Malaysia

‘Special grant raise for Sabah far less than constitutional formula’

Interpretation of 40% formula lies with Federal Court, not assessor, says Pakatan Harapan

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 21 Apr 2022 8:18PM

‘Special grant raise for Sabah far less than constitutional formula’
Sabah Pakatan Harapan says that the responsibility to interpret the constitution lies with the Federal Court, not with an independent assessor. – The Vibes file pic, April 21, 2022

KOTA KINABALU – Sabah Pakatan Harapan (PH) leaders have taken the state government to task for not insisting on the 40% revenue entitlement for the state before agreeing on a review of the matter with Putrajaya.

They said the review is questionable given that it disregards the 40% revenue-sharing formula as stated in Article 112C of the federal constitution and Subsection 2(1) of Part IV of the Tenth schedule.

Subsection 2(1) specifies the amount of the special grant that Sabah is entitled to, being two-fifths (40%) of the revenue that the federal government collects from the state. 

In a statement, Sabah PH questioned the basis on which the state government agreed to the 4.7-fold increment made on the special grant for this year. 

They noted that the state and federal governments have stated that Sabah is due to receive RM125.6 million in the form of a special grant beginning this year.

Previously the amount was RM26.7 million, an amount originally intended for 1973. 

“Clearly, the agreement to increase the special grant by multiplication of 3.7 is not premised on the 40% formula,” the PH leaders said in a joint statement.

The statement was signed by Sabah PKR chief Datuk Christina Liew, Upko president Datuk Seri Wilfred Madius Tangau, Sabah DAP chief Datuk Frankie Poon Ming Fung, and Sabah Amanah chief Lahirul Latigu.

“Since this is so, does that mean the state government has agreed to set a new precedent for future reviews to the detriment of Sabah?” they asked. 

“The move can be seen as conceding to any review under Article 112D of the federal constitution while disregarding the 40% formula. 

They said that the state government should have insisted on the 40% entitlement before agreeing to any review, and the federal government must respect the applicability and acknowledge the rights to the 40%.

“If the 40% formula remains a stumbling block in talks between the federal and state governments, then the responsibility to interpret the constitution lies with the Federal Court, not with an independent assessor, as stated under article 112D (6).”

The Sabah government has welcomed the higher special grant, but maintains it will continue to pursue the 40% revenue entitlement. – The Vibes, April 21, 2022 

Related News

Malaysia / 1d

Sabah and Sarawak can become 'kingmakers', determine who will lead Federal government

Malaysia / 2d

Warisan keeps Sabah pact talks open, pushes for local parties to contest 25 seats

Malaysia / 3w

Sabah does not agree to 200-litre diesel quota, forms special committee - Masidi

Malaysia / 2mth

Tsunami alert: Stay calm and obey instructions from the authorities – Hajiji (video)

Malaysia / 2mth

Sabah embarks on five-year initiative to document multiethnic heritage - Hajiji

Malaysia / 2mth

Anwar - Sabah's special grant interim payment increased from RM600m to RM1.5b

Spotlight

Malaysia

Sarawak schools told to halt outdoor activities as haze pushes air quality into unhealthy range

World

Indonesia haze forces schools to close as wildfires intensify amid severe dry season

Malaysia

PN walkout over Tabung Haji debate a political misstep, says analyst

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

51 witnesses to testify at inquest into death of 10-year-old boy found unconscious in school toilet

Malaysia

Female student arrested for allegedly hurting classmate with kerambit at school

World

Colombia quake death toll hits 111 as rescue teams race to find survivors

World

Trump secretly switched to third aircraft in Türkiye over Iran assassination threat

Malaysia

Anwar questions PN’s priorities after Tabung Haji RCI walkout

Malaysia

MACC, police probing TH after RCI findings as govt warns no one will be spared

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Penang: Good progress seen in two major projects in the state

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Man, 49, found dead in Banting plantation

Malaysia

Malaysian held in Chennai after 4kg of high-grade hydroponic cannabis seized

Malaysia

Selangor yet to finalise funding for RM3 billion Shah Alam Stadium redevelopment

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Sabah and Sarawak can become 'kingmakers', determine who will lead Federal government

Malaysia

Police investigate case of knife-wielding woman who damaged vehicle (video)

Malaysia

TH faced risk of RM74.5 billion liability exposure before bailout, Dewan told

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

US$620 million returned, not to Najib's account - Angela