Malaysia

After inaccurate results, MMA calls for audit of Covid-19 test kits

Not all 17 RTK-Ag kits in the market of acceptable quality, while some have failed to detect positive cases, says president

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 18 May 2021 3:53PM

After inaccurate results, MMA calls for audit of Covid-19 test kits
The Health Ministry says RTK-Ag tests can produce false or negative results 10% of the time, owing to its sensitivity level of 90%. – The Vibes file pic, May 18, 2021

by A. Azim Idris

KUALA LUMPUR – The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) is urging the government to conduct an immediate audit on the quality of Covid-19 test kits, following complaints raised by several practitioners on their efficacy.
 
MMA president Prof Datuk Dr Subramaniam Muniandy questioned the quality of some of the Antigen Rapid Test Kit (RTK-Ag) swabs available in the market.
 
Currently, 17 RTK-Ag kits have been approved by the Medical Device Authority (MDA), although not all “have been of acceptable quality”.
 
“Some of these kits have failed in detecting positive cases,” Dr Subramaniam said in a statement.
 
“We are deeply concerned as false negatives in test results can also lead to further spread of Covid-19 in the community.”
 
The RTK-Ag test kits cost less than the more elaborate reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) screenings, and its results can be obtained almost immediately.
 
However, in July last year, the Health Ministry said RTK-Ag tests could produce false or negative results 10% of the time, owing to its sensitivity level of 90%.
 
Dr Subramaniam said under the current standard operating procedures for testing, those who receive a positive test result via RTK-Ag screening will require an RT-PCR test to confirm the diagnosis.

MMA president Prof Datuk Dr Subramaniam Muniandy says false negatives in test results can lead to further spread of Covid-19 in the community. – Bernama pic, May 18, 2021
MMA president Prof Datuk Dr Subramaniam Muniandy says false negatives in test results can lead to further spread of Covid-19 in the community. – Bernama pic, May 18, 2021

“The practitioners are concerned that, with many kits available now, are regular audits being carried out once the kits are approved and released into the market?
 
“The quality of RTK-Ag kits is paramount for the practitioner to pick up positive cases,” he said.
 
“RTK-Ag kits are an important tool in the fight against Covid-19. 
 
“It is a fast and effective method of screening to detect Covid-19 infections. 
 
“The quicker the infection is detected, the quicker we can isolate the positive case and prevent further spread of Covid-19.”
 
Dr Subramaniam also highlighted concern over the efficacy of RTK-Ag kits to detect new variants of the virus.
 
He said updates are needed as there are reports of the variants spreading across the country.
 
Dr Subramaniam urged the Health Ministry, through the MDA, to conduct an audit followed by regular audits on all test kits available in the market.
 
The ministry, he added, must also provide an online platform for medical practitioners to file complaints on issues encountered with any test kits.
 
“Aside from this, MMA is also concerned over the lack of transparency on the approval process of the saliva test kits,” he said.
 
“We hope there are no middlemen taking advantage of the Covid-19 situation through commercialisation of the test kits or monopoly of the market.” – The Vibes, May 18, 2021

Related News

World / 2mth

Trump's health: Weighs 108kg, heart age 14 years younger, hands bruised from frequent handshakes – Doctor

Malaysia / 2mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Malaysia / 3mth

Over 70 per cent of GPs struggling to remain open - MMA

Malaysia / 3mth

Government’s RM5.7 billion spending cut a bold move to curb waste, says PKR leader

Malaysia / 3mth

Funding cutbacks may jeopardise public health, education, safety and crime prevention needs – Guan Eng

Community / 5mth

Only 6 months after cleaning, senior citizens' 'treasures' pile up again

Spotlight

Malaysia

Private university CFO charged over alleged RM6.56m CBT

World

Unleashed 60kg dog in Hong Kong mauls poodle, bichon frise to death (video)

Malaysia

Three family members killed after Immigration truck runs red light

Malaysia

Woman, believed to be foreigner, allegedly causes disturbance at KLIA (video)

Opinion

Has DAP chosen the path to a slow death?

Malaysia

Three years of bullying at school puts 15-year-old at risk of hearing loss

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Police officer's wife cries, pleads for leniency after misusing disabled child's account

Malaysia

Organised cybergroups likely behind rise in racial hate on social media

You may be interested

Malaysia

Woman, believed to be foreigner, allegedly causes disturbance at KLIA (video)

Malaysia

Mother’s use of anxiety medication during pregnancy caused baby to test positive for drugs

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

MACC probe into Dr Xavier Jayakumar closed in 2024 over lack of evidence

Malaysia

AUKU repeal to focus on universities, not students, says Fahmi

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Man, woman claim trial to animal cruelty against dog named Rocky (Updated)

Malaysia

Immigration's 'Black Maria' driver charged with causing death of three family members

Malaysia

Singaporean man charged with obstructing police, possessing weapon (video)

Malaysia

Elephant footprints spark fear among Felda Chalok Rahmat residents