Malaysia

Couple haul Facebook to court to reveal Instagram account holders’ identities

Duo say they need info for defamation suit concerning kidnapping, abuse allegations

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 11 Mar 2021 7:00AM

Couple haul Facebook to court to reveal Instagram account holders’ identities
Retiree Mariani Saad says she and her husband, Abu Jamal Sulaiman, need the identities of certain persons behind eight Instagram accounts to undertake legal proceedings against them. – Pixabay pic, March 11, 2021

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – A Malaysian couple has named Facebook in a court action filed at the Kuala Lumpur High Court to determine the real identities of individual(s) behind eight Instagram accounts.

It is understood that retiree Mariani Saad, who was a civil servant for 29 years, and her husband, Abu Jamal Sulaiman, need the identities of those behind the accounts to undertake legal proceedings against them.

Facebook currently owns Instagram.

They initiated the action on January 9 last year following allegations made in the Instagram accounts that they had kidnapped an underprivileged teen named Muhammad Aisy Aakiff and abused their own children.

Based on an affidavit signed by Mariani sometime around 2015, Aisy, who was then 15, and his friends had helped Abu Jamal with some catering activities under a work-while-studying programme.

He had done so with the permission of his principal at the Serendah Vocational School (PPKKS).

He then developed a good relationship with Mariani and Abu Jamal, and considered them his parents.

Retiree Mariani Saad says she and her husband intend to get information of the account users from Facebook to initiate a defamation suit against those making false claims about them. – Facebook screen grab, March 11, 2021
Retiree Mariani Saad says she and her husband intend to get information of the account users from Facebook to initiate a defamation suit against those making false claims about them. – Facebook screen grab, March 11, 2021

“Based on that reason, Aisy stayed in our house at times when he did not have class with the permission of the school principal,” Mariani said in the affidavit.

Aisy had then informed the couple that he had a good relationship with Syahril Azwan, a staff member of the Welfare Department. However, according to Mariani, Aisy later ran away from Syahril.

In 2018, Aisy went to the couple’s home before the release of his Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia results and asked if he could live with them.

Mariani said that she was then informed by someone, believed to be from the National Welfare Foundation, that she and Abu Jamal had been accused by Syahril and a man by the name of Ustaz Izudin of hiding Aisy from the school. She said that this allegation is false.

The couple said they also received a call from a police officer who said a police report had been lodged against them for kidnapping Aisy.

Aisy, however, explained to the police his version of events and some disturbances, allegedly by Syahril, stopped temporarily, she said.

Months later, however, disturbances resurfaced in the form of Instagram posts and poison pen letters, including statements that the couple had kidnapped Aisy and used him as a male prostitute.

One of the poison pen letters eventually reached the police. This led to the police raiding the couple’s home to investigate whether their children had been raped or endured sexual and physical abuse.

A few other Instagram accounts also appeared with allegedly defamatory posts against the couple, stating that they practised black magic to kidnap children.

Mariani said that she and Abu Jamal have been married for 33 years and were not able to produce their own children. They adopted eight children, six of whom are now successful graduates while two are still in school.

The couple intends to get information of the account users from Facebook to initiate a defamation suit against the alleged perpetrators.

Last September, Facebook filed a notice stating its intention to appeal certain technical matters involving the case to the Court of Appeal.

On February 17, 2021, the high court ordered a stay in proceedings pending determination of the technical matters by the Court of Appeal. – The Vibes, March 11, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 2w

Defamation is a rich man’s game

Malaysia / 4w

CPJ calls for withdrawal of excessive RM100m defamation suit against veteran journalist

Malaysia / 1mth

Is reputation worth so much more than a person’s life?

Malaysia / 5mth

Najib, Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad reach amicable settlement over RM5m defamation suit

Malaysia / 5mth

Defamation suit against Najib not meant to destroy him politically - Dzulkefly

Malaysia / 6mth

Guan Eng wins defamation suit against Zuraida, two others

Spotlight

Malaysia

Jokes that hit below the belt: In the race for Malay votes, how far is UMNO willing to go?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

UMNO man says he’s prepared to apologise over ‘joke’

Malaysia

Loke proposes PH presidential council meet on ‘latest political developments’

Malaysia

Sabah leaders condemn priest and nun joke at UMNO PAU

Malaysia

DKU affirms that Tuanku Muhriz is the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan

Business

Budget 2027 nears final stage with high-impact sectors in focus

Health

Respiratory disease ranks among Malaysia’s top three health burdens

Malaysia

High Court acquits student in Bandar Utama murder case on schizophrenia finding

Malaysia

PAS rejects UMNO call to test political ties through SG4 polls

You may be interested

Malaysia

Share economic benefits equitably, reduce toxic politics of race and religion, says Guan Eng

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Tun Faisal concedes Zahid may have been right about PAS

Malaysia

Businesswoman loses RM315,963 in fake projector tender scam

Malaysia

Jokes that hit below the belt: In the race for Malay votes, how far is UMNO willing to go?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Illegal action did not mean malice, court rules in Shafee case

Malaysia

Police looking for man who kicked child in viral video (video)

Malaysia

Long Lellang crash: Police probe BO-105’s final flight, refuelling stop after fatal crash

Malaysia

UMNO man says he’s prepared to apologise over ‘joke’