Malaysia

‘Profits over people’: Top Glove workers speak up on filthy, crowded dorms

Covid-19 outbreak among employees of world’s biggest rubber glove manufacturer looks set to impact global supply amid pandemic

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 13 Dec 2020 11:46AM

‘Profits over people’: Top Glove workers speak up on filthy, crowded dorms
Top Glove’s mainly migrant workers say the company has not done enough to protect them from Covid-19 despite repeated warnings. – The Vibes file pic, December 13, 2020

KUALA LUMPUR – Bangladeshi migrant worker Sheikh Kibria recalls with horror the filthy, overcrowded dormitory where he was housed by the world’s biggest rubber glove manufacturer when a coronavirus outbreak erupted and infected thousands.

Malaysia’s Top Glove Corporation Bhd saw profits soar and its stock price jump as much as 400% this year as countries worldwide rushed to buy protective gear as the Covid-19 pandemic intensified.

But in interviews with AFP, the South Asian migrants working flat out to make the gloves – typically earning around US$300 (RM1,215) a month – described appalling living conditions in cramped dormitories, where up to 25 people sleep in bunk beds in a single room.

Some said the company has not done enough to protect them despite repeated warnings.

The scandal has added to growing pressure on the firm, already under scrutiny after the US banned the import of some of its gloves over allegations of forced labour earlier this year.

The infections also prompted factory closures, and look set to have an impact on global supply.

Top Glove, which commands about a quarter of the world market, has warned of delays to deliveries, and rising prices.

‘Didn’t keep workers safe’

More than 5,000 workers – almost a quarter of the firm’s workforce – have tested positive after the outbreak at an industrial area housing factories and dormitories outside the capital here.

“The accommodation is so overcrowded,” said Kibria.

“The room itself is a bare minimum. It is quite impossible to maintain cleanliness when so many people live in a single room. It is like an army barracks – only less maintained.”

When the situation escalated last month, Top Glove began shifting infected workers to hospital and their close contacts to quarantine centres, reducing the numbers in dormitories.

Kibria, 24, was suspected of having Covid-19, so was first put in hospital, although he later tested negative and was moved to a hotel.

But, critics said such actions are too little, too late.

Top Glove employs 21,000 people and can produce 90 billion gloves a year. – The Vibes file pic, December 13, 2020
Top Glove employs 21,000 people and can produce 90 billion gloves a year. – The Vibes file pic, December 13, 2020

“The company had discussed decreasing people in the rooms before infections began, but it never happened,” said a Nepali production line worker, Karan Shrestha.

“The rooms stayed crowded – and in the end, coronavirus cases started to increase.

“The company didn’t keep the workers safe. They are greedy, and were more concerned about their income and profits.”

‘Really scared’

As cases spiralled, the government ordered 28 Top Glove factories to close out of the 41 it operates in Malaysia.

Authorities are planning legal action against the company over poor worker accommodation, which could result in heavy fines.

The firm, which has 21,000 staff and can produce 90 billion gloves a year, insists that it is making improvements.

It has spent RM20 million to buy new worker accommodation in the past two months, and plans to build “mega hostels” kitted out with modern facilities that can house up to 7,300 people.

“We are mindful that there is much more to be done to uplift the standard of our employee welfare, and promise to rectify shortcomings immediately,” said managing director Lee Kim Meow.

His comments come as the company announced a 20-fold jump in quarterly net profit to RM2.4 billion.

For those campaigning for low-paid migrants, the controversy highlights how companies continue to put profits before people.

“The company, its investors and its buyers have prioritised the delivery of more gloves, more quickly and at higher profitability, over the welfare of its mainly migrant-worker labour force,” said Andy Hall, a migrant labour specialist who focuses on Asia.

Malaysia, a relatively affluent Southeast Asian country of 32 million, has long attracted migrants from poorer parts of the region to work in industries ranging from manufacturing to agriculture.

Top Glove said the vast majority of staff who tested positive have already been released from hospital, and some factories are now reopening.

But, some workers remain terrified at the prospect of returning to the production line, despite the company trying to enforce social distancing and providing protective gear.

“If we work in the factory, I would be really scared,” said Salman from Bangladesh, speaking from his hostel.

“Even with extra safety, it is really tough to prevent an outbreak.”

AFP used pseudonyms to protect the workers’ identities, as they were fearful about speaking out. – AFP, December 13, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 5mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Malaysia / 8mth

Bad move to channel EPF dividends into Account 3 for festive withdrawals, cautions economist

Opinion / 1y

A tale of two administrations: How Warisan and GRS shaped Sabah’s future

Malaysia / 1y

MOH closely monitoring Covid-19 amid rising cases in neighbouring countries

Opinion / 1y

The Trump dilemma and reclaiming balance: The urgent need for fair global trade

Culture & Lifestyle / 1y

Renowned public health expert honoured at award ceremony in Penang

Spotlight

Malaysia

Geopolitical tensions must not derail regional economic integration - Anwar

Malaysia

Najib has been given a second chance. But where is the accountability to Malaysians?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

PAS joins BN in sitting out Sarawak polls

Malaysia

PAC to probe possible financial breaches, abuse of power in Sabah Pan Borneo project

Malaysia

Landowners cannot demolish unauthorised places of worship themselves, says Nga

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Differing views do not constitute treason – lawyer

Malaysia

Suspected criminal shot dead in exchange of fire with police in Perak

You may be interested

Malaysia

Surging power demand puts ASEAN grid integration in strategic spotlight

Malaysia

Unidentified body found at Pandan Jaya LRT station, police appeal for public help

Malaysia

Najib’s house arrest: Govt, AG, Hannah opposed conditional pardon, minutes show

Malaysia

Umno seeks clarification on declassification of Najib's pardon board minutes

Malaysia

Federal debt ratio targeted to fall to 60pc by 2030 despite RM1.76 trillion debt, liabilities

Malaysia

Attack on the KLSCAH lease agreement an attack on freedom of speech

Malaysia

Anwar orders immediate, transparent probe into death of Perak boarding school student

Malaysia

Ismail meets Negeri Sembilan ruler amid leadership uncertainty