Malaysia

M’sian doctor in Sydney rapped for condemning trans patient

Netizens outraged by invasive, probing questions posed by Dr Shaiful Aizad

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 20 Jan 2021 6:11PM

M’sian doctor in Sydney rapped for condemning trans patient
Dr Shaiful Aizad has drawn criticism over his Facebook posting detailing invasive questions he posed to a transgender patient, as well as condemning people who are transgender. – Facebook pic, January 20, 2021

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – A Malaysian doctor practising in Australia drew flak after condemning a patient for being a transgender man on social media.

Dr Shaiful Aizad, former president of the Australian branch of Ikatan Muslimin Malaysia had initially thought of his patient as a man but was later baffled when the CT scan showed that the patient had a uterus.

Only then did he realise that the patient is a transgender man.

“I never expected to face a case like this. On the outside, he really looks like a man, even his voice, appearance and body hair.

“What is so wrong with being a woman?” asked Dr Shaiful in his Facebook post, which has since been deleted.

He went on to ask if having monthly periods was the cause of him (the patient) wanting to become a man.

“Before this, such issues were classified as mental conditions. Now it is their own choice. Doctors can be detained for trying to revert them or diagnosing them with other mental illnesses,” he said.

He also said that he had met female patients with extra testosterone in their bodies, but they had never declared their intentions to become men.

Other questions posed by Dr Shaiful included those of personal nature, about the patient’s marital status, work, relationships, before finally ending with: “What made you decide to become a man?”

The patient apparently replied that he had always wanted to be a man, causing the doctor to feel “weird”.

“If people wanted to live without religion, or choose not to follow a religion, this is what happens. They choose to defy logic as they wish,” said Dr Shaiful.

The post had garnered 375 reactions, 394 comments and 82 shares.

He deleted the post not too long after he uploaded it as a result of netizens slamming his remarks and calling for the Australian Medical Association to revoke his licence. 

He said the decision to delete his post was to avoid debates.

Attempts by The Vibes to contact the doctor is ongoing.

Inadvertently, Malaysia is once again in the limelight for attacking the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community.

Yesterday, Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Ahmad Marzuk Shaary said the government was mulling harsher laws against LGBT folk.

This included amending the Shariah Courts (Criminal Jurisdiction) Act 1965, or Act 355, to provide for harsher punishments for the LGBT community. – The Vibes, January 20, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 5mth

LGBT should be called ‘deviant culture’ to avoid normalisation, says deputy minister

Malaysia / 6mth

Selangor Sultan orders firm action on LGBT events

Malaysia / 1y

Cops: Raid on alleged LGBT gathering was done after due intelligence work

Malaysia / 2y

Activist lodges report over alleged lewd shows in Penang

Malaysia / 2y

Group calls for halt to Johor govt’s plans for LGBT rehab centre

Malaysia / 2y

Ahmadi pro-LGBT rally: cops submit investigation papers to AGC

Spotlight

Malaysia

Rais Yatim’s political journey: From Umno rising star to royal controversy

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Special Dewan Rakyat sitting on Tabung Haji RCI set for Aug 11

Malaysia

Play chess, not checkers: Why Negeri Sembilan matters

By Vinod Sekhar

Malaysia

CAP questions vape policy as health costs reach RM369 million

Malaysia

MP urges Indian community to accept PM Anwar’s sincere apology

By Ian McIntyre

World

Former ICC prosecutor defends Khan over Gaza war crimes case

Malaysia

Newborn baby found in toilet bowl, college students arrested

Malaysia

Fake police officer scam leaves Tangkak woman RM170,000 poorer

Malaysia

Negeri Sembilan ruler revokes Rais Yatim’s state honours

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

TH RCI speaks for itself: 'I'm not accusing anyone, don't challenge me' - Anwar

Malaysia

Mother: ‘The lives of my kids matter more than any VIP’

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

PRNNS: Johor sends 318 police personnel to reinforce security for Negeri polls

Malaysia

RCI: TH paid high staff bonuses despite financial strain, report finds

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

TH cases referred to MACC but no charges filed, RCI report reveals

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Govt rolls out targeted SDG programme across 13 districts with Batu Pahat as national pilot site

Malaysia

Tok Mat calls for return to 'Malay leadership' model to safeguard stability, economic growth

Malaysia

Man pleads not guilty to drug-impaired driving charges over crash that killed family of three