World

Covid-19 origins probe ‘being poisoned by politics’: WHO

Discourse around investigation, often speculative and critical, making it hard to focus on the science, says emergencies chief

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 29 May 2021 2:15PM

Covid-19 origins probe ‘being poisoned by politics’: WHO
Several members of the international World Health Organisation team of experts tasked with probing into Covid-19 origins seen in Wuhan, China, in January this year. – AFP pic, May 29, 2021

GENEVA – The World Health Organisation (WHO) warned today that efforts to uncover the Covid-19 pandemic’s origins are being hampered by politics, insisting that scientists needed space to work on solving the mystery.

“We would ask that we separate the science from the politics, and let us get on with finding the answers that we need in a proper, positive atmosphere,” WHO emergencies chief Michael Ryan told reporters.

“This whole process is being poisoned by politics,” he warned. 

The UN health agency has been facing intensifying pressure for a new, more in-depth investigation of where Covid-19 came from, but so far there has been no timeline for the next stage in the probe.

US President Joe Biden this week ordered the US intelligence community to investigate whether the Covid-19 virus first emerged in China from an animal source or from a laboratory accident.

The move hints at growing impatience with waiting for a conclusive WHO investigation into how the pandemic that has killed more than 3.5 million people worldwide began. 

During an ongoing meeting of WHO member states, European Union countries and a range of others also pressed for clarity on the next steps in the organisation’s efforts to solve the mystery, seen as vital to averting future pandemics.

‘No timeline’

But the UN health agency said earlier today that it is still waiting for recommendations from a team of WHO technical experts on how to move forward.

“The technical team will prepare a proposal for the next studies that need to be carried out, and will present that to the director-general,” spokesman Fadela Chaib told reporters.

“He will then work with member states on the next steps,” she said, acknowledging “there is no timeline”.

WHO finally managed to send a team of independent, international experts to Wuhan in January, more than a year after Covid-19 first surfaced there in late 2019, to help probe into the pandemic origins.

But in their long-delayed report published in late March, the international team and their Chinese counterparts drew no firm conclusions, instead ranking a number of hypotheses according to how likely they believed they were.

‘Impossible position’

The report said the virus jumping from bats to humans via an intermediate animal was the most probable scenario, while a theory involving the virus leaking from a laboratory was “extremely unlikely”.

But the investigation and report have faced criticism for lacking transparency and access, and for not evaluating the lab-leak theory more deeply – a mere 440 words of the report were dedicated to discussing and dismissing it.

WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has also continued to insist that all theories remain on the table and further investigation is needed.

Long dismissed as a right-wing conspiracy theory, and vehemently rejected by Beijing, the idea that Covid-19 emerged from a lab leak in Wuhan has been gaining increasing momentum in the United States.

While not suggesting that a lab leak was necessarily the source, a number of prominent international scientists have said a deeper, more scientific look at the theory was needed.

“Every country and every entity is free to pursue their own particular theories of origin... It’s a free world,” Ryan said.

But he complained that the discourse around the origins search, and around WHO’s role in it, was making it difficult to focus on the science.

“Putting WHO in a position like it has been put in is very unfair to the science we’re trying to carry out,” he said.

“It puts us, as an organisation, frankly in an impossible position to deliver the answers that the world wants.” – AFP, May 29, 2021

Related News

Community / 3y

M’sian tells of managing Wuhan hotel during height of pandemic

Health / 3y

WHO, US health authorities tracking new Covid-19 variant

Health / 3y

Even one alcoholic drink a day could be bad for your health, study says

Wellness / 3y

Half the world’s population will experience a mental health disorder by age 75

World / 3y

WHO warns against using artificial sweeteners

Health / 3y

Youth with mental health issues have higher risk of heart attack: study

Spotlight

Malaysia

Tuanku Muhriz to focus on state affairs; Will not attend Conference of Rulers meeting

Malaysia

Sarawak projects record RM15.09b revenue, budgets RM10.1b for development in 2027

Malaysia

Sultan Nazrin: Delay in environmental action places future generations at risk

Malaysia

Woman allegedly raped at KL shopping centre after being threatened with intimate video

Malaysia

Jordan’s King confers highest civilian honour on Sultan Ibrahim

Malaysia

Driver monitoring aims to stop commercial vehicle crashes before they happen

Malaysia

KTMB heritage sites set for tourism makeover, says Loke

Malaysia

Zara Qairina’s mother: No doctors recorded injuries consistent with being beaten

You may be interested

World

Houthi attacks hit Riyadh, Dammam airports as Saudi Arabia faces mounting security threat

World

Man dies after entering tiger enclosure at UK wildlife park

World

Bangladesh to deploy army at two new posts near Rohingya camps amid rising crime

World

Iran says US response on Hormuz Strait reopening proposal falls short

World

Trump calls for Zelenskiy’s removal after deadly Russian strike kills 20 in Ukraine

World

India releases youth protest leaders after detention as voter-list row deepens

World

Trump weighs joining Saudi strikes after deadly Houthi attack on Riyadh airport