Malaysia

Johor Orang Asli community fight to maintain land, way of life

Although state has clarified meaning of sultanate land status, villagers still worried

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 08 Apr 2023 8:00AM

Johor Orang Asli community fight to maintain land, way of life
Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon villagers live along the Johor Straits and depend on the sea for a living. However, recent land reclamation projects have affected their work. – ARJUN MOHANAKRISHNAN/The Vibes pic, April 8, 2023 

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

JOHOR BARU – After settling a 10-year land dispute earlier this year, the Seletar community of Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon is concerned over calls to classify native settlements as “sultanate land.”  

Although the state government has explained that the proposed status does not mean the sultan would have ownership of the land, Southern Johor Fishermen’s Association board member and village resident Tony Anak Dana said settlers in the village here have been in constant battles to maintain their way of life.   

In 2013, after the Johor government alienated their land to developer Node Dua Sdn Bhd, residents of Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon filed a suit which reached a settlement in January this year after the dispute reached the high court.   

According to the settlement, the villagers will be relocated a 90-minute drive away to Kg Orang Asli Pasir Salam in Ulu Tiram and would receive RM6,500 compensation from the Johor government, among other things.   

Southern Johor Fishermen’s Association board member and Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon resident Tony Anak Dana has said that although he is aware that the proposed sultanate land status does not mean the sultan would own the land, villagers there have always had to battle to maintain their way of living. – ARJUN MOHANAKRISHNAN/The Vibes pic, April 8, 2023 
Southern Johor Fishermen’s Association board member and Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon resident Tony Anak Dana has said that although he is aware that the proposed sultanate land status does not mean the sultan would own the land, villagers there have always had to battle to maintain their way of living. – ARJUN MOHANAKRISHNAN/The Vibes pic, April 8, 2023 

Additionally, the new settlement will be located along Sg Johor which may be a new environment for the village’s seafaring Seletar community.   

However, Tony said not everyone in the village was satisfied with the terms of the settlement, adding that the villagers would like to remain in the area.  

We aren’t satisfied with the decision, but what can we do? 

“The new village is quite far, it is 90 minutes away,” Tony said.  

Tony said the village residents were not happy and expressed concern over the decision to designate Orang Asli land as “sultanate land.”  

He said this sentiment was shared among all Orang Asli communities and not residents of Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon alone.  

“The decision to put our land under the Johor sultan was done on the basis that our land won’t be misused. 

Around 400-m away from Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon lies a large sand pile understood to be part of a land-reclamation project. – Google Earth pic, April 8, 2023
Around 400-m away from Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon lies a large sand pile understood to be part of a land-reclamation project. – Google Earth pic, April 8, 2023

Orang Asli communities all over Malaysia just want rights to the land that they reside in, not being placed under the protection of another,” Tony added.  

On March 16, Sultan of Johor Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar urged the state government to classify all Orang Asli settlements in the state as sultanate land, to avoid their misuse.  

Although Menteri Besar Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi explained that the reclassification did not mean that the Johor sultan would own the land, Johor Network of Orang Asli Villages chairman Dolah Tekoi rejected the idea.  

He said that Orang Asli settlements should not be placed under the ruler’s protection, given that there are legislative safeguards such as the Aboriginal Peoples Act 1954 and National Land Code in place.  

Not just land, we have problems at sea too 

Villagers at Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon live along the Johor Straits and depend heavily on the sea for a living.  

Most settlers are fishermen, operate mussel “kelong” (platforms), or rent land to outsiders who operate seafood restaurants.  

However, recent land-reclamation projects have affected the work of the village’s residents.  

In fact, around 400-m away from Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon lies a large sand pile understood to be part of a land-reclamation project.  

Most of the people in Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon are fishermen and operate mussel platforms, also known as ‘kelong’, as pictured here. – ARJUN MOHANAKRISHNAN/The Vibes pic, April 8, 2023 
Most of the people in Kg Orang Asli Sg Temon are fishermen and operate mussel platforms, also known as ‘kelong’, as pictured here. – ARJUN MOHANAKRISHNAN/The Vibes pic, April 8, 2023 

Tony refused to name the developer in question but explained that projects such as these have resulted in profits for fishermen dwindling by 80%.  

However, Tony noted the developer provided compensation to the fishermen, but described the amount received as merely a “consolation prize.” 

“Due to the land reclamation projects here, our catch from the sea has reduced by 20%.  

“We did receive compensation from the developer, but each fisherman received slightly over RM1,000.  

“That’s not enough compensation, that’s merely a consolation prize,” Tony explained. – The Vibes, April 8, 2023 

Related News

Malaysia / 13h

After Johor, the uncomfortable question for Anwar’s critics: Were we too impatient?

Opinion / 13h

Orang Asli in Pahang: Token gestures or genuine recognition?

Malaysia / 1w

Higher voter turnout in Johor reflects confidence in BN, not anti-incumbent sentiment, says analyst

Malaysia / 1w

PRN Johor: Take accountability, not blame others – former MP tells PH

Malaysia / 1w

PN wiped out in Johor, faces uphill battle in Negeri Sembilan, says analyst

Malaysia / 1w

DAP emerges as biggest loser in Johor polls after losing Chinese strongholds, says analyst

Spotlight

Malaysia

After Johor, the uncomfortable question for Anwar’s critics: Were we too impatient?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Network School's business licences revoked, to cease operations tomorrow

Opinion

Orang Asli in Pahang: Token gestures or genuine recognition?

Malaysia

Tuition teacher sentenced to 105 years in prison and 70 lashes for raping daughter

Malaysia

Azam Baki denies involvement in RM178.29 million contract linked to brother’s company

Malaysia

Aminuddin urges NS voters to weigh manifesto promising benefits for M40 and B40 groups

Malaysia

No need to resign, PM has absolute power if there is doubt – Ahmad Zahid

World

Gaza’s water crisis deepens as families face thirst, disease and collapsing sanitation systems

You may be interested

Malaysia

After Johor, the uncomfortable question for Anwar’s critics: Were we too impatient?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Network School's business licences revoked, to cease operations tomorrow

Malaysia

Voters place greater emphasis on government performance than traditional political assumptions - INSAP

Malaysia

140 Palestinian NGOs support Khan over denial of due process

By Abbi Kanthasamy

Malaysia

Who is Sarah? What we know about the Malaysian lawyer at the centre of the Karim Khan case

Malaysia

KWAP’s eFishery loss triggers governance review as Anwar backs full investigation

Malaysia

Telco identifies suspect in data breach as MCMC demands full report

Malaysia

PH banks on Negeri Sembilan development record as campaign heats up