 Dec 2020 7:10PM

Federal Court reserves judgment on Malaysiakini appeal
The Court of Appeal had in 2018 found that three articles and two videos published by Malaysiakini in 2012 related to RAGM were unbalanced and one-sided. – Pixabay pic, December 1, 2020

PUTRAJAYA – The Federal Court today has reserved its decision to a date yet to be fixed on Malaysiakini's appeal against an appellate court decision ordering the news portal pay RM200,000 in damages to Raub Australian Gold Mine (RAGM) over the publication of defamatory articles.

A five-member panel chaired by Justice Datuk Vernon Ong Lam Kiat decided to reserve judgment after hearing lengthy submissions from Malaysiakini's counsel Datuk Dr Cyrus Das and Tan Sri Cecil Abraham for RAGM, via online proceedings due to the conditional movement control order (CMCO).

“We thank both counsels for the comprehensive written and oral submissions. We need time to digest (the submissions) so we will advise the parties once the grounds of our decision are ready,” said Vernon.

Presiding with him were Federal Court judges Datuk Abdul Rahman Sebli, Puan Sri Zaleha Yusof, Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Datuk Rhodzariah Bujang.

On January 11, 2018, the Court of Appeal reversed a Kuala Lumpur High Court decision and ordered Malaysiakini and three other defendants, who were members of the editorial staff, to pay RM200,000 in damages and RM150,000 in legal costs.

The Court of Appeal had found that the three articles and two videos published in 2012 in relation to the gold-mining activities of RAGM were unbalanced and one-sided as they did not carry responses from the Department of Environment, Health Ministry or Land and Mines Department.

On May 23, 2016, the High Court dismissed RAGM’s claim against Malaysiakini and the other three defendants.

Earlier, Cyrus submitted that the articles and videos were published based on information and extracts sourced from other news publications, various blogs and reproductions of two press conferences, which were called by the Ban Cyanide Action Committee (BCAC) formed by the Bukit Koman residents against the use of cyanide by RAGM in their mining activities.

“The Court of Appeal also failed to have regard to the evidence that at the outset, the appellants attempted to contact the representatives of the respondent for their comments prior to publications concerning the respondent's gold-mining activities. The respondent consistently refused or avoided contact and communications with the appellants.

“Given that all the articles and videos are of public interest, the appellants, therefore, published the same without the comments of the respondent as the opportunity had been given but declined by the respondent. The Court of Appeal, however, misread the evidence and held that there was a failure of verification to the extent that the defence of responsible journalism was denied,” said Cyrus.

Meanwhile, Cecil submitted that the articles and videos bear an accusatory tone, which leans in favour of giving wide political coverage of politicians from the opposition at that time and the BCAC's unverified and false assertions.

He further submitted that it was apparent that the appellants have functioned as nothing more than a blog, publishing untruths in the hopes of securing a large readership and attention for their articles by using sensational and entirely inaccurate information.

“I would respectfully submit my lords and ladies that this case is one of the worst cases of irresponsible journalism. On the issue of verification, my learned friend (Cyrus) suggested to my lords and ladies that there was verification. With the greatest respect, there is in fact no verification.

“My learned friend said they asked Mr Andrew Kam (RAGM chairman and CEO Datuk Seri Andrew Kam), that was in respect of the judicial review proceedings which were pending before the court and because of that reason, Mr Andrew Kam did not want to comment,” he said, hoping that this appeal would be dismissed with costs. – Bernama, December 1, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 4w

Man jailed for 9 months after admitting to stealing women's undergarments at laundromat

Malaysia / 4w

10 former Negeri Excos file application in Federal Court to challenge revocation of appointments

Malaysia / 4w

UK academic fights to be allowed to leave Malaysia for father’s funeral

Malaysia / 2mth

Saravanan charged with accepting bribe of nearly RM1.1 million

Malaysia / 2mth

‘Stop playing games and get your facts right’ – Ramkarpal tells Sanusi

Malaysia / 3mth

Is reputation worth so much more than a person’s life?

Spotlight

Malaysia

Geopolitical tensions must not derail regional economic integration - Anwar

Malaysia

Najib has been given a second chance. But where is the accountability to Malaysians?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

PAS joins BN in sitting out Sarawak polls

Malaysia

PAC to probe possible financial breaches, abuse of power in Sabah Pan Borneo project

Malaysia

Landowners cannot demolish unauthorised places of worship themselves, says Nga

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Differing views do not constitute treason – lawyer

Malaysia

Suspected criminal shot dead in exchange of fire with police in Perak

You may be interested

Malaysia

Surging power demand puts ASEAN grid integration in strategic spotlight

Malaysia

Penang CM: Guan Eng dismisses explanations, misleads the public  

Malaysia

Umno’s royal loyalty credentials face test in Negeri Sembilan

Malaysia

Mother and child killed in pre-dawn house fire in Batu Pahat

Malaysia

PN gets one seat in 10-member Melaka Exco, BN dominates line-up

Malaysia

Father of deceased boarding school student calls for transparent, thorough probe

Malaysia

Those who breach rules, discipline, standards of conduct must resign - Anwar

Malaysia

Malaysians urged to update phones to avoid missing emergency alerts