Malaysia

‘Unconstitutional to bar people from their homes over swab tests’

Minister urged to clarify rule on management given the right to make Covid-19 screening mandatory before entry

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 29 Jan 2021 1:29PM

‘Unconstitutional to bar people from their homes over swab tests’
Article 13 of the federal constitution stipulates that all citizens have a right to their homes and that no person shall be deprived of property save in accordance with the law, and no law shall provide for the compulsory acquisition or use of property without adequate compensation. – The Vibes file pic, January 29, 2021

by Rachel Yeoh

GEORGE TOWN – Senior Minister (Security) Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob needs to clarify his recent announcement that the management of condominium and residential complexes have the right to make Covid-19 tests mandatory.

State Housing, Town Planning and Local Government Committee chairman Jagdeep Singh Deo said that this is because such a requirement infringes on the people's right to access their own properties.

Article 13 of the federal constitution stipulates that all citizens have a right to their homes. 

It further states that no person shall be deprived of property save in accordance with the law, and no law shall provide for the compulsory acquisition or use of property without adequate compensation.

“I want this minister to please give an explanation. We will give him a chance. Now, only foreign workers are required to do the Covid-19 screening. 

“If what he announced yesterday only concerns foreign workers, I have no qualms about it. It is fine because it is a requirement for now that all foreign workers be screened.

“If it includes locals, then we need an explanation as it is not compulsory for Malaysians to do the Covid-19 screening,” he told the media via Facebook Live.

He also said if people are refrained from going into their houses, the management needs to conduct a general meeting for people to agree on the housing rules. 

“Even if (management) wants to call for an annual general meeting, it can’t because of the movement control order (MCO).

“(Ismail Sabri) needs to know that the places that are under MCO right now have a lot of residential complexes.

“What puzzles me the most is that, in May last year, Ismail Sabri stated that the management of condominiums and apartments cannot take the law into their own hands by denying entry to residents. 

“Therefore, the whole country needs clarification from him.”

Jagdeep also urged the federal government to consider providing aid for Covid-19 screening tests if it is true that locals need to show their swab test results. 

This is because many urban folk live in high-density, low- and medium-cost flats, and cannot afford to pay for the screening.

Meanwhile, another lawyer is also protesting against the minister’s statement, saying it is discriminatory.

Human rights advocate K. Sudhagaran Stanley Singh told The Vibes that the announcement has caused confusion among high-rise residents.

“If we are barred from entering our own homes, where are we going to stay? The entire country is in lockdown under the MCO. Hotels are not supposed to operate.” – The Vibes, January 29, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Penang CM defends move by housing board, says enforcement is last resort

Business / 1mth

Property developer, Matrix Concepts sets RM1.8b FY2027 sales target

Malaysia / 1mth

Lawyers’ breach of trust cases cause RM192m losses since 2023

Malaysia / 2mth

MACC: No one off limits in probe into US$13 million luxury property deal

Malaysia / 2mth

Young voters could decide Johor election outcome as parties battle for new electorate

Malaysia / 3mth

PH launches 'Johor For All' manifesto, focuses on jobs, housing and people's well-being

Spotlight

Malaysia

Do not hide school safety issues to protect reputation - IGP

World

Flydubai pilot planned to crash plane into terminal at Ben Gurion Airport

Malaysia

Sabah Pan Borneo Highway: Only 4 of 35 packages complete after a decade

Malaysia

School caning was never abolished, Minster says

Malaysia

Sepang draws record crowd as Bahrain GP puts Malaysia back on F1 map

Malaysia

Irene Sofiya died from blunt-force head injuries, post-mortem confirms

Malaysia

No CCTV at spot where Irene was killed, says Minister

Malaysia

Irene’s only focus was her studies and her dream to become a doctor - aunt

You may be interested

Malaysia

School caning was never abolished, Minster says

Malaysia

Fuel subsidy spending plunges as targeted welfare aid surges in 2025

Malaysia

Unhealthy air spreads to eight areas as haze worsens

Malaysia

Malaysia prepares for aged nation status by 2036

Malaysia

Moderate magnitude-5.8 earthquake strikes north Sumatera

Malaysia

Loneliness, social media drive elderly pensions into hands of cyber scammers

Malaysia

Malaysia must navigate global tensions to protect trade, supply chains, says Anwar

Malaysia

PPIM warns public against widespread Telegram sex syndicates operating blackmail scams